Loading...
Ordinance No. 10761 ORDINANCE NO. 1076 3 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF VERNON AMENDING SECTION 5.45 OF ARTICLE IV OF 4 CHAPTER 5 OF THE CODE OF THE CITY OF VERNON, CALIFORNIA, 1959, REGARDING A SPECIAL TAX ON 5 PARCELS OF REAL PROPERTY USED OR DESIGNED FOR USE AS A WAREHOUSE, TRUCK TERMINAL, FREIGHT 6 TERMINAL, A RAILROAD FACILITY OR OTHER DISTRIBUTION FACILITY; MAKING PROVISIONS FOR THE 7 ASSESSMENT, LEVY AND COLLECTION OF SAID TAX; ESTABLISHING A DATE FOR AN ELECTION TO BE HELD 8 TO APPROVE THE LEVY OF SAID SPECIAL TAXES; AND DECLARING THAT SAID ORDINANCE SHALL TAKE EFFECT 9 IMMEDIATELY 10 11 WHEREAS, on January 6, 1998, the Vernon City Council adopted 12 Ordinance No. 1057, which among other things added Article IV to 13 Chapter 5 of the Code of the City of Vernon, California, 1959, which 14 established a parcel tax on warehouses, truck terminals, freight 15 terminals and other distribution facilities; and 16 WHEREAS, Ordinance No. 1057 was submitted to the electorate 17 and duly approved at the April 14, 1998, Municipal Election; and 18 WHEREAS, a substantial and increasing percentage of land area 19 in the City of Vernon is occupied by warehouses, truck terminals, 20 freight terminals and other distribution facilities, all of which 21 attract businesses which require improved right-of-ways and/or cause 22 disproportionately high wear and tear on public streets when compared 23 to manufacturers and other businesses in the City; and 24 WHEREAS, businesses occupying warehouses, truck terminals, 25 freight terminals and other distribution facilities typically generate 26 significantly less local tax and other revenue that might be used to 27 address such needs and impacts than do manufacturers and other 28 businesses; and 1 WHEREAS, the special parcel tax established by Ordinance No. 2 1057 was intended to equitably distribute the burden of generating 3 local revenue for construction, improvement and maintenance of 4 streets, bridges and other public rights -of -way among all businesses 5 in the City; and 6 WHEREAS, Ordinance No. 1057 established a maximum special tax 7 of $1.00 per 100 square feet of gross area of land and, pursuant to 8 resolution, the Vernon City Council subsequently imposed the maximum 9 special tax rate authorized by Ordinance No. 1057; and 10 WHEREAS, the small maximum parcel tax which is currently 11 authorized and which is currently in effect is not substantial enough 12 to deter trucking uses from entering the City or to offset the 13 detrimental effects that these businesses have on the City; and 14 WHEREAS, Article XIIIC of the California Constitution, 15 enacted by the passage of Proposition 218 by the voters of the State 16 at the statewide election held in November, 1996, authorizes a local 17 governmental agency to impose, extend or increase a special tax on 18 real property upon approval by a two-thirds vote of the electorate 19 voting on the issue at an election; and 20 WHEREAS, in order to distribute the burden of generating 21 local revenue for construction, improvement and maintenance of 22 streets, bridges and other public rights -of -way among all businesses 23 in the City in a more effective and equitable manner, the City Council 24 finds that it is necessary to increase the maximum parcel tax rate of 25 $1.00 for each 100 square feet of gross land area, which was 26 established by Ordinance No. 1057, to $20.00 for each 100 square feet 27 of gross land area; and 28 WHEREAS, refrigerated warehouses are typically large -2- 1 consumers of electricity and, therefore, contribute to the reserves of 2 the City of Vernon's Utilities Department, which generates interest 3 and a revenue stream for the City's General Fund; and 4 WHEREAS, certain warehouses have a large retail component 5 and, therefore, contribute sales taxes to the City's General Fund; and 6 WHEREAS, the refrigerated warehouses and those warehouses 7 which pay a sales tax to the City of at least .20G per square foot 8 during the fiscal year are providing a contribution which will offset 9 some of the detrimental effects that such businesses may have on the 10 City during that year and, therefore, will be exempted from the 11 special parcel tax for that year; and 12 WHEREAS, the increased special parcel tax to be imposed is a 13 flat -rate tax based upon the square footage of each parcel of real 14 property so used or improved, and is not to be levied or assessed on 15 an ad valorem basis; and 16 WHEREAS, it is the intent of the City Council that the 17 proceeds of the special parcel tax established by this ordinance be 18 for the specific purposes of funding construction, improvements and 19 maintenance of streets, bridges and other public rights -of -way, 20 including acquisition of land; and 21 WHEREAS, it is further the intent of the City Council that 22 the special taxes imposed by this ordinance be for the purpose of 23 raising revenue, not for the purpose of regulation; and 24 WHEREAS, Article XIIIC provides that the voters may establish 25 a maximum tax rate for special taxes, and that increases in taxes 26 which do not exceed said maximum tax rate do not require voter 27 approval; and 28 WHEREAS, Government Code §.53739(b), as amended by urgency -3- 1 legislation effective July 1, 1997, provides that an ordinance or 2 resolution presented for voter approval pursuant to Article XIIIC may 3 provide that the tax rate stated in the ordinance or resolution may be 4 adjusted for inflation pursuant to a clearly identified formula stated 5 in that ordinance or resolution, and that if the ordinance or 6 resolution is approved by the requisite number of votes at an election 7 held for that purpose, the governing board of the adopting local 8 government may thereafter impose the tax at any rate or amount that is 9 less than or equal to the inflation -adjusted maximum amount authorized 10 by the voter -approved ordinance or resolution; and 11 WHEREAS, it is the desire and intent of the City Council that 12 this ordinance, if approved by the voters, establish a maximum rate 13 for all of the special parcel tax which is the subject of this 14 ordinance, that the maximum tax rate be adjusted annually based upon 15 increases in the Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers (CPI-U), 16 All Items Index, Los Angeles -Anaheim -Riverside Area, as published by 17 the Bureau of Labor Statistics of the United States Department of 18 Labor, 1982-84 base year; and 19 WHEREAS, Section 4.3 of the Charter of the City of Vernon 20 allows an ordinance to be introduced and adopted at one meeting if it 21 relates to an election; and 22 WHEREAS, a Special Municipal Election in the City of Vernon 23 will be held on November 16, 1999; and 24 WHEREAS, the City Council desires to submit the taxes 25 established in this ordinance to the voters of the City for approval 26 pursuant to Article XIIIC of the California Constitution and 27 Government Code §§ 50076, et sea. and 53972, at sea. at the 28 November 16, 1999, Special Municipal Election. -4- 1' 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF VERNON AND THE PEOPLE OF THE I CITY OF VERNON HEREBY ORDAIN: SECTION 1: The City Council of the City of Vernon hereby finds and determines that the recitals contained hereinabove are true I and correct. SECTION 2: Section 5.45 of Chapter 5 of Article IV of the Code of the City of Vernon, California, 1959, shall be amended to read as set forth in Exhibit "A" attached hereto and incorporated herein by this reference as though set forth at length. SECTION 3: The City Council orders that the special taxes and related provisions established herein be put to a vote of the people at a Special Election to be held on November 16, 1999, said election to be more formally established by resolution of the City Council. Voters shall indicate their approval or disapproval of this ordinance and the taxes and related provisions established by this ordinance by voting "yes" or "no" on the following proposition: Shall an ordinance entitled "AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF VERNON AMENDING SECTION 5.45 OF ARTICLE IV OF CHAPTER 5 OF THE CODE OF THE CITY OF VERNON, CALIFORNIA, 1959, REGARDING A SPECIAL TAX ON PARCELS OF REAL PROPERTY USED OR DESIGNED FOR USE AS A WAREHOUSE, TRUCK TERMINAL, FREIGHT TERMINAL, A RAILROAD FACILITY OR OTHER DISTRIBUTION FACILITY; MAKING PROVISIONS FOR THE ASSESSMENT, LEVY AND COLLECTION OF SAID TAX; ESTABLISHING A DATE FOR AN ELECTION TO BE HELD TO APPROVE THE LEVY OF SAID SPECIAL TAXES; AND DECLARING THAT SAID ORDINANCE SHALL TAKE EFFECT IMMEDIATELY" be approved and adopted? -5- YES NO 1 Said proposition shall be designated "Measure 'All' on the ballot 2 unless given a different designation by county election officials. 3 SECTION 4: The special taxes established by this ordinance 4 shall not be levied on any business or parcel unless and until said 5 taxes receive the approval of two-thirds of the votes cast by voters 6 of the City voting on this issue at the November 16, 1999 election. 7 SECTION 5: The City Council of the City of Vernon may, by 8 ordinance, amend, repeal, renumber or recodify any or all of the 9 provisions of Article IV of Chapter 5 of the Code of the City of 10 Vernon enacted by this ordinance, except that no ordinance imposing, 11 extending or increasing the taxes established by this ordinance shall 12 be effective unless approved by the voters if required pursuant to the 13 law applicable at the time of such action. 14 SECTION 6: The renumbering of any article or section of the 15 Code of the City of Vernon shall not constitute a change in its intent 16 or purpose, and it shall have the same effect and enforceability as if 17 it had never been renumbered. Any Code section numbers not used shall 18 be reserved for future use. 19 SECTION 7: If any section, subsection, sentence, clause, 20 phrase or word of this ordinance is for any reason held to be invalid 21 or unconstitutional, such decision shall not affect the validity of 22 the remaining portions of this ordinance; it being the intention of 23 the City Council of the City of Vernon to pass and adopt this 24 ordinance and each section, subsection, sentence, clause or phrase 25 thereof irrespective of the fact that one or more of the sections, 26 subsections, clauses, sentences or phrases thereof may be declared to 27 be invalid or unconstitutional. 