Loading...
20130604 Regular City Council Meeting - MinutesMINUTES OF THE SPECIAL AND REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF THE CITY OF VERNON HELD TUESDAY, JUNE 4, 2013, IN THE COUNCIL CHAMBER OF THE CITY HALL LOCATED AT 4305 SANTA FE AVENUE, VERNON, CALIFORNIA MEMBERS PRESENT: McCormick, Davis, Maisano, Ybarra, Martinez MEMBERS ABSENT: None The Special meeting of the City Council was called to order at 7:30 a.m. by Mayor McCormick. PUBLIC COMMENT Interim City Clerk Dana Reed announced that this was the time allotted for public comment on the Special meeting portion of the Agenda, the Budget Study Session only. Mayor McCormick inquired whether anyone in the audience wished to address the City Council. No one responded. BUDGET STUDY SESSION 1. Budget review for City Council Department, City Administration Department, City Clerk Department, Human Resources Department, Community Services and Water Department, Industrial Development and Community Promotion. City staff conducted a public workshop on the review of the proposed budget for said Departments. At 9:00 a.m., it was moved by Maisano and seconded by Ybarra to adjourn the Special Meeting of the City Council. A short recess was declared, the Regular City Council is to begin at 9:10 a.m. The Regular meeting of the City Council was called to order at 9:10 a.m. by Mayor McCormick who led the flag salute. CHANGES TO THE AGENDA Interim City Clerk Dana Reed announced that the Successor Agency to the Redevelopment Agency, the Public Benefits Resource Committee and the Board of Library Trustees meetings will be heard before the Closed Session of the City Council meeting, as it is anticipated that the Closed Session matter will be long in nature. PUBLIC COMMENT Interim City Clerk Dana Reed announced that this was the time allotted for public comment. Mayor McCormick inquired whether anyone in the audience wished to address the City Council. Marisa Olguin, President of the Vernon Chamber of Commerce, advised that the City Council member's compensation has been agendized multiple times but has been deferred. She explained that one of the concerns in Sacramento was that Vernon's City Council is compensated at a much higher rate in comparison to other Councilmembers. Special and Regular City Council Meeting Minutes June 4, 2013 In May 2011, the City approved a resolution to reduce the salary compensation to be effective at the end of the current term. Independent Reform Monitor John Van de Kamp keeps referring to the inequality. Olguin advised that the Council needs to reevaluate the issue. Confirmation from the Fair Political Practices Commission has been received that there is no conflict of interest. Olguin opined that legislators would not be pleased to find that there is inequality in compensation among the Councilmembers. She urged the Council to address the issue. CONSENT CALENDAR It was moved by Davis and seconded by Martinez to approve the matters listed on the Consent Calendar as recommended. Motion carried, 5-0. Claims Against the City (to be received and filed) 1. None received Minutes Approval 2. Minutes of the Special and Regular City Council Meeting held May 21, 2013, to be received and filed. Warrant Registers 3. Ratification of City Warrant Register No. 1367 to record voided Check No. 339067 in the amount of $15.00. 4. Ratification of Light and Power Warrant Register No. 344 to record voided Check No. 510059 in the amount of $200.00. 5. Approval of City Warrant Register No. 1380, totaling $774,211.99, which covers the period of May 14, through May 27, 2013, and consists of the following: a. Ratification of wire transfers totaling $585,782.27; and b. Ratification of the issuance of early checks totaling $67,061.63; and c. Authorization to issue pending checks totaling $121,368.09. 6. Approval of Light & Power Warrant Register No. 345, totaling $1,520,841.57, which covers the period of May 14, through May 27, 2013, and consists of the following: a. Ratification of wire transfers totaling $1,507,337.48; and b. Ratification of the issuance of early checks totaling $2,635.10; and c. Authorization to issue pending checks totaling $10,868.99. 7. Approval of Gas Warrant Register No. 133, totaling $24,977,82, which covers the period of May 14, through May 27, 2013, and consists of the following: Page 2 of 12 Special and Regular City Council Meeting Minutes June 4, 2013 a. Ratification of the issuance of early checks totaling $7,982.31; and b. Authorization to issue pending checks totaling $16,995.51. 8. Approval of Federal Funds Street Improvements Warrant Register No. 17, totaling $57,134.66, which covers the period of September 25, 2012, through May 27, 2013, for the ratification of wire transfers. Community Services and Water Department 9. On May 7, 2013, the City Council adopted Ordinance 1207 to impose a 45 day moratorium on the establishment of new private electricity generating facilities. Consistent with the requirements of Government Code Section 65858, Ordinance 1207 directed the Director of Community Services and Water to create a report describing the measures taken to alleviate the conditions that led to the adoption of Ordinance No. 1207. It is recommended that the Council receive and file the report. No action is required. 