28 SECTION 8: There being no newspaper printed, published or 1 circulated in the City of Vernon, the City Clerk is hereby directed to 2 certify to the passage of this ordinance and shall post the same, or 3 cause the same to be posted, within fifteen (15) days after its 4 passage in accordance with Section 36933 of the Government Code, in 5 three (3) of the most public places in the City of Vernon, to wit: 6 the northwest corner of 38th Street and Santa Fe Avenue, the northeast 7 corner of Leonis Boulevard and Pacific Boulevard, and on the bulletin 8 board in the lobby of the City Hall of said City, located at 4305 9 Santa Fe Avenue, all in the City of Vernon, County of Los Angeles, 10 State of California. 11 SECTION 9: Pursuant to Chapter 4.3(a) of the Charter of the 12 City of Vernon, this ordinance shall be introduced and adopted at one 13 regular or special meeting of the City Council and shall be in full 14 force and effect immediately upon adoption. 15 INTRODUCED AND ADOPTED this 17th day of August, 1999. 16 17 THOMAS A. YB RA, Mayor Pro Tem 18 ATTES �-� 19 BRUCE V. MALKENHORST, City Clerk 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 -7- 1 STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) ) ss 2 COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES ) 3 I, BRUCE V. MALKENHORST, City Clerk of the City of Vernon, do 4 hereby certify that the foregoing Ordinance, being Ordinance No. 1076, 5 was duly and regularly introduced and adopted at a regular meeting of 6 said City Council held on Tuesday, August 17, 1999, and thereafter was 7 duly signed by the Mayor Pro Tem of the City of Vernon, by the 8 following vote: 9 10 AYES: Councilmen: Ybarra, Gonzales, Davis 11 NOES: Councilmen: 12 13 ABSENT: Councilmen: Malburg, McCormick 14 15 BRUCE V. MALKENHORST, City Clerk 16 17 (SEAL) 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 EXHIBIT A CHAPTER 5 BUSINESS LICENSE TAXES AND OTHER CITY TAXES Article IV. Special Parcel Tax Sec. 5.45. Special parcel tax on warehouses, truck terminals, freight terminals and other distribution facilities. (a) Pursuant to authority of Article XIIIC of the California Constitution and Government Code § 50075, e-t sea., there is hereby levied and assessed a special tax by the City of Vernon on each parcel of property improved with a "warehouse," a "truck terminal," a "freight terminal," a "railroad facility," or a "distribution facility," as hereinafter defined. The special tax shall be levied and assessed each year, commencing in the year 1998 and continuing until modification or repeal in a manner provided by law. (b) As used in this Section 5.45, the following terms have the meanings or limitations indicated: (1) Assessor's parcel map means an official map of the assessor of the County of Los Angeles designating parcels by assessor's parcel number. (2) Cold storage and refrigerated warehouses mean a building or part of a building used primarily to store non- durable, perishable goods under refrigeration including services for processing, preparing or packaging goods for storage. Page 1 of 8 EXHIBIT A (3) Freight terminal is a lot, building or part of a building, as used or designed for use, in or on which goods or freight are transferred or redistributed from one vehicle to another. (4) Maximum special tax means the maximum special tax, determined in accordance with subsection (c) below, that can be levied by the City of Vernon in any fiscal year on a parcel of property improved with a warehouse, truck terminal, freight terminal or other distribution facility. (5) Other distribution facility includes an intermodal container transfer facility and storage areas related to such facility. (6) Parcel means a lot or parcel shown on the current applicable assessor's parcel map with an assigned assessor's parcel number. (7) Truck terminal means a lot, building or part of a building used or designed primarily for the storage, maintenance or servicing of highway -type vehicles carrying persons or property, including but not limited to trucks and buses. (8) Trucking uses mean any lot, building or part of a building in or on which goods or freight are transferred or redistributed from one vehicle to another, or any lot, building or part of a building used primarily for the storage, maintenance or servicing of highway -type vehicles carrying persons or Page 2 of 8 EXHIBIT A property including, but not limited to, trucks and buses, but excluding commercial repair facilities. (9) Railroad facilities mean rail lot yards used primarily for the switching of rail cars or transferring of freight or goods from a rail car to another vehicle, but does not include railroad spur tracks. (10) Retail sales mean those sales in which the City receives one percent (1%) of the sales tax. (11) Warehouse, distribution and wholesale uses mean a building or part of a building used or designed primarily for the storage of non-perishable goods or non -refrigerated perishable goods intended for distribution to other locations, or the sale of goods for distribution to other locations for wholesale or retail sale, but does not include: (i) an accessory warehouse building that is an integral part of a manufacturing business located in the City of Vernon used for storage of goods or materials produced in that operation, (ii) any wholesale, distribution and wholesale uses which pay at least .20� per square foot in sales tax to the City of Vernon during the subject fiscal year, and (iii) cold storage and refrigerated warehouses. (c) The maximum special tax commencing in fiscal year 1999, shall be $20.00 per 100 square feet of gross area of land. (d) (1) Pursuant to section 2(b) of Article XIIIC of the California Constitution, the tax rate established by this article Page 3 of 8 EXHIBIT A is a maximum rate, and the city council, by resolution or ordinance, may levy a tax at any rate or amount that is equal to or less than the maximum rate or amount authorized by this article. (2) The maximum rate established by this article shall be revised annually based upon changes in the Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers (CPI-U), All Items Index, Los Angeles -Anaheim -Riverside Area (1982-84=100) (hereinafter "CPI") published by the United States Department of Labor, Bureau of Labor Statistics. In the event said CPI for the twelve-month period ending March 31 of each year (the "adjustment date") is higher than said CPI for the twelve-month period ending March 31, 1999, the maximum tax rate set forth in this article shall be increased by multiplying said tax rate by a fraction, the numerator of which is the CPI on the adjustment date and the denominator of which is the CPI for the twelve-month period ending March 31, 1999. The resulting adjusted tax rate shall then be the maximum tax rate for the fiscal year commencing the next July 1st. There shall be no reduction in rates by operation of this provision. If, in the future, said CPI shall be changed so that the base year differs from that used as of the effective date of this article, it shall be converted in accordance with the conversion factor published by the United States Department of Labor, Bureau of Labor Statistics. The city clerk shall Page 4 of 8 EXHIBIT A submit a written report to the city council setting forth the adjustments to the maximum tax rate required by this subsection, which the city council shall approve by resolution. (3) Periodically, the city clerk shall submit to the city council a recommendation for revising the rate to be employed in levying the tax, provided, that the recommended tax rate shall not exceed the maximum tax rate authorized by this article. (e) The city council is authorized to determine for each fiscal year, by ordinance or resolution, the special tax to be imposed on each parcel subject to this section. The special tax shall not exceed the maximum special tax rate established in subsection (c) of this section as adjusted by subsection (d), but it may be imposed at a lower rate. The ordinance or resolution shall also list, by assessor's parcel number, all parcels subject to the tax. The ordinance or resolution shall constitute the official record of the assessment of the special tax, and a copy thereof, together with any other pertinent data, shall be transmitted to the appropriate county or city officials to facilitate collection of the special tax. (f) The special tax shall be due in two equal installments in accordance with the collection procedures of the Los Angeles County Tax Collector, with the first installment due November 1, and the second installment due the next succeeding February 1. Page 5 of 8 EXHIBIT A The owner of the land, land and improvements, at the time set forth in California Revenue and Taxation Code Sections 405 and 2192 for each fiscal year, shall have a personal obligation to the City of Vernon until the tax is paid. (g) The city clerk may prepare a questionnaire to be served on the owner of a parcel or improvements subject to the tax imposed by this article. The questionnaire may request information which would be useful to the city clerk in the enforcement or administration of this article. The failure by an owner to provide the information requested within thirty (30) days of receipt of the request, or the act of an owner in knowingly providing false information, shall be a misdemeanor. (h) In determining the gross square footage area of improvements the city clerk may use County Assessor's records, city records, questionnaires and any other records the city clerk deems reliable. (i) Properties or entities exempt by law from the ad valorem tax imposed by Articles XIII and XIIIA of the California Constitution shall be exempt from the tax imposed by this section. (j) The special tax imposed by this section shall be collected in the same manner as ad valorem property taxes are collected and shall be subject to the same procedure, sale and lien priority in case of delinquency as is provided by ad valorem Page 6 of 8 EXHIBIT A taxes (which such procedures include the exercise of all rights and remedies permitted by law to make corrections, including but not limited to, the issuance of amended or supplemental tax bills), as such procedure may be modified by law or by the Board of Supervisors of the County of Los Angeles from time to time; provided that the city council shall have authority to provide, by ordinance or resolution, for a different method of collection of said taxes as it shall determine to be in the best interest of the City of Vernon. The Board of Supervisors, the Auditor - Controller, the Treasurer -Tax Collector and the Assessor of the County of Los Angeles shall perform the duties of assessment of property for the special tax, the correction of any assessment, the collection, payment, and enforcement of the special tax, including delinquent taxes, and the redemption of property from sale or other penalty for