10. Approval of Amendment No. 1 extending the existing Services Agreement for Engineering Design and Support Services for Well 21 between the City of Vernon and Cannon Corporation for a period of one year. Recommendation: (1) Find Amendment No. 1 extending the existing Services Agreement for Engineering Design and Construction Support Services for Well 21 with Cannon Corporation, is exempt under the California Environmental Quality Act ("CEQA") in accordance with Section 15061(b)(3), the general rule that CEQA only applies to projects that may have an effect on the environment; and (2) Authorize the City Administrator to enter into Amendment No. 1, extending the existing Services Agreement for Engineering Design and Construction Support Services for Well 21 with Cannon Corporation. The Services Agreement will be made effective June 4, 2013, and terminate upon completion of the project, or June 3, 2014, which ever date occurs first. The amendment will be in a not to exceed amount of $46,311.46. 11. Alameda Street Repair at Union Pacific Railroad ("UPRR") Rail Crossing (Fed Xing ID 747585T) (CPUC No. 001BG- 485.96-C) - Section 130 Grade Crossing Improvement Program Caltrans Service Contract No. 75LX230 - Federal Aid Project No. STPLR-7500(207). Recommendation: (1) Find that the proposed Section 130 Grade Crossing Improvement Program is exempt under the California Environmental Quality Act ("CEQA") in accordance with Section 15301, Existing Facilities, part (c), existing highways and streets, because the project is merely to repair existing streets; and (2) Authorize the City Administrator to enter into a Section 130 Grade Crossing Improvement Program Service Contract with the State of California, Department of Transportation ("Caltrans") to reimburse the City for Page 3 of 12 Special and Regular City Council Meeting Minutes June 4, 2013 the design and construction for the street improvements at the UPRR crossing on Alameda Street south of 37th Street. 12. Downey Road Sidewalk Repair at Union Pacific Railroad ("UPRR") Rail Crossing (Fed Xing ID 810942N) (CPUC No. 003A-4.67-C) - Section 130 Grade Crossing Improvement Program - Caltrans Service Contract No. 75LX228 - Federal Aid Project No. STPLR-7500(206). Recommendation: (1) Find the proposed Section 130 Grade Crossing Improvement Program is exempt under the California Environmental Quality Act ("CEQA") in accordance with Section 15301, Existing Facilities, part (c), existing highways and streets, because the project is merely to repair existing streets; and (2) Authorize the City Administrator to enter into a Section 130 Grade Crossing Improvement Program Service Contract with the State of California, Department of Transportation ("Caltrans") to reimburse the City for the design and construction for the street improvements at the UPRR crossing on Downey Road north of Slauson Avenue. Fire Department 13. Activity Report for the period of May 1, through May 15, 2013, to be received and filed. Police Department 14. Activity Log and Statistical Summary of Arrest and Activities for the period of May 1, through May 15, 2013, to be received and filed. NEW BUSINESS Community Services and Water Department 1. Resolution No. 2013-53 - A Resolution of the City Council of the City of Vernon Authorizing the Execution of a Memorandum of Understanding between the Los Angeles Gateway Regional Water Management Joint Powers Authority and the Cities of Bell, Bell Gardens, Commerce, Cudahy, Huntington Park, Maywood, Vernon and the Los Angeles County Flood Control District for Administration and Cost Sharing relating to a Watershed Management Program and Coordinated Integrated Monitoring Program. Recommendation: (1) Find that the proposed Memorandum of Understanding ("MOU") between the Los Angeles Gateway Regional Water Management Joint Powers Authority ("GWMA") and the Cities of Bell, Bell Gardens, Commerce, Cudahy, Huntington Park, Maywood, Vernon and the Los Angeles Flood Control District ("Watershed Permittees") is exempt under the California Environmental Quality Act ("CEQA") in accordance with Section 15061(b)(3), the general rule that CEQA only applies to projects that may have an effect on the environment; and Page 4 of 12 Special and Regular City Council Meeting Minutes June 4, 2013 (2) Authorize the City Administrator to enter into the proposed MOU between GWMA and the Watershed Permittees for administration and cost sharing to prepare a Watershed Management Program ("WMP") Plan and Coordinated Integrated Monitoring Program ("CIMP") Plan as required by the Regional Water Quality Control Board, Los Angeles Region ("RWQCB"), National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System ("NPDES") Municipal Separate Storm Sewer System ("MS4") Permit Order No. R4-2012-0175 ("Permit"). The City of Vernon's estimated cost share for the WMP Plan and CIMP Plan is $135,000. The term of the MOU is through July 1, 2023; however, the WMP and CIMP Plans are due by June 28, 2014, to the RWQCB; and (3) Authorize the Director of Community Services and Water to execute the Notice of Intent ("NOI") as required by the RWQCB NPDES MS4 Permit. The purpose of the NOI is to notify the RWQCB of the Watershed Permittees' intent to develop a WMP Plan and CIMP Plan for the Los Angeles River Upper Reach 2 Sub Watershed area. The NOI is due to the RWQCB by June 28, 2013. Director of Community Services and Water Kevin Wilson recalled that he had previously reported on the requirement to develop a Watershed Management Program and Coordinated Integrated Monitoring Program plans to meet the criterion set forth by the National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System ("NPDES") Municipal Separate Storm Sewer System ("MS4") Permit. The City has grouped with neighboring communities, as this will allow for cost savings. Wilson explained the cost allocation formula; 50o is divided evenly among the participants, the rest is broken down proportional to the size of the community. Wilson noted that this is more advantages to Vernon than other similar formulas. Vernon's cost is approximately $135,000; however if a participant should drop out, the cost allocated to Vernon will increase. This is not anticipated. It was moved by Ybarra and seconded by Maisano to approve Resolution No. 2013-53. Motion carried, 5-0. 2. Contract No. CS-0338: City Hall Building Chiller Replacement - Acceptance of Work. Recommendation: (1) Affirm that accepting the work of Complete Thermal Services, Inc. ("Complete Thermal"), on the City Hall Building Chiller Replacement Project, Contract No. CS- 0338, is exempt under the California Environmental Quality Act ("CEQA") in accordance with Title 14, Chapter 3, Class 1, Section 15301, and in accordance with Section 15061(b)(3) because the project consisted of the repair of an existing mechanical piece of equipment involving no expansion of use beyond that existing at time of the lead agency's determination; and (2) Accept the work by Complete Thermal as part of the City Hall Building Chiller Replacement Project, Contract No. CS-0338. Page 5 of 12 Special and Regular City Council Meeting Minutes June 4, 2013 Director of Community Services and Water Kevin Wilson reported that the Chiller unit has been replaced, and is operational. The unit has a five year warranty. He recommends acceptance of the work and issuance of the final payment. It was moved by Davis and seconded by Martinez to accept the work by Complete Thermal as part of City Hall Building Chiller Replacement Project, Contract No. CS-0338. Motion carried, 5-0. OLD BUSINESS City Administration Department 1. One-year Consulting Services Agreement with Mercury Public Affairs for strategic consulting and management services on City of Vernon government relations, issues management, renewable energy projects, and retention and expansion of utility customer base. Recommendation: (1) Find that approval of the proposed agreement is exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act ("CEQA") in accordance with Section 15061(b)(3), the general rule that CEQA only applies to projects that may have an effect on the environment; and (2) Authorize the City Administrator to enter into a consulting service agreement with Mercury Public Affairs, in substantially the same form presented, for a term of one year, June 1, 2013 through May 31, 2014, at a not to exceed cost of $200,000, for strategic consulting and management services on the City of Vernon government relations, issue management, renewable energy projects, and retention and expansion of utility customer base. Competitive bidding is not required for this professional service contract pursuant to Section 2.17.12(A)(10) of the Vernon Municipal Code. It is requested that the City Council grant an exemption from the competitive selection process, pursuant to Section 2.17.12(B)(2) of the Vernon Municipal Code, based upon a determination that the best interests of the City are served by a direct award of the contract without a competitive selection process, for the reasons set forth in the staff report. City Administrator Mark Whitworth reported on Mercury Public Affairs' expertise. They are familiar with the community and assisted with the success of the AB46 defeat. They will be a valuable asset for Vernon going forward. Whitworth noted that the contract includes the services of former Speaker Fabian Nunez. Additionally, the costs for services have been reduced to $200,000 from the previous recommendation. It was moved by Davis and seconded by Maisano to approve the Consulting Services Agreement with Mercury Public Affairs. Motion carried, 5-0. 