nonpayment of the special tax. (k) The special tax imposed by this section shall be a tax upon each parcel of property, and the tax shall not be measured by the value of the property. (1) The proceeds of the special tax shall be used for construction, improvement and maintenance of streets, bridges and other public rights -of -way, including acquisition of land. (m) Nothing in this article shall be construed as requiring the payment of a tax or the doing of an act which would constitute an unlawful burden upon or an unlawful interference Page 7 of 8 EXHIBIT A ,'T,I t • with interstate of foreign commerce or which would be in violation of the constitution or the laws of the United States or • the constitution or the laws of the State.of California. (n) The penalties provided for in Section 5.11 of this Code shall apply to the tax imposed by this article; provided, that should said tax be collected by the County of Los Angeles, the delinquency date shall be the same date ad valorem property taxes become delinquent. I m Page 8 of 8 EXHIBIT A SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS REPORT ON INCREASE OF PARCEL TAX The City Council approved a staff report explaining the need for legislative changes to the City Code to encourage the development of manufacturing uses. The report also recommended an increase in the parcel tax as part of the solution to discourage certain uses which compete with manufacturing uses. These legislative changes were made in response to Subdivisions that were being contemplated that converted prime industrial property into warehouse and distribution sites. The principal focus of the City of Vernon's General Plan is to provide locations for manufacturing and industrial uses. The thrust of the Land Use Element is twofold. First, the goals and policies of the City shall promote and maintain the industrial character of the City and second, encourage the modernization, replacement or reuse of the older industrial facilities. One of the goals and policies of the General Plan Land Use Element reads as follows: Goal 1: PROMOTE AND MAINTAIN MANUFACTURING AS THE PRIMARY LAND USE WITHIN THE CITY POLICY 1.1: Provide sufficient appropriate locations for manufacturing and industrial uses and provide for the location of those activities which support manufacturing (e.g., warehousing and transportation -related uses) in areas where they will not interfere or compete for space with manufacturing operations. POLICY 1.2: Designate sufficient land for commercial uses which are necessary to support industry, in areas where they will not interfere with industrial operations. POLICY 1.3: Continue to permit residential development which supports industry provided that environmental constrains can be mitigated to an acceptable level. POLICY 1.4: Continue to maintain and upgrade City services, utilities, and infrastructure to levels required by modern industry. In accordance with the Vernon General Plan, the City Council adopted Vernon's current comprehensive zoning ordinance on April 18, 1989. The City was incorporated in 1905 as an "exclusively industrial City" and subsequent City Council's have adopted policies which were intended to encourage the continued development of industrial uses. The current General Plan continues that long history of encouraging the development of industrial uses. The public policy reasons for maintaining the industrial nature of the City includes: 1. Creation of Employment. 2. Efficient Use of Developed Resources. 3. Inadequate Street Right -of -Way -2- 4. Historical Use Evolution. S. Revenue Impacts. 6. Police and Fire Expertise in serving an Industrial Community. In the preparation and adoption of the General Plan and Comprehensive Zoning Ordinance, the City attempted to place controls on the establishment of warehouse and distribution related uses by limiting the size of warehouses to 50,000 square feet and excluding transportation uses from the M-Zone. The Community Services Department was asked to recommend legislative changes which will assist Vernon in maintaining and attracting industrial uses. City staff held discussions with the Real Estate Developers in the community to determine how the City's goal could be achieved. A variety of concepts were studied. Staff reviewed trends of new construction and the existing landscape of the City. It was determined that a broad scope of changes were needed in order to achieve our goal. The Community Services Department has considered numerous programs that can assist the City in reaching the General Plan goal of providing sufficient appropriate locations for manufacturing and industrial uses. It is apparent that zoning and City policies could be changed to encourage industrial development in the City. The following are the concepts that were studied: I. WAREHOUSE, FLOOR AREA, MULTI -TENANT OR SUBDIVISION SIZE LIMITATIONS -3- A. Elimination of Warehouse and Wholesale Uses in the M- Zone or a Reduction in Size B. Establish a Minimum Lot Size C. Establish New Floor to Area Ratio D. Prohibit Multi -Tenant Uses E. Allow existing buildings used for warehouse purposes in excess of 75,000 square feet the ability to convert back and forth between warehouse and industrial uses II. ESTABLISH NEW ZONING DISTRICTS III. CREATE AN ECONOMIC DISINCENTIVE FOR WAREHOUSE AND TRANSPORTATION RELATED USES IV. REDEVELOPMENT PROGRAMS Based on the study conducted, staff recommended that a number of code changes and policies be adopted. In order to achieve the City's goal of maintaining Vernon's industrial character it was determined that this package of changes working in harmony would allow the City to achieve its goal. However if one of the policies was not incorporated the full success of the plan may not be fully realized. The recommended code changes and policies are as follows: A. Restrict the adjusting of Lot Lines or Subdividing of parcels in excess of 3 acres so that only one lot less than three acres is created. Establish a minimum lot size of 3/4 acre for commercial and general office, and 1 acre for all other uses with the exception of -4- residential lots which will be developed in accordance with Section 26.4.3 of the Comprehensive Zoning Ordinance. Each lot shall have a minimum frontage along a public street of 150 feet. City owned property shall be exempt from the minimum lot size and frontage requirements; B. Allow existing warehouses in excess of 75,000 square feet the ability to convert back and forth between warehouse and manufacturing use; C. Increase the City parcel tax on warehouse and transportation related uses; and D. Encourage the Redevelopment Agency to purchase smaller sites and assemble them into larger sites to be made available for manufacturing uses. One of the primary recommendations was to create an economic disincentive for warehouse and transportation related uses by increasing the special parcel tax. Warehouses, truck terminals and intermodal facilities generate substantial numbers of trucks. The great volume of trucks has adversely impacted the City's circulation system. Trucks often maneuver in the streets as they back up to onsite truck docks causing significant delays to the traveling public and adversely impact emergency response. Just as detrimental to the circulation system are the long Port Trains traveling to the intermodal facilities on the north side of the City. These trains must travel slow and often stop prior to entering the railroad yards causing significant delays on City -5- streets. The City has enacted Zoning Policies that would require all truck maneuvering to be performed onsite. However the City has been forced to consider constructing expensive Public Works Projects in order to alleviate the substantial congestion caused by the slow moving trains. The contemplated projects include the reconfiguration of the 710-Atlantic/Bandini Boulevard Interchange, Grade separations at Bandini Boulevard, District Boulevard and Slauson Avenue over Downey Road and the Union Pacific Railroad, the Alameda Corridor, the construction of a new Interchange at Route 710 and Slauson, the widening of Soto Street from Bandini Boulevard to Olympic Boulevard and improvements to 26th Street so that capacity on this roadway can be increased. Not only do the trucks cause substantial congestion, they are the primary cause of pavement failure. Roadways are designed based on the number of repetitive truck loads. Automobiles have no impact and are not considered in pavement thickness design. The more trucks, the thicker the pavement must be designed. One overloaded truck could potentially cause the pavement to prematurely fail. Given the number of trucks that travel on City streets the pavement must be resurfaced at an accelerated pace when compared to typical arterials and local streets of neighboring communities. If the City fails to resurface the street in a timely manner full reconstruction could be required. Lastly, trucks are involved in approximately 40 percent of all vehicular accidents within the City. Therefore the industries causing the truck movements should pay their fair share for road improvements and other City services. Typically warehouses, (except for those warehouses that make retail sales or are refrigerated and use substantial amounts of electricity) truck terminals and intermodal facilities contribute very little money to the General Fund. Since the City of Vernon is an industrial community it receives very little gas tax and other state funding earmarked for roadways because the funds are distributed based on population. Therefore the vast majority of roadway improvements within the City are paid for out of the City's General Fund. The General Fund must also pay for Police and Fire Department services. Each local community must decide where every dollar must be spent. Typically the decision of whether the infrastructure of the City should be maintained, or police and fire protection be preserved is a difficult one. An alternative would be to supplement the City's General Fund with a tax or impact fee on those creating the truck movements causing damage to the public streets and adding to the congestion on our circulation system. It appears that the City could achieve two goals with one mechanism. As stated previously the City goal established in the General Plan is to maintain and attract industrial uses. If the tax or impact fee were high enough it would cause warehouses and transportation related uses to reconsider staying or moving into Vernon. If truck intense businesses don't move into Vernon then the funds generated by those business are not needed because the circulation and roadway -7- surface would not suffer the abuse caused by their vehicles. Last Year, the City council adopted Ordinance No. 1057, which among other things established a parcel tax on warehouses, truck terminals, freight terminals and other distribution facilities. The ordinance was approved by the voters of the City. The City Council then passed a resolution setting the parcel tax at the maximum rate allowed by the ordinance — $1.00 per 100 square feet of land (approximately $436 per acre). Proceeds of this parcel tax are earmarked for construction, improvement and maintenance of streets, bridges and other public rights -of -way, including acquisition of land. However, the small parcel tax currently in effect is not substantial enough to deter the trucking uses from entering the City. The average lease rate for a Class A warehouse building in Vernon is approximately 40G per square foot per month. Therefore the lease for a 50,000 square foot warehouse per year is $240,000. A class B building would be approximately 3/4 of this, while a class C building would be one half. In comparison given a lot coverage of 55% the current annual parcel tax for the same size building is $909.09. While the parcel tax will collect over $400,000 for the City annually, it is far from covering the City's total public works and capital improvements budget. The City of Vernon's General Fund revenues for Fiscal Year 97-98 are as follows: TABLE 1 GENERAL FUND REVENUES 1997-98 PERCENTAGE $ CONTRIBUTED CONTRIBUTED BY BY WAREHOUSE/ WAREHOUSE/ TOTAL TRANSPORTATION TRANSPORTATION Sales and Use Tax(l) $4,465,631.00 00-. $0.00 Franchise Tax�2) $2,222,897.00 5.706 $126,705.13 Property Tax(3) $1,889,454.00 2001 $377,890.80 Building Permits and''' Plan Check Fees $746,069.00 200-o $149,213.80 Community Services(l) $82,059.00 20% $16,411.80 Business Licenses(4) $935,124.00 22.4% $209,467.78 Investment Income(2) $13,805,015.00 5.70-o $78,688.86 Fines and Forfeitures(') $123,240.00 00-. $0.00 Miscellaneous(') $817,728.00 250-. $204,432.00 $25,087,217.00 $1,162,810.17 (')Estimated by City Staff (2jEstimated by Utilities Department (3)Estimated by HDL (')Percentage based on 1999 Business License figures (warehouse/trucking $361,765.00, Total all Business License Fees $1,609,198.60) The City of Vernon's General Fund expenditures for Fiscal Year 97-98 are as follows: TABLE 2 GENERAL FUND EXPENDITURES 1997-98 General Government $5,146,587.00 Fire Protection $8,984,639.00 Police Protection $7,721,749.00 Public Works $7,032,536.00 Health Services $1,135,114.00 Capital Outlay $1,408,928.00 $31,4291553.00 The City had an operating cost of $31,429,553 for Fiscal Year 1997-98. Approximately $6.34 million had to be taken from the General Fund's dwindling reserve to cover the shortfall in revenue. Additionally the City completed only a fraction of its normal capital improvement projects due to the construction of the City of Vernon natural gas distribution system. Street improvements have been on a temporary hold until the gas pipes are installed so that newly paved streets would not be cut. Of the $25,087,217 of revenues that the General Fund received, approximately 4.63% was generated from warehouse, distribution transportation related uses. Of the $31,429,553 in City expenditures only 3.7% was paid by warehouse and transportation related uses. According to the City of Vernon's General Plan approximately 37.7% of the land within Vernon is used for industrial uses, while warehouse and transportation uses -10- account for 26.90-. of the land use within Vernon. In addition the Railroad facilities utilize 5% of the property within Vernon. Retail and commercial uses account for 2.4% of the land. The vast majority of remaining land is dedicated to streets, public utility rights -of -way and the Los Angeles River. Based on recent studies, warehouse, trucking and transportation facilities account for approximately 32.41 of the usable property in Vernon, (streets, river and utility easements are considered to be non -usable property) yet they account for only 4.632% of the revenue to the General Fund. Therefore, it appears that they are not paying their fair share for City services. The current parcel tax is less than 0.411 of the annual cost of the revenue gained on the property. I believe that in order to deter a warehouse use or transportation related use the annual parcel tax would have to have a stronger disincentive and would have to be in the range of 8% or greater of the lease rate. At the rate of 8% or greater, the mentioned uses may consider relocating to other sites away from the Vernon manufacturing core. This parcel tax could cause the warehouse and trucking uses to consider alternative sites. If a warehouse decided that Vernon was still the prime location for their business, then the parcel tax would offset the detrimental effects that their trucks would cause in our community. The funds received could be used for much needed roadway and circulation improvements. A parcel tax based on 8% of the lease rate would result in a tax of approximately $.211 per square foot per year or $21.10 per 100 square feet which -11- equates to $9,191 per acre per year. This would be 21 times the current rate. The new parcel tax for the above -mentioned 50,000 square foot building would be $19,200 per year. Certain warehouse uses contribute substantial revenue to the Vernon General Fund. These include refrigerated warehouses and warehouse uses with a high retail component. Refrigerated warehouses typically are large consumers of electricity. The City of Vernon electrical rates include a utility franchise tax which goes to the General Fund. Additionally, large energy consumers contribute to the reserves of the Utility Department. The interest on these reserves is a major revenue stream for the General Fund. Warehouses that have a large retail component also contribute to the General Fund in the form of sales tax. For each dollar of retail sales the City receives one cent. Therefore, a business with $1,000,000 in retail sales would contribute $10,000 to the General Fund. It is my opinion that those properties contributing .20G per square foot in sales tax should be exempted from the parcel tax. The City Attorney has reviewed the legal question of raising the tax to the level of $20.00 per 100 square feet. Despite the size of the increase, the City Attorney has concluded that the increase would be legally justifiable both as a means of raising additional revenue for street construction and maintenance and as a means of discouraging non -industrial uses. A tax increase will require voter approval at a general or special election. Under the state Elections Code, a special -12- election on a measure submitted to the voters by a legislative body can be scheduled between 88 and 103 days after the call for the election. It is recommended that August 17, 1999 be targeted as the date for adoption of an ordinance increasing the tax and the necessary resolutions for scheduling the election. This would enable the Council to schedule a special election between November 13 and November 28, 1999. Staff recommends that the maximum parcel tax rate of the on warehouse and transportation related uses be increased to $20.00 per 100 square feet of gross area of land. It is recommended that the parcel tax be capped at $20.00 per 100 square feet, or .20G per square foot. Further, this parcel tax should however be allowed to increase based on the consumers price index. The parcel tax should apply to warehouse, distribution trucking, wholesale, and transportation related uses including railroad facilities but excluding railroad spur tracks, cold storage and refrigerated warehouses and warehouses producing substantial retail sales. The tax should be specifically applied to the following uses: 1. Warehouse, distribution and wholesale uses are defined as follows: A building or portion of a building used primarily for the storage of non-perishable goods or non -refrigerated perishable goods intended for distribution to other locations or the sale of goods for distribution to other locations for wholesale or retail sale but excluding any wholesale, distribution and -13- wholesale uses which generate retail sales in excess of $5,000,000 and whose point of sale is at the subject site, and also excluding cold storage and refrigerated warehouses; 2. Cold storage and refrigerated warehouse is defined as a building or part of a building used primarily to store nondurable, perishable goods under refrigeration including services for processing, preparing or packaging goods for storage; 3. Trucking uses are defined as any lot, building or a part of a building in or on which goods or freight are transferred or redistributed from one vehicle to another, or any lot, building, or part of a building used primarily for the storage, maintenance, or servicing of highway type vehicles carrying persons or property including but not limited to trucks and buses, excluding however commercial repair facilities. 4. Railroad facilities are defined as railroad yards used primarily for the switching of railcars, or transferring freight or goods from a railcar to another vehicle. 5. Retail sales are those sales in which the City receives 1% of the sales tax. Attached as Table 3 is a list of properties that as of June 1999 the tax would be applicable to. Based on this list the City would receive approximately $321,000 for each penny of special parcel tax applied. At a parcel tax of 20G per square foot it -14- would equate to $6,420,000 which is nearly equal to the shortfall in the Fiscal Year 1997-98 budget. report.parceltax -15- FINAL REPORT ON INCREASE OF PARCEL TAX The City Council, On July approved a staff report explaining the need for legislative changes to the City Code to encourage the development of manufacturing uses. The report also recommended an increase in the parcel tax as part of the solution to discourage certain uses which compete with manufacturing uses. These legislative changes were made in response to Subdivisions that were being contemplated that converted prime industrial property into warehouse and distribution sites. The principal focus of the City of vernon's General Plan is to provide locations for manufacturing and industrial uses. The thrust of the Land Use Element is twofold. First, the goals and policies of the City shall promote and maintain the industrial character of the City and second, encourage the modernization, replacement or reuse of the older industrial facilities. One of the goals and policies of the General Plan Land Use Element reads as follows: Goal 1: PROMOTE AND MAINTAIN MANUFACTURING AS THE PRIMARY LAND USE WITHIN THE CITY POLICY 1.1: Provide sufficient appropriate locations for manufacturing and industrial uses and provide for the location of those activities which support manufacturing (e.g., warehousing and transportation -related uses) in areas where they will not interfere or compete for space with manufacturing operations. POLICY 1.2: Designate sufficient land for commercial uses which are necessary to support industry, in areas where they will not interfere with industrial operations. POLICY 1.3: Continue to permit residential development which supports industry provided that environmental constrains can be mitigated to an acceptable level. POLICY 1.4: Continue to maintain and upgrade City services, utilities, and infrastructure.to levels required by modern industry. In accordance with the Vernon General Plan, the City Council adopted Vernon's current comprehensive zoning ordinance on April 18, 1989. The City was incorporated in 1905 as an "exclusively industrial City" and subsequent City Council's have adopted Policies which were intended to encourage the continued development of industrial uses. The current General Plan continues that long history of encouraging the development of industrial uses. The public policy reasons for maintaining the industrial nature of the City includes: 1. Creation of Employment. 