2. Request from Mayor Pro-Tem Davis to discuss the compensation of the City Council members. (This matter had been continued from prior meetings pending advice requested of the Fair Political Practices Commission Page 6 of 12 Special and Regular City Council Meeting Minutes June 4, 2013 ("FPPC"), by Mayor Michael McCormick, which has now been provided by FPPC letter, dated April 29, 2013.) Mayor McCormick moved to table the item. Hearing no second, Interim City Clerk Dana Reed declared that the motion dies due to a lack of a second. Mayor Pro-Tem Davis reported on conversations with other cities' councilmembers and their inquiry on why there was a difference in salaries among the Vernon Councilmembers. The same has been questioned by the Vernon businesses and residents. Independent Reform Monitor John Van de Kamp has recommended the same rate for all the members. Davis questioned why the salary rates should be different when all the Councilmembers share the same responsibilities. Davis recalled that the City Council adopted Resolution No. 2011-87 reducing the Councilmembers' salaries to $24,996 at the completion of their current term. However, the City of Vernon is now facing a financial deficit. He recommended amending the resolution to reduce the salaries effective immediately. Davis formally motioned to direct staff to prepare a resolution to amend Resolution No. 2011-87 to equalize the Councilmembers' salaries at the reduced rate to be effective immediately. It was seconded by Ybarra. Motion carried, 5-0. ORAL REPORTS Police Chief Daniel Calleros reported on an armed robbery that occurred on May 24, 2011, in the 4700 block of 26th Street. The suspect fled the scene in an awaiting vehicle; there are few leads in the case. Calleros reported that there have been 3 diesel fuel thefts during the last three weeks. Video footage is being used and Detectives are aggressively working on leads. This is an ongoing issue in the Los Angeles area. On June 2, 2013, officers responded to a burglary investigation on 49th Street as two suspects were removing copper wire from a vacant building. Calleros noted that it was the same building that had a recent fire. Officers requested support from local agencies and located one suspect. The second suspect was not located. Based on evidence and statements made by the suspect, he was arrested for suspicion of commercial burglary. The suspect's vehicle was impounded for investigation given the numbers of items found in the vehicle. On June 2, 2013, City staff reported a break-in of three storage containers located at the City Recycle storage yard. Detectives will be examining the evidence found in the aforementioned suspect's vehicle as the two incidents may be linked. An inventory of the containers will be performed to identify missing items, if any. The Police Department is working on an online reporting system. This will not only make it convenient for the public to file reports online, but will also allocate patrol and detective resources to better meet the needs of the community. The system will interface the records management system eliminating the Page 7 of 12 Special and Regular City Council Meeting Minutes June 4, 2013 need for records staff to re -type the report data. Calleros anticipates having the system available on the Police Department's webpage within the next few months. The project is being funded through grant funds. Calleros reported on the anticipated promotion of one sergeant and one captain. In addition to hiring a Records Technician on June 3rd, two additional staff positions are critical given that there was only one person working in the Records Division as a result of the retirements that occurred in January. This will bring staffing levels up to a satisfactory level. Lieutenant Jerry Winegar reported vandalism on June 3, 2013, at a commercial building on 27th Street. The incident resulted in the arrest of four adults and one juvenile. One of the suspects assaulted an officer during the arrest and will be charged with assault on a police officer. Councilmember Ybarra reported that he has seen an increase in graffiti on sidewalks. He will provide a list of the locations to staff. Mayor McCormick reported vandalism on Boyle Avenue and Randolph Avenue, and in front of Greenwich Village Cafe. In response to Mayor McCormick, Winegar advised that City staff does not paint over a company's sign but would discuss it with staff and or the company. Fire Chief Michael Wilson reported on the Engineers' Practical Exam scheduled for June 22, 2013. One personnel will be promoted from this list as the previous list has been exhausted. Retesting for a new list will be conducted in two years. On June 5, 2013, first graders from the Vernon Elementary School will be visiting Fire Station No. 2. Staff