2. Efficient Use of Developed Resources. 3. Inadequate Street Right -of -Way -2- 4. Historical Use Evolution. 5. Revenue Impacts. 6. Police and Fire Expertise in serving an Industrial Community. In the preparation and adoption of the General Plan and Comprehensive Zoning Ordinance, the City attempted to place controls on the establishment of warehouse and distribution related uses by limiting the size of warehouses to 50,000 square feet and excluding transportation uses from the M-Zone. The Community Services Department was asked to recommend legislative changes which will assist Vernon in maintaining and attracting industrial uses. City staff held discussions with the Real Estate Developers in the community to determine how the City's goal could be achieved. A variety of concepts were studied. Staff reviewed trends of new construction and the existing landscape of the City. It was determined that a broad scope of changes were needed in order to achieve our goal. The Community Services Department has considered numerous programs that can assist the City in reaching the General Plan goal of providing sufficient appropriate locations for manufacturing and industrial uses. It is apparent that zoning and City policies could be changed to encourage industrial development in the City. The following are the concepts that were studied: I. WAREHOUSE, FLOOR AREA, MULTI -TENANT OR SUBDIVISION SIZE LIMITATIONS -3- A. Elimination of Warehouse and Wholesale Uses in the M- Zone or a Reduction in Size B. Establish a Minimum Lot Size C. Establish New Floor to Area Ratio D. Prohibit Multi -Tenant Uses E. Allow existing buildings used for warehouse purposes in excess of 75,000 square feet the ability to convert back and forth between warehouse and industrial uses II. ESTABLISH NEW ZONING DISTRICTS III. CREATE AN ECONOMIC DISINCENTIVE FOR WAREHOUSE AND TRANSPORTATION RELATED USES IV. REDEVELOPMENT PROGRAMS Based on the study conducted, staff recommended that a number of code changes and policies be adopted. In order to achieve the City's goal of maintaining Vernon's industrial character it was determined that this package of changes working in harmony would allow the City to achieve its goal. However if one of the policies was not incorporated the full success of the plan may not be fully realized. The recommended code changes ,and policies are as follows: A. Restrict the adjusting of Lot Lines or Subdividing of parcels in excess of 3 acres so that only one lot less than three acres is created. Establish a minimum lot size of 3/4 acre for commercial and general office, and 1 acre for all other uses with the exception of -4- residential lots which will be developed in accordance with Section 26.4.3 of the Comprehensive Zoning Ordinance. Each lot shall have a minimum frontage along a public street of 150 feet. ..City owned property shall be exempt from the minimum lot size and frontage requirements; B. Allow existing warehouses in excess of 75,000 square feet the ability to convert back and forth between warehouse and manufacturing use; C. Increase the City parcel tax on warehouse and transportation related uses; and D. Encourage the Redevelopment Agency to purchase smaller sites and assemble them into larger sites to be made available for manufacturing uses. One of the primary recommendations was to create an economic disincentive for warehouse and transportation related uses by, increasing the special parcel tax. Warehouses, truck terminals and intermodal facilities generate substantial numbers of trucks. The great volume of trucks has adversely impacted the City,s circulation system. Trucks often maneuver in the streets as they back up to onsite truck docks causing significant delays to the traveling public and adversely impact emergency response. Just as detrimental to the circulation system are the long Port Trains traveling to the intermodal facilities on the north side of the City. These trains must travel slow and often stop prior to entering the railroad yards causing significant delays on City -5- streets. The City has enacted Zoning Policies that would require all truck maneuvering to be performed onsite. However the City has been forced to consider constructing expensive Public Works Projects in order to alleviate the substantial -congestion caused by the slow moving trains. The contemplated projects include the reconfiguration of the 710-Atlantic/Bandini Boulevard Interchange, Grade separations at Bandini Boulevard, District Boulevard and Slauson Avenue over Downey Road and the Union Pacific Railroad, the Alameda Corridor, the construction of a new Interchange at Route 710 and Slauson, the widening of Soto Street from Bandini Boulevard to Olympic Boulevard and improvements to 26th Street so that capacity on this roadway can be increased. Not only do the trucks cause substantial congestion, they are the primary cause of pavement failure. Roadways are designed based on the number of repetitive truck loads. Automobiles have no impact and are not considered in pavement thickness design. The more trucks, the thicker the pavement must be designed. One overloaded truck could potentially cause the pavement to prematurely fail. Given the number of trucks that travel on City streets the pavement must be resurfaced at an accelerated pace'' when compared to typical arterials and local streets of neighboring communities. If the City fails to resurface the street in a timely manner full reconstruction could be required. Lastly, trucks are involved in approximately 40 percent of all vehicular accidents within the City. Therefore the industries causing the truck movements should pay their fair share for road improvements and other City services. Typically warehouses, (except for those warehouses that make retail sales or are refrigerated and use substantial amounts of electricity) truck terminals and intermodal facilities contribute very little money to the General Fund. Since the City of Vernon is an industrial community it receives very little gas tax and other state funding earmarked for roadways because the funds are distributed based on population. Therefore the vast majority of roadway improvements within the City are paid for out of the City's General Fund. The General Fund must also pay for Police and Fire Department services. Each local community must decide where every dollar must be spent. Typically the decision of whether the infrastructure of the City should be maintained, or police and fire protection be preserved is a difficult one. An alternative would be to supplement the City's General Fund with a tax or impact fee on those creating the truck movements causing damage to the public streets and adding to the congestion on our circulation system. It appears that the City could achieve two goals with one mechanism. As stated previously the City goal established in the General Plan is to maintain and attract industrial uses. If the tax or impact fee were high enough it would cause warehouses and transportation related uses to reconsider staying or moving into Vernon. If truck intense businesses don't move into Vernon then the funds generated by those business are not needed because the circulation and roadway -7- surface would not suffer the abuse caused by their vehicles. Last Year, the City council adopted Ordinance No. 1057, which among other things established a parcel tax on warehouses, truck terminals, freight terminals and other distribution facilities. The ordinance was approved by the voters of the City. The City Council then passed a resolution setting the parcel tax at the maximum rate allowed by the ordinance — $1.00 per 100 square feet of land (approximately $436 per acre). Proceeds of this parcel tax are earmarked for construction, improvement and maintenance of streets, bridges and other public rights -of -way, including acquisition of land. However, the small parcel tax currently in effect is not substantial enough to deter the trucking uses from entering the City. The average lease rate for a Class A warehouse building in Vernon is approximately 404� per square foot per month. Therefore the lease for a 50,000 square foot warehouse per year is $240,000. A class B building would be approximately 3/4 of this, while a class C building would be one half. In comparison given a lot coverage of 550-. the current annual parcel tax for the same size building is $909.09. While the parcel tax will collect over $400,000 for the City annually, it is far from covering the City's total public works and capital improvements budget. The City of Vernon's General Fund revenues for Fiscal Year 97-98 are as follows: TABLE 1 GENERAL FUND RRVV.MTTvc 1 a a,7_ o o ("Estimated by City Staff (Z'Estimated by Utilities Department (3)Estimated by HDL (4)Percentage based on 1999 Business License figures (warehouse/trucking $361,765.00, Total all Business License Fees $1,609,198.60) The City of Vernon's General Fund expenditures for Fiscal Year 97-98 are as follows: TABLE 2 GENERAL FUND EXPENDITURES 1997-98 General Government -. $5,146,587.00 Fire Protection $8,984,639.00 Police Protection $7,721,749.00 Public Works $7,032,536.00 Health Services $1,135,114.00 Capital Outlay $1,408,928.00 $31,429,553.00 The City had an operating cost of $31,429,553 for Fiscal Year 1997-98. Approximately $6.34 million had to be taken from the General Fund's dwindling reserve to cover the shortfall in revenue. Additionally the City completed only a fraction.of its normal capital improvement projects due to the construction of the City of Vernon natural gas distribution system. Street 11 improvements have been on a temporary hold until the gas pipes are installed so that newly paved streets would not be cut. Of the $25,087,217 of revenues that the General Fund received, approximately 4.6301 was generated from warehouse, distribution transportation related uses. Of the $31,429,553 in City expenditures only 3.7a was paid by warehouse and transportation related uses. According to the City of Vernon's General Plan approximately 37.7% of the land within Vernon is used for industrial uses, while warehouse and transportation uses -10- account for 26.90 of the land use within Vernon. In addition the Railroad facilities utilize 515 of the property within Vernon. Retail and commercial uses account for 2.4% of the land. The vast majority of remaining land is dedicated to. streets, public utility rights -of -way and the Los Angeles River. Based on recent studies, warehouse, trucking and transportation facilities account for approximately 32.40 of the usable property in Vernon, (streets, river and utility easements are considered to be non -usable property) yet they account for only 4.632!k of the revenue to the General Fund. Therefore, it appears that they are not paying their fair share for City services. The current parcel tax is less than 0.415 of the annual cost of the revenue gained on the property. I believe that in order to deter a warehouse use or transportation related use the annual parcel tax would have to have a stronger disincentive and -would have to be in the range of 8s or greater of the lease rate. At the rate of 81-k or greater, the mentioned uses may consider relocating to other sites away from the Vernon manufacturing core. This parcel tax could cause the warehouse and trucking uses to consider alternative sites. If a warehouse decided that Vernon was still the prime location for their business, then the parcel tax would offset the detrimental effects that their trucks would cause in our community. The funds received could be used for much needed roadway and circulation improvements. A parcel tax based on 80 of the lease rate would result in a tax of approximately $.211 per square foot per year or $21.10 per 100 square feet which -11- equates to $9,191 per acre per year. This would he 21 times the current rate. The new parcel tax for the above -mentioned 50,0oo square foot building would be $19,200 per year. Certain warehouse uses contribute substantial revenue to the Vernon General Fund. These include refrigerated warehouses and warehouse uses with a high retail component. Refrigerated warehouses typically are large consumers of electricity. The City of Vernon electrical rates include a utility franchise tax which goes to the General Fund. Additionally; large energy consumers contribute to the reserves of the Utility Department. The interest on these reserves is a major revenue stream for the General Fund. Warehouses that have a large retail component also contribute to the General Fund in the form of sales tax. For each dollar of retail sales the City receives one cent. Therefore, a business with $1,000,000 in retail sales would contribute'$10,000 to the General Fund. It is my opinion that those properties„ contributing .20� per square foot in sales tax should be exempted from the parcel tax. The City Attorney has reviewed the legal question of raising the tax to the level of $20.00 per 100 square feet. Despite the size of the increase, the City Attorney has concluded that the increase would be legally justifiable both as a means of raising additional revenue for street construction and maintenance and as a means of discouraging non -industrial uses. A tax increase will require voter approval at a general or special election. Under the state Elections Code, a special -12- election on a measure submitted to the voters by a legislative body can be scheduled between 88 and 103 days after the call for the election. It is recommended that August 17, 1999 be targeted as the date for adoption of an ordinance increasing the tax and the necessary resolutions for scheduling the election. This would enable the Council to schedule a special election between November 13 and November 28, 1999. Staff recommends that the maximum parcel tax rate of the warehouse and transportation related uses be increased to $20.00 per 100 square feet of gross area of land. It is recommended that the parcel tax be capped at $20.00 per 100 square feet, or .20� per square foot. Further, this parcel tax should however be allowed to increase based on the consumers price index. The parcel tax should apply to warehouse, distribution trucking, wholesale, and transportation related uses including railroad facilities but excluding railroad spur tracks, cold storage and refrigerated warehouses and warehouses producing substantial retail sales. The tax should be specifically applied to the following uses: 1. Warehouse, distribution and wholesale uses are defined as follows: A building or portion of a building used primarily for the storage of non-perishable goods or non -refrigerated perishable goods intended for distribution to other locations or the sale of goods for distribution to other locations for wholesale or retail sale but excluding any wholesale, distribution and -13- wholesale uses which generate retail sales in excess of $5,000,000 and whose point of sale is at the subject site, and also excluding cold storage and refrigerated warehouses; 2. Cold storage and refrigerated warehouse is defined as a building or part of a building used primarily to store nondurable, perishable goods under refrigeration including services for processing, preparing or packaging goods for storage; 3. Trucking uses are defined as any lot, building or a part of a building in or on which goods or freight are transferred or redistributed from one vehicle to another, or any lot, building, or part of a building used primarily for the storage, maintenance, or servicing of highway type vehicles carrying persons or property including but not limited to trucks and buses, excluding however commercial repair facilities. 4. Railroad facilities are defined as railroad yards used primarily for the switching of railcars, or transferring freight or goods from a railcar to another vehicle. 5. Retail sales are those sales in which the City receives to of the sales tax. Attached as Table 3 is a list of properties that as of June 1999 the tax would be applicable to. Based on this list the City would receive approximately $321,000 for each penny of special parcel tax applied. At a parcel tax of 20G per square foot it -14- would equate to $6,420,000 which is nearly equal to the shortfall in the Fiscal Year 1997-98 budget. report.parceltax -15- TABLE 3 Page 1 of 13 Cl O m cD (D (D m 00 Cl (D m co 0 CD (R cq a a W t- .-st 00(+oM lgtU')oo t� cD� �tt+��cDOc� CO ���`M?000cc* VMOOV (co 6(6 �0c0�tV(�t��t c� C6(OOrf�gt00 ¢q��3twcDl�OrnNN�tff�d3�tNrcOu0`NO� i7 (~) 6i E!3 (i9 6N9 b9 d9 � b9 d9 (� � -7 cq w �_ Lr 0000(D(D(D OMB-N00 V.to000(D 0000OoLOf\ -It0C) C'7 Cnt`(Dtr)v-(()O(DOM Ci OO C? (D tq 0 (D (p 1� 2 M M et (O (ct C! tq "t to C) J U) COlgt '�N(OD�OrnNNCCV) CCDr(Qcir000hNOOi Nco-0)N a r (D(A ti- CC O N N ,- X -' a F- } F- cc: w a z< o O �o¢o U ° cc - °d ~ o a oQo� Z � ¢ w U �� O w z rn Z w0l-o�U < Q z °b 3 Y WzOwOOO: o ¢ rn O V O a¢ oU m U U U J o F- O O O O O O O z O O O w r F-2UJp 2���¢UZ000UUUU¢UUUo X �Y�UQQ�¢���Qa��¢¢ wzZa<LL UU-I- U- LLLLLLLLLLLL�ELLLLLLZ J �H�¢damzZOononon0o0(nCn2n0 w J0 mo000¢ w Y Om=zzzzzawz m z zzzzw CC wOJ¢mOZZZ F-¢F-�-hE-F-F-F-pf-1-I-Q a w ww > >V o00000000000> Q MN^OOoCDC5(5C) o0000(c)(c)MOpCC)0000 COC'0CoC0Chc�C�o0a000ChCDM0000M(Cj(cyj((jMM0-0-rM L j M 0000 00 co cr. (D (D (D (D (D CD (D 00 M 00 (D 00 N (D (D (D (D (D (D N r- 1� 00 00 CO ;0 M f� t\ t` ti .-- O 0 0 0 0 0 0 00 pp p 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0~~ Z O p T - 0 0 0 0 Z cc v J U (D00M --MLf> 00MNm(0f-MOO ctNM�.- '- O `- ♦-- 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 (� O O O O O O r O 0 0 0 r z cc 999Qoo9o0OoT9TC o Oocoowp00ocwp 'i N N N COCO CO CtO � rn rn (1) f� rn (� rn rn 0) 6 6 6 6 C� 6 6 i d O NNNNNNNNNNcomcom, 9 0 0 0 O O O O p 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 CD (D (D MOornrnrna)(DNNCV NNNNNNNNNNNNCVNco co co tD (D0 0 O CA Cn CA CA 0 0 0 l(') In (ti L() lf) (!� Lt7 (1') (!i In Lf') (!) Lf) Lf) �-- e-- N LO LO Ln to L() TABLE 3 Page 2 of 13 N ID NNNO'ct08�}CO0 N�tAr C�M �tN(DOOtiO(Drr<O%r-��a r- am V •-rN�T�Uj6C7Cp�r��A�cC EqC C coMNM't0CDNrNMMIZ-It- "I' 0) co �O CO�lr-- fA cpt0 ttc000wOt� Orwtrj (fl0 (Dcm0)(flE�3(fl Q ' EJjr --6"'N cq -fir zr,:65M69 69 69 69 69 69 69 69 69 6969 (fl W W CO _M > o a) N(OM Nc� NlAtpr�C,- '0� d W'ct (o rr'N Cntqrn000. V W 0tCO.,Nt�f�O�! �00�0 NcMO(MO�cODO�OCO00000t rnO�c�OMu �cAOl� cOttu�6 0 N N .a. dv B: 0 X J a } U W > Z W U U Q a U 1--0 UZZ f- H o Z U p -� Wuj ir Z U W U U W Q= rn Z gZp�0 Qai3 —z9cc 0 J(1) WOMU JOZ U QW Q W� Qlrp Cb 3 � 3: co � p� F-Q rn 0 QUQmmO Z-� wco�OWF-o[? QF-QZ C) QW2Z�UWW QSCLMDacnzLIJ >a-> W W> aZ(!) OwxQUQmaOpW UJ ¢� c� < Q��pW(n��00<—OWQW-J JZ� JQf-cr� �F cn p�Z�J}ZcnQpWWOQJWMO JOOML' PpW w_QQpJ=LL= CCW—W=cc W �ZLLf2 LLJ WO>f'O3: UpW=NZW W U �0=,�-X >F-W�mQv�yZCO)CL w�w�eo-�n Q 3: -3: YcwnQ���¢�WzaaYvmU.0¢ov a w w 0 UO N 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 O �Oa(DMC) +000rrNOONOr r M M c`') C) CO N M M M 0 0 (� O N CO r (� M N� M- CNM M CO C`0 cM Cl) cM CO CO co C'M CO M M CO M cM M c M 0') O M M CO m M M W 3 � ti ti (D c0 O0 O0 c0 c0 03 00 CO (D f— T N r" ♦— e— r r r- e— (0 (D CO CO (D c0 O 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Z r— O O .— .— O O .— — r— r 0 •• Z v cc W W D) � O N CO M 0 N 00 M O. T U) N c0 O M t19 cD O (� r--. 0�. r NM ct.-(�J. NNN— .-N0000 z cc 0004ogc9g0000000944a0000o0 Q *-�-�NNCMchMco � I b W I d ---- N N N O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O 9999 Q Q Q Q Q N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N :t "t �'t � "t �t V 000000000 00000000 lf7 (D (0 cM0 W c0 cM0 cM0 (0 (00 10 cOD (0 (0 (0 cMD O TABLE 3 Page 3 of 13 �t00NOO',TOOChw�h0)m"MM00O'tw-1- 'V• CDMCi t,,:CC)OM erMNtQtt r` 'Nt•`tgIgCO NCDMMh00 C �I�wNC9�MMt'Mtr.CM C%irna�m ttom- NCDACA EAdct�3ic�iCl) D(D QM2MN4mCI NGH 2 er%2 o U ,��� 69 EA (i3 (n w ti- v J CnCDCONU)M1-N tCr) to r001,NMMCO co Mnf-00OC7MMNtgrtp�si MtA '�tnNe-N't N'CY NNNtoNChf-tp0)tgtgt�MNf�rMcoopMj'*!' d (0 CV (A ^ 00 C9 t- � Co CA tp M CV t- to C; <D N �- tq CD p to (p to .