will educate the students on fire survival techniques such as Stop, Drop and Roll, and emergency evacuation for the home. Hydrant Flushing will continue throughout the month of June. Wilson reported that crews raised $29,000 for the Muscular Dystrophy Association's Fill the Boot campaign. This is $2,000 more than the previous year. On June 1, 2013, the Alisa Ann Ruch Burn Foundation made their annual walk through the City and collected a donation of $500 from the Vernon Firefighters Association. Fire Department training in June will consist of the annual wild land fire training and night drills simulating commercial structure fires with an emphasis on hose lay in conjunction with raising ladders. Wilson reported on a natural gas leak on May 29, 2013 at 4317 S. Downey Road. The high pressure natural gas line was severed by a backhoe digging in the area. The gas line was determined to be a Southern California Gas ("So Cal Gas") line. So Cal Gas responded and made the necessary repairs. On May 29, 2013, Crews responded to a commercial structure fire in the City of Maywood along with the Los Angeles County Fire Department. On May 30, 2013, Crews responded to a commercial structure fire on Pacific Blvd. The roof fire had been Page 8 of 12 Special and Regular City Council Meeting Minutes June 4, 2013 partially extinguished by a contractor working on the roof. Staff checked the roof to ensure no fire had extended beyond the roof area. Lastly, on June 3, 2013, Crews responded to a structure fire at 49th Street and Santa Fe Avenue. Wilson noted that this was the same building that burned in December of 2012. The fire is currently under investigation. Independent Reform Monitor John Van de Kamp noted that on the Fire Activity Reports there was been a 30% decrease in fire prevention and other activities than in the previous year. He sought clarification. In response, City Administrator Mark Whitworth recommended that Council provide the Fire Chief time to look into the request and report back at the next meeting. Director of Community Services and Water Department Kevin Wilson regretfully reported that former City employee Victor Trujillo had passed away over the weekend. His funeral is this today. Wilson advised that further closures on Atlantic Boulevard and the 710 Freeway are anticipated. A notice from CalTrans has been received. He will be working with the Police Department on communicating the closures to the community. With the funeral services for Victor Trujillo beginning at 11:00 a.m., Interim City Clerk Dana Reed requested that Wilson and any other staff that planned on attending be excused from the meeting so that they could attend the service. Council concurred with the request. Mayor McCormick requested that the meeting be adjourned in Trujillo's honor. Electric Resources Planning and Development Manager Abraham Alemu, siting in for the Director of Light & Power, reported on a large power outage on May 26, 2013, caused by Mylar balloons. Alemu expressed that Mylar balloons are a concern to the department as they are the cause of many outages and add to costs. On May 30, 2013, a 26 minute outage was also cause by a Mylar balloon. Alemu elaborated on the container break-in previously reported by the Police Chief. It is not obvious what was taken. He clarified that the equipment stored belongs to the Community Services Department. It is believed that the break-in is related to recent copper thefts. Alemu emphasized that copper thefts and balloon related outages are real problems for the Light & Power Department. Alemu reported on potential new dark fiber customers to the fiber optic system. Staff is conducting leak inspections on the natural gas pipelines to comply with the Department of Transportation requirements. Alemu reported that electricity load consumption has increased slightly. He advised that one customer did indicate that business was picking up. He reported on the increase in power and gas prices than in previous years. Page 9 of 12 Special and Regular City Council Meeting Minutes June 4, 2013 Alemu reported that the Regular Advisory Committee on Electric Rates meeting scheduled for June 5, 2013, is canceled, but that a Special meeting was held on May 23, 2013. He summarized the informational items presented at the meeting. He noted that a notice advising customers on the commencement of the pass - through adder will be included in the next invoice. Staff is working with the owner of the Malburg Generating Station to get the plant certified and begin flowing bio-methane gas. It is anticipated that by July 1, 2013, bio-methane gas will be flown at the plant. In response to Mayor Pro-Tem Davis' inquiry on the Mylar balloon outage, Electronics Technician Don Quiroz clarified that the string to the Mylar balloon allowed for the contact and further added to the outage. Director of Finance William Fox reported on the budget public hearing scheduled