- M a a C`ONOMtoco rCOto `�t0000N(DOtoCO`tt r O � r to �••- r r Cb Ir O X a } tZ _ �-- cc d U z Z a °� cc Z UO W H OU cca H Z CC � U>UCO �Z- w~ 1= C) C 3 O noOZ Q01---Z }OZ>-0< =w-57,m c -jQ � w Oz--xw Opo OI-1-�- < h -�a rn `- �cdQmw--1U,_,¢oCF-www-jwZOOO QO �wDU--JUwoawmwZUUWRO000 OOO 0°�ir Q aa_ Z � Q z m 0 Q w Y Q Q J Z Z Z W F- i-o_wwZW< J LLJU Q w-ja_wQw U c- w- w O Z a Li Q m m F- U x x x O m cc zN=UZZWYzmZYccacawapp1=5�Qzcn QQwU>-w=z)Qaw¢��oozaQa f-�o=� C7aaU�Q==a_cncn3aOC'3C7C7cncn_,•UM a w U w w M Cl O �V o00000O00000000p0000>0000 OOOrrrp(V .rpNMNNMrMMppppOO CO M M CO M M CO Cl) C) CM r 07 CO M M <h w f� M co r O N r r C7 M M M M M M M M M Cl) M M M M M M M M M M `' M M M co cc 3 L� r cD cD cD (D (D (D (D (D (D (D (D cD (D cD cD cD cD cD cD cD cD cD cD cD cp f_ Tw r Ar r r wr• Ar' r r_ �i z► Ar- 0 0 0 0 O O O 0 0 0 0 CD 0 0 0 O O(D CD O 0 0 0 O O r r r r r r .- O r Li Z w > w V cc f� CO M O N (D (n N CD ti O (D CO M O CO M O to t- N (D r CO Or r-NNNNCD -- -N - rrNNNMMMOOr- (O (DQ Q O r: Q. n9999999999999999999999999 ((DD (D w 0o0 M CD COO C)C" 0) (n 0) 0) 0) 0) 0) 6 6 6 6 o00000000000 0000o0000rrr 9 g 0 0 0 0 0 0 o q O 0 0 0 0 0 0 o O 0 9 0 0 0 0 N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N 0 0 0 CD 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 CD CD 00 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 co M co co M co co co M co co co co M co co co co co co M co co co co (D CD co (D (D (D (D CD (D (D (D (D co (D (D (D to (D (D (D to (D (D (D co TABLE 3 Page 4 of 13 {.: t(')10 a(0hM0N00atq w,t, r-cD +� C?O'ctccV?shcm (5cotoC-4, (DOMO�t0NNrM00CV)pOjO (% 0'ttot,�tccN(��o9D(�3tiNl^Otc[—��C�N�O�lC(M��OMO�tMq(�D�p�O�OscO�- Q b9 Eft v) 69 -" (fl (� Eft y9 0 c� c0 t1 a0 NN 69#to O tq �t U � �d9dN96s� (� �� m w CC tv L tgtga00(DNcAN000to -----�� (0`to CO OOOC9t'. C)COgCmr(00q(pOCD 0 tq'ItCIC7cDtgtMtgAMg(D N000MNO ItttotOMOtqa00N)tg00N00c9f-N(0wcmtoCM00OACDco 'V O VtONCVco CO A CV) (0 CA CO N N O to tq co 0 F- '� N '- N •- ct cc O x Q Z Z cc W W Q 0a. D U = H Z O-O w cn CL w } CC C Z OU Cr m 0 w t- U�wE-a) z000000m<w LL w ij - ZUUUUzQ3w (00-- oQF- O UUUO' rn ZFFoId<0<D-= F- UpOQw �¢ZcrY�ZZO=UUUz w�UwZ OQOzC�X mbm>wO<O cc w-�Z zOOaQrOno Q 00000}WUOUOU�zU>Z W=w<owmaaQo c� c� F->� F-a <Zz�j }}}}OWO Omwzw°�WWzO?Z¢?ZO wCO<<<*W WJWQm(�wZQQQ>"oti��tA(n�CC cr-mQQQQ QQWQ Q_]..]0 WQQDJOF- --����cn>u.>�m>--�=Q¢CO>==U¢z(n a W W w U� > > V CD � C:)000000000MtgooOo(:DC) O O r.-�.-OOo.-.-000_0.--cr)--MOO.- = MMCOCOMNCOCMCMOccjCMOCMOCOCCOOCOOMMCMOMMCMOMC�CCOO cam.) W � a (D (0 (D (D (D (0 (D (0 O CD (D (0 (0 M 00 (0 M M (D (0 (D(0 (0 00 00 A T T O O O O O O O O O O Oa O O CD O O (D CD O O O O OD 00 O O Z t W W r N M (D ti CO to ti N d N co t- M — ---—--O�tO, NN,-. NNNNNCOOO rNNN(� z cc 99999999999999999999 99c)Q t Q .- r- .- N M 'It V- v �t tO tO (D (D r, r,- t,- r� ao ao rn 6 d d d 99N99999999999NN9 CV NNNCV NNo 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 CCCDCDCCCCCC0 0 0 0 cMD cMD cM0 cMD (MD (D (00 (MD (MD (MD coM(MD (MD (0 (0 coM<M0 (00 (D(MD (0 (MD (MD TABLE 3 Page 5 of 13 MCO W W "Cr 0 0►l-MN(0CD r (OOCO r OO[tMMwrprCati(O �t(ONrCnNCO CMNdgr 05666666106f�h(0c0(O�t� tO0 co OO co co0)0''tINM200MMMtoMC") rco69 coocr) l0 M O In In CK O _� tlY 69 f��� U d9dN9b96r9b9 H3 (f3 G9(l369 w CC ti- � rCOMMU7'cf'f� r-I�MOr r1�OrNN(Ol�(�Dti�O N C000ON CO Q!c!4= NC?rNC?Mf� rCOMt'tC O(pc�p wrrCp J 0coItl�N(2(Ooo ct t�Q VCi�t CO M _ �COMNN J co (OMOst r cOCO�M�COCgCDOa01�(00 V'CO(OCO(O�(O 0 � rNCOrr �� r o Ir 0 X J Q w Z Z Z F- F- F- CL m 0 (!) w m w cc Q 0 H _ a<<z CC�O m w w J w w U� FAQ 000< LJwQ Q JZFQ-F- Cb 3 �wFw-ZZ��W ¢z_Q�w F�--jjQ aU�< ¢ w >- Q o rn O w>¢¢-OOw F- ccw Z F"�iF='=o< rn a.zaNOoom cr2um��F-wwmwz�wmo-�Z OponOo COW W,MZWF->H>=zmwZ=O x a:Z(nccwcccc _IYw�=��Q�aQ�sm n. wmmwwOOoww _I o-i Fa- Cl) ccl'"-��o Jzm=Fm�oo m�>��aa00 mOOmQ—xWUZF-MF-LL F-CC O 2DcA =00¢wira zw-wma-cn to zmzV?a U kQZmaC7C7F-Vim>LL ZOCOiLUF- zQH a c� w LU w 0 > >V o000000000000000000000000 O oCMMoNC7N0(nCpChaMMrInC)aNOOONOco COMMM(M(Mccic�cMO(co(mMcMCMOMcMo(h�Mto mC.Qm ONC\l w (� N (`) (`3 M N N a CC �o co co CO CO CO Cp CO CO 00 00 co Cp co co CO CO CO CO cO C0 Co CO co F- ryM� MM T MMr r r M ry� rMM� r• ryTry�� f� w A co co co co CO 00 co 00 co W�� W CD W 0 0 W W ;-D ;-D W 0 1` 1_ I O O O O o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Z o0000Ooo00000000000000.- ,0 - Z y� w w w O M CtC\l�tU3U)C')00-O'�O'-N' LID —C� .-MC)CDMCO gggga���Q NNr- C)CD 'CDC70oc*DC) z goQ000000Q00001001 N N N N N N N N O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O o 0 o- Q400000000000000000000000 0000000000000000000000000 M m co co co co co m OD Cl) m CO m m C7 C ) co Co CO co co co co co co (D co CD (D co co (D CD CD (D CD co to cD CD (D co CD cD co (D (D CD CD CD TABLE 3 Page 6 of 13 (O O O r p r (O CO V et O CO 4 N NCO to CD r� ;n (0 CON.-MOChCnCAp�(n(OCRgR CON(h CO "It ll OR ItN coCO DV,69 MONwNaw it tDcnMchcr) 0icM(Ooi y co0mNf: c)aN(01o000`�f4 0 c'!r In CA �t �t0f�N1�t�ONcD(0 tOTN.- ¢ E9 Efl �-- E9 fA Efi nj fi3 69 G9 (fl r r Eli % 0% fib U (s (fl 69 � W (n tr d L (()OOf�CAr(O f�NCO ct �f C)W NNCO(naMr- r- co CONS-MC)gMwQ)2�000OOCn 00 Cl) chOtAO`gt'�TMO 000)cOCO NM CO `(t �tCAf�ttN J (OtnMM MNOiMCOCA ui CO CD'�tM.-e}Of�NtOhOCOd vi OCOC7-�NOist .- J (OOI�N(�ln(Ofl.NN(0(C) CO . -NO Nto r cc O X -' Q U z Cl- 0 U z Y w uw 0- W H n~. w Z c=i) Z O w F- Q Z z cr FZ- o tr �mQ o Q Q F- p a--3 4. w �IJw mZ W Z Om Z CC wZ ¢ Z a� CL Cb � ZW< Wa >- ZZcr- F-M o) wamWa0 c=namoom<O-QWOQ ='= a _ J F.. aow-w Z�<Qw��w"-mc=nwF-o�m.`Da ¢F- J m�uQ> QJ=azw<WZW=2WZ==�Qw� JWOW}Q�oa �'jwZl�W(jQWQDW��IQi a,cnzcoaawzU-ccircrzF-am¢F- __ W �QJnwJ¢wwwp¢m QrcAmm y.U<cn cc ¢Fw-¢¢�¢ppY¢OOmmZ>>--5<<<WN> Q cnmm=¢mmYO=mo OMZ�`D�tccn�cca¢ L.Crz a w ww V) (1)a > >V o000000000000000000000000 O OOOOCr)OOCQrcpOpMONOMMN r"rCMOrr 'ctMf*rMMrc+7MM rNCONO3ODcococMaOchCOMCMM = Mcr)m mc")MM(�')M Ch chMc�cOMcgc+)coc^O(,)M(hcoM w cc Q 3 00 co 00 00 M 00 OD 00 00 00 CO Co M 00 co 00 00 00 00 00 00 co co 00 ~ N ti ti fl- �� iz r r r r r r r r L z r r r r r r r r r r r O p O p p O O CD O o 0 0. O O Or r r r r r r r r r r z vXX � W W W M N CO �(D O N (n (() O N 0) p CO rY (n r N (0 f` O Nt to N V 0 0 0 0 O O r p 0 0 0 0 0 0 r O O r z Q Q o 9 o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o CD o CD CD p p CD p o 0 tz cc 4 4 wV)cotoO.. . .. N NNN . . i Y tL r' r r r. N N N N N N N N N N N CO N N Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q pi Q Q Q Q V Q O 999999999 O O O O co O O co O co O co O O co O O co co O O O co co co � Cl) (MO (MO (MO (MO (MD co (0 (MO tM0 to to(0(MO tM0 cM0 (00 (MO cM0 co (D (D (MO to TABLE 3 Page 7 of 13 W) CO r CO MMCr� C3 I t O M W M CD M 't co 0 0 0 .— thOOlt�l[)cD�YcOa O00 OOrMWU')(nMNcocor'ct' m00CV ICit-:uic000CV t�6`4CV 666C6If)6t-:1 NMLONCO�O�tN tN m w � m > o a) U)(D NrCO MmwU)00c0 0 Ch 0 m w to co `ct co �t m Cl OO r O0 C7 W M 0) 0 CO (0 0 0 'qT rn OO N It) t� Iq cc OO N t% cO N Iq Iq CIL IQ r Ci7 r Iq ti �! C7 M �tCot-�Cooco 0OO(Ot_: www J co ---M—�� rr��! NCOM0N VNt-N((DD� 0U') O F- v �n In X O X J Q F- } U . ~ z W 0 0 ¢ � F- t- ar w CC m _�_j F- H~ o am fA W -H_3 Q CCW Q w--�F- 3 QZ= IS-Szrr 0902 OQwO O zoa— t-_Cc C)�-F�-wm~_jMX Lu ?pg00 J Q��O-�JJ�ZQZIi- JWC/)0Om}}Q X ��0ZC>00OQwU_WXt.-QOgOQ0-ZZW < CD1_ Om-'-�SSS(9a�Z1-^�Zqo—ZLLF- LL <=�O_OZ UWSSUUUZM<".E<=OQJww-joo ObE J OWoW*Uif2P Ho c'JO-SUU- W W ZZ F-1-F-00 _3ILDcj'JQp' Q<< -W ZZF. M a O w w w w¢ 0 m= O z a¢¢° Q O w 0 Q¢< w Q ¢u�a000cn3mww2Qmm� m�a<< a w ww CO)a > >V oCDOOOOOOOO000000000O000Oo O CCC)OOMMNMOONrrOrrONCoC)CDm O_OM Z M M M Cl) (CM Cl) (CM CM7 CC j CM r0 M r M c'O co M C`7 '14-(y) N M T 00 M M M M M co M M M M M M co M M W 7 OOO_000MO_000OOO_000 OD000000OOMt-t- ,T M 0000000000000000000000000 Zr r r• r T r rfrr r ♦� r r T r T t� T T �� � � "0 Z 0� W L j 11) t'-M M(D to t- _ 1_ M u,3N� M M M O r V r `- O � N N O O r r 0 0 ,- r O O ,- N N 0 0 0 0 z ggoqO9Ooq9CD9OooO000000Waoo < � et ` 14 to In to I1� C>7 (D O (fl M OO N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 C o 99999999999999999999999qq 00000000000o0CDCDCD -s8�000 (MD (MD (MD (MD (MD c(0 (MD co M M (MD c(0 fD (0(0(0 o (D (MD (D C(0 (MO (MD (MD (0 co (DD TABLE 3 Page 8 of 13 NMCOO Ma. W'It OOt-a00WWC4t-Ooam at" a0 C" 7 ssa ( �)? to w N h a co O w �-- , to a N N t,- O C7 O 00 M 'V' It 0 ¢ njrz (�696c,21 b9�HN9EA�fA u6N96Mo201aac�N •-. F- 69 b9 Efl fA b9 69 (fl Z7 U m w to tr > o m F- NcoGoc0� O • to'tL,O0)0) 00LOcoNh,Nrn(0coOt,OO iL C\ls CIL0)00 "OON t�0)c7t�cO �-tnONttt�.-MOcoMIo t� <n cO C'O Cli rl cp 'CT <q t� O 't It cO m .- m 00 t% 10 r J Q stCN�ttO00t-a'IT�<nC7C)0totoa V'Otoca W)cotz0 J (n N,- r N�ttANNC7Nc0 fit.- NOtpOO'CtMm r- ir 0 X Q F- U ~ = m ¢ a F- CLw ¢¢�O° U2 w O ir O O wO _Ucc ¢00 W U Up M cc OZZ �(!3ZgwZ F- Z Z0 C) w UW¢ 0 wdw Zp W W¢tr rn zMZ Om WZ¢M 'oF- r O Y¢ZaUpaz�ZO 0()'ap NQp-JQ) rrmww>mh-a<-~-jIW0<J�UJ ¢W j°zmOwjwQw> jjwzCwwwpUirx ¢EW0m H UMLL=5ul cc�QM(!)�CZpU(nJ Jm�ZZ J ZQNJ0WXZ:0 LwzzOplwwJ-�W ZJ(Al�J1Ja0w LU LL U QYwW¢WMMOW WYF-J¢UZF-ZZ1-.3JF—wF- -ja 3:0cwO �¢iC700w<cr mm0U-U-UCiY3.}UU' a w w w CO W a > >V OOOo0o000000000000000CD>00 O OCM Cl) ONr0M7 C)—N NO r C) NONNNOOrN = 00 co 0") M CIO Cl) co CM c� Cc j CMO co M co q) co M V) CY) m CC) V3 V) cMO cm w a 3 �00wmmmm00mm00000000mmc000_oo_o�rmcooaoo_oa_o f m t\ t) tD t) t` tD tD tD C) tZ t` tl_ tl- t\ N- I. t-- tl- m t_ P- tl_ � � 0000000000 0000000p0CD0C)0OO Z C:) r' T T r T r� r' O rCD W CD TNNCr*�MT MTN0z cc CDOOrOO0M'cLOV 000000C999 9999999QQRQRoQ0oo C04., LOWQCDCDr� Nr066666 T T T T T r— T - N N N N/L OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO O000OO Cl Cl O O O O O O O O C7 co m co Cl) Cl) Cl) co co co co C`) co m Co co M M ch c� OM Cmmm )O O CD(D CD CD CD CD CD CD CD CD CD cD CD CD CD CD CD CD co co CD Cfl (D CD (MD co TABLE 3 Page 9 of 13 wOco0to(Dvrn0CGw0 N'M rOi.o.~-Mc� •- tOrnhmcO.:GOc'701n.-.- O'(t CM 0) CO Uj t0 c(00 ch M C7 to N ui �M.+-� ..0i .- cp p �j f� N O `ct c0 (o Q� 609 Ofii M(a � ^ 61va 61a60<4696699<469 0 a 69 69 w (D v U)a(oC)U) 'd CAOco(gMvNNM C)C)NM U)M0)-4t'COco•-CO MOOS-tG qtO)(D c+ C). C) NCO(0 CO)CO to (q Cl ch ti c7 U) CV to y- CO O (O O V � N C%l C) CO 0) ...i ( f+ •- c7 O) to CO CO C6 t-ca CO c6 .- t�: cp 40 C 0 0 tf) a0 t� f� Oi c� Qj J <Dstc0cOc0.-NOf- NM'�i cAc01�NcoNN.-c\jNN—.- 0 i- CL O x J Q f- � U Z cc L7 U _Z Z Z cc = 0CC = w w w WO< xz J c� w -� QozZ <UDmw Uz= IrH-O W a Z o- a- w W L _ U C) Z �Q W irQQ _!-1 ozz�OW=wU f- 07 06 U0�� wZ_j<---a_ �'5J O O Z U W Q.� Z x 0 0� J Ln W_j Q w Z P Z Z ,- gact)M2000UQ¢>-ta-=k>Ma-<W<OW= a=Z¢�0<<�-2z¢a�zUwowOOxZowWO zzr <XxzowOmmoo(n�azxwf-w J 9 z z z y (nf-tnZwF-�Ma � am Xtn W �O�cOnau�u�zwZwwwza-0w03waw ~¢ C� Q Z ccZ w o p O rrow o w U w} d (c c o <zi W w=-ILrQY=QQU> W QwMM<W Q -U=X 000 7-�C7aOt-aUnw>-Ou-ULcn�: IL w ww CO (na O U O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O N O 0 0 0 O MMNMNNNMNMr'�-NNNOO.