for June 18, 2013. An overview of all the departments as well as adjustments will be presented. Fox announced that the external financial auditor and the financial advisor request for proposals are on the City's website. Southern California Public Power Authority ("SCPPA") members' firms were notified to ensure that specific expertise is captured in the responsive proposals. Fox reported on the business license module as part of the IT infrastructure. He advised that the module will allow electronic filing, fee calculations, and online payments. He anticipates that the module will be online by December 2012. The cost allocation and rate study are progressing. Fox will be providing an update at an upcoming meeting. Through downsizing the Purchasing Department was reduced from four to one employee. The department is in the process of hiring one employee. Over one -hundred applications were received. Interviews will be held this week. Director of Health and Environmental Control Department Leonard Grossberg reported that the Department continues to monitor the situation at Exide Technologies ("Exide"). The Air Quality Management Department ("AQMD") will be holding a workshop on June 5, 2013, at 4:00 p.m. in the Vernon Council Chambers. The Sustainable Development and Energy Efficiency Commission will be meeting on June 19, 2013. In response to Councilmember Ybarra, Grossberg advised that Exide is conducting both partial and long-term repairs, as final testing cannot be concluded until the facility is running again. The oversight is being conducted by AQMD. The Department of Toxic Substances Control has authority over the other issues. The Vernon Health and Environmental Control Department is there as a consultant. Grossberg noted that permits for repairs at Exide are being expedited by the Community Services Department. Assistant to the City Administrator Alex Kung announced the Oversight Board of the Successor Agency to the Redevelopment Agency meeting on June 6, 2013. Page 10 of 12 Special and Regular City Council Meeting Minutes June 4, 2013 Interim City Clerk Dana Reed announced that an ordinance recommending Rules of Order will be introduced at the next Council meeting. The Council will also need to appoint a delegate and alternate for the League of California Cities conference. Mayor McCormick reported that usually the Mayor and Mayor Pro- Tem are identified as the Delegate and Alternate. He directed staff to prepare a resolution to that affect for Council consideration. City Administrator Mark Whitworth revisited the issue at Exide Technologies ("Exide"). Staff attended the information meetings and is available to answer questions. Whitworth announced the Vernon Housing Commission meeting on June 12, 2013. The June lottery for the housing waitlist will be conducted at said meeting as well as the introduction of the new third party property manager, Solari Enterprises, Inc. The Commission will be revisiting the market rent implementation schedule. Whitworth reported that seven units are currently at full market rent. He noted that three of the Committee members' terms will expire in August. Notice of the open seats will be announced, incumbents are eligible for reappointment. As previously requested by Independent Reform Monitor John Van De Kamp, progress on the Community Benefit Fund will be captured by a resolution. He noted that Interim City Clerk Dana Reed has been engaged to spearhead the project. Whitworth advised that consulting services from Jemmott-Rollins Group and Rockefeller Philanthropy Advisors will be used. Whitworth reminded all that the meeting will be adjourned in memory of Victor Trujillo. Whitworth reported that Trujillo had participated in the PARS early retirement program and retired on January 31, 2013. At 10:19 a.m., Mayor McCormick recessed the City Council meeting to address the three other agency meetings. At 10:26 a.m., the City Council meeting resumed. CLOSED SESSION At 10:26 a.m. it was moved by McCormick and seconded by Davis that the City Council go into closed session to discuss the item listed under closed session. Motion carried, 5-0. 1. CITY COUNCIL CONFERENCE WITH LABOR NEGOTIATORS Government Code Section 54957.6 Agency Designated Representatives: Mark Whitworth, Teresa McAllister Employee Organizations: Vernon Police Management Association, Vernon Firemen's Association and Teamsters Local 911 At 10:59 a.m, it was moved by Maisano and seconded by Davis, that the City Council exit closed session. Motion carried, 5-0. Page 11 of 12 Special and Regular City Council Meeting Minutes June 4, 2013 Deputy City Attorney Scott Porter announced that there was no reportable action. At 10:59 a.m., it was moved by Maisano and seconded by Martinez, to adjourn the meeting in memory of former City of Vernon employee Victor Trujillo. Motion carried, 5-0. ATTEST: Da$z Reed ' IntLyrim City Clerk W. Michael McCormick Mayor Page 12 of 12