-O.-MOOTT MC7MMMMMCM7MccjMMMMM.-C7Mf�MM� .-MM MMMMMch M'-MMMc7c�(� W cc a 3 M V gg-,TNNd'et-'r co NCOco etco co coco MOO t� ODO (D (D (00 N N (D CO W r .- .- .-- (0— .- _ _ cD CO OO O O p 0 0 0 0 0(D M^~~ ti CO ti ti ~ ti izz^ N- t ti Z 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 �-000000000—D—aC �O—.--,- 0 r r r cc J _ t� > U CO- N M M� CD M � M M �t cY O N N O (D a U) M M (D CO r- N M M M M Ut M 0 .- M cc c�99999999999QQQQOO0000000 0- NdN N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N Y n' 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 ,� 0 0 0 999999 O O O O O O O O co M co co Cl) CM co M M co M M M M co co co M M M M c7 co M M (D cD (D (D cD (0 (D CD 10 (0 (D (D (0 (D (D (0 (D (D (0 to (0 M (D (D (D TABLE 3 Page 10 of 13 {� 000'( r,r,OMCV O NM.--t,-w(0m 41tMOppa�-w +� (DoI�I�00( w7cocor-Ow cr"N(Daw OO 6 I-: CO CD 1� CV (D CO M O) Op ct 00 N eY !� e- t� N M M (V .= (� m ��tiNN 0�6900 NCp�O��C��h'^d N �difAb9fAb9�� (�39 �� �GHEiib9'�� w > o ti" OODtO d CO NM M N -CV ce) t-(D(0M V'OOtoC rCm^ (D O O I : C) Go Oi rlt C:i Lq ci N (O J Q OMOarN���NN� M� tom•-•-•-N o00tntOQil�d N --� co (0 r ON r+-CO N'I-IT(0M(0NNN O H CL 0 X a o ~ z a w m a: Q n. m I- CO o I- � ¢~0z z z xm w U >- O I- a >- w w a F- E- = aJ_Zm°oCp3mmzm�- p 0 YYo¢ rnw CZ0 Uwzz <0wU OO UtzO LLJ�w Z�Z�prn O Zm0C.ZZcnti�O�2w0 >¢50-QM¢Z¢U>owawac ir (x ir0azww1)CC W Z 07zU-�>Uw >O>=wZ='<ZwzZzp�OmUWW3 �a z w=¢¢QZ0ZI= (1)P IL CDQz==�-um0 QZO_¢O=900<m-�z>a0Za(-)NZ¢w p='wMUM-jm<o o?o=lawo-=9=Y OQ¢O -tC<XM<O0¢U¢0 CO a w ww U) Wa O U c D o O O o O o O O O O O o 0 CC0 0 0 O O O O O O O N O O N o _O M O r o O CCO o M O O = MC0MM(V)�~-CCONM OOCO mq)0CNC7O00CM0(Mp� CMM CO CO N CM C) CO CM M (Y) OO C`') CM Cl) w O 00 M M 00 M (D (D cD cD c0 cD cD CO (0 M L r �— � ;D r r r /_ �_y 0y0� (D co (D co (D co (D f (� W W W 00 00 00 CD 0 (D m 00 h I,- I� 1l- 1� 1-- t- 00000000 0 0 00 0000000000000 Z r000000'-r rpp rr� O .-rrr vuu � W > U OQrMNN"�M('It NI �',OpN o—o NCD rO N-000-0000 :7 Ir g T Q Q T T T 9 T O OO OO T 9 r r 99999999 r r a M000000000000000000000000 x 99999g0000Q99999 9999999999999999999999999 CO 00 00 00 co co co 0o co co 00 0o co 0o O co 00 co 000 0c0 0o 0o 00 MMCO')MCco��00 (O COOOCO)c) C�C�C� cMmcv)ccocOe)()cc) CD (D (D tD (D (D (0 (MD (D 10 co <00 (MD (D (D (D CD (D (D (0 (D (D CD (D CD TABLE 3 Page 11 of 13 (ON�t00 ct f�00CCUt�-(DmOONCON f- O?CACAr''�t0'cthOCOMCACnNOf�NM r (NOtj`Md'lqWQtj. 0~00�0'�t<O0C<vjc!cd'�1'rrN06vi000M'iC_00 c! lri0 N �- Nrt'I�tCOat-t�(�'� �ChMQh0pppCpappcort��- MM Q <flEH69d9<fldN9<flEl�d9� fAOr O6RCfl�<9Efl60969 CO CD CO t0t�� W69 69 bN9 � 6% I 69 63 tr � p d MCO NIT W O�-MCD W ��0000N(ONI�N.-000 CA1:0 2 ^MNrt�NC9 <p 10 V 0,M �?OLN rrv--'it00MCOC'7ll OOOMtnO J CO CD.-'<tC00t`M (DCO OOCgt'-CO<0�-- rMt'- - --) to rN.-!n'-C4 03coICONCO� M W O M(D�<COOCOOW O - cc O X Q } cr 1-- w u- a w �ZCL �� uj cr- cc <ow 0 Q0 o FZ CC F- cr F- -� M JO -j CE "—� C) W w Q P Q Z Q Q cr cc m � h-- _l O °' 3 TWO w� Cr LL w `LFQ —aZ rnO WX OF-MOOMOVVFm-Q MXM <Y Oa OWpUUF—Zad> F— F—w1- �` w0Fw-O J>2�-}�z<T00 Z02C0�2Q<=OUc2i) X a�wcn0�?Q�wQZ 2 Q <OX¢i>-0LLWZJWF-Q23: wz H>'ars J wQOJ=Zw2pt]Fw-waaco:) 0=mJ=..jap} W cc W2wzzCO �Z�N�22200ZQZ U 2 Q Y� X x Q Q m >Z w Y 2 2 O W U w? O g m 0 Q W-J2ZwWUF-F-Q�FJ_-a2fFW..CD.32;�O�Fr Q2CLca �wUiztL��QQW�F-Qc��r��cnorOMEcco ul.� a W w w U)p UO O O O O O O O O O O O O O N> 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Q O_ NO.-00_OMCV COMMC700(D (D.-00000 Co M M Cl)MC� M CMO C0 00 CMg M M M M M m cr) CO CO CO cr) c - N co <Y) W (`)MMC7C7C7MC'�(7(7C'�MC') Fr- Q 3 Fes- <O (O (D (D (D (D co M co co (D co (D co (O (O co (D (D (D (D CD (D 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Z•- --- --- --- --- -- '- O O O O .- �-- ,-- .- ,-- .-- C) ,-- .-- p .- .- Z cc -j LU LU '- OOCOmOerCn(DO0tot`CA.-00MMt\O<'7-t-, NO N N N C9 N C) � 0 0 �-- .-. N N N co CO O cr.000000000O000 *- N C� O Q 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ID < o00o dcST�NN�vv�rv(n(i�16Loto nwC6L6 Qgg0000 .- .- OO m m m c0 00 00 oQO oQO aQ0 0A0 am0 omo m m OO OO OO CO M CD 0M M Co' 00 CO2020(C`oCo('�MCOMMCOMMMco C07CoC,)Co 000<000 CD (D (D (D (D (D (D to (0 (D CD CD CO (D co (D (D (D (D (O (D (D (D (D (D TABLE 3 Page 12 of 13 r-m(Dot--(0 wcn ),D �mt-AM'!gq q(Dt-:gCR l-Zt (h McoN�~ aW tof-- Ot--wmWch<OCRCul�-,,tM'tOt)(OMONcGV �T�M ti NN cl (.0O(0(OprD(t(0coM��N6�M< ^ 69f69H6%69k60 � r(� O O E1369 m w � 60 •; v CO {� 'ct in O o t' (D (O CO CM ") `Q' M t� (n M F F COfit' co co coco (y f�MCOaWCOtoNcoto0M(0(04m �7 COV*cocociU) c0CMcaOticor- Ocj(OCDN COONNcvit J J (p0 f` MN Q h(MONC�(gti^(mo((0C) O��(O(Dto) (0 co CD rr NC)CN(Olo 0 Q X -i a E- W m a Y m � a. O za U m'j0 M OU w�_ui(0 ¢ w Jw CC O C) z Z��(n W ¢ Z Z O U rn 3 acn�¢z Q m ¢¢�W0)Q zU¢ Q m�zwaw a,crf-= =>-o��=-ink z~ 0N0_j0 0 H �- XMo ] r=ate— m<c w�-� OQO np U ¢UwM crJ0:0QzML�Q w5 zwmwu-MMz-NDNQcCc z¢¢¢zUO[—C- gYmmOzzz�-Uw �c�X p aaa.p-j¢3¢U-p cn¢oZW wm0[¢=wZw<-i1-- U ¢O�Xmmmz'o00�zM¢ _ w¢to00>>-NXO:c0Y>LDY���a W w w O > O >V o0000000000CC::))00000000000 O M M O cr) cr) �) M 0 0 0 0 0 0 M M Cq N O N M V) CO M O C') M C'') M O c� (`7 r- co t`) W �-- r (D �-- V-- M M M C`7 t7' CO Ch M M N c`3 c`) m c`) c ) CO Cl) (`) M CO CO N CM C7 c`') M M () (7 C ) m � Q ~ t� t� � t(r0 (0 (0 (D (O (D to 00 CO CO OD (0 (O (D CO d' O O O O Z Q O O-- O O O0 00 QO QO p O O O O O O O CO co co 0 0 0 0 0 0 Z 0 (D vX � u W > Z w U) O N N C7 O r\ V O•-Nc`')(`') ct ci c7 torn Mt tom.-OO(nOMNOvmv 00 OQ9999CD O rNm CO(D(D(DtDQ 169999999999999999999 0- N.tm(D (D (DNN.,I.'ct94444449z? ?? 44444444g000 MOMMOOOcoOOmMCOCOmmmmmMm (0cocomCOcoc)coc0000Maaa TABLE 3 Page 13 of 13 1S4100000tOMtACDOt� Ci<ncq"t CD00r MOrtiONCOCDOM CO Mr-' q,ciQi�njttj�tmato —,tf--Qif,- M M CA C7 r CO �} r (� ^ O t— to co to O Q CV � t"t�69Pz 69(fl69ab69 Coco g?, V69 to 69 to69 � W d v CC)MMO�mctDO�MCN,) tDat, .t �tOO in fwOf�N�r�Mt�rWaN000D00 cM� �tC�At1rtnr�tiOr J N�00 d ^ONONO)NNf��a000m0mMOccow((0 O H IY O x J Q F-- Z Z W a O 0 0 0- -j t-r rr rr cc U >-WZ0000000 a xw=�ZZZZZZZZZ } w aCO ZW<>WO000000 z T JZI— L LL Q -- Zm00 W(rOZ<UOmmmm0)0 aOOJWLWWWWWw�wF-w wI»» >WQ>UQU»i- UJ Q lnD��OMm> JJ_l.JJ_J—j Q Z aa- tLQ ECLa- F E- J �Mcn-Ju- m 00000000ow U 0a9aOaP-irz00 3;:3: ��Zzz OC U5W rn-jxnO)wmUComxxmOmmm Q �oOJ.-cpLtmtn�UUUUUUUYYY a w W W "' o C.i OOOC')ON<C)>Ot�CV)NcoNNCD NN-00 O NCl) Q:)C rMCMOMMMMMMMC')MNN C� M CO CO 03 C) 07 C') M 07 C0 07 V) c7 M M co C7 co W CC Q Imo- CO 00 - et coco m W co co 0M0 co W oM0 oMp OMO W aM0 t� CD CD O O O O CD O CDO O O O O CD O O Z r r 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 r - O r Z W w W O N O M .- N (`') c0 M N ch V U O r O N N N N N VN CD "'T � 0 0 0 z cc 999999999O000000000 to M rn r� 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 Q 0 0 0 N N N N N N N 0 0 0 a dddddd66cs 6do6N�o CO cco cM0 Ch M C) �-- CO r r r r CM M CO� co co t0 tD c0 COO ((0 CO CO CO <0 <00 CMO cD CD (D C(00 cco 0 M CD IZ N L!] STAFF REPORT SUBDIVISIONS MORATORIUM (May 27, 1999) On March 24, 1998 the City Council of the City of Vernon adopted Ordinance No. 1061 prohibiting the processing or approval of Tentative Maps, Parcel Maps and Lot Line Adjustments. The moratorium on the processing of maps and lot line adjustments was extended by Ordinance No. 1062. (April 28, 1998) In recent years numerous large industrial facilities within the City have closed. Many of these sites -were subsequently subdivided into smaller parcels which encouraged the construction of warehouse and other distribution related facilities. The principal focus of the City of Vernon's General Plan (adopted by Resolution No. 5609 on April 18, 1989, and revised by Resolution No. 6109 on June 16, 1992) is to provide appropriate locations for manufacturing and industrial uses. It also provides for the location of those activities which play a supporting role to manufacturing. Therefore, warehousing distribution and transportation related uses are intended to be located in areas where they will not interfere with manufacturing and industrial uses. 2.4 SUMMARY OF GOALS AND POLICIES "The thrust of the Land Use Element is twofold. First, the goals and policies determine the City will promote and maintain the industrial character of the City and second, encourage the modernization, 1 replacement, or reuse of the older industrial facilities..° 3. GOALS AND POLICIES GOAL 1 PROMOTE AND MAINTAIN MANUFACTURING AS THE PRIMARY LAND USE WITHIN THE CITY POLICY 1.1: Provide sufficient appropriate locations for manufacturing and industrial uses and provide for the location of those activities which support manufacturing (e.g., warehousing and transportation -related uses) in areas where they will not interfere or compete for space with manufacturing operations. POLICY 1.2: Designate sufficient land for commercial uses which are necessary to support industry, in areas where they will not interfere with industrial operations. POLICY 1.3: Continue to permit residential development which supports industry provided that environmental constrains can be mitigated to an acceptable level. POLICY 1.4: Continue to maintain and upgrade City services, utilities, and infrastructure to levels required by modern industry. In accordance with the Vernon General Plan, the City Council adopted Vernon's current comprehensive zoning ordinance on April 18, 1989. This zoning ordinance established the M-2 Zone, which is generally located north and 2 east of the L.A. River, excluding that portion north of 26tn Street west of Downey Road. Within this zone warehouses of unlimited size are allowed and transportation related uses are allowed with a conditional use permit. This area of the City consists of mostly larger parcels. In the preparation and adoption of the General Plan and Comprehensive Zoning Ordinance, the City attempted to place controls on the establishment of warehouse and distribution related uses by limiting the size of warehouses to 50,000 square feet and excluding transportation uses from the M-Zone. In response to this policy expressed in Vernon's General Plan, the development community has reacted by subdividing large parcels into smaller parcels in order to develop and construct warehouse and distribution related type facilities. Therefore, it has become apparent that the principal focus of the General Plan has not been achieved. The Community Services Department has studied this issue and considered various legislative changes in order to properly implement the General Plan's focus and policy of promoting industrial uses within the City. These changes include: 1. Establishing a minimum lot size; 2. Allow existing buildings used for warehousing purposes in excess of 75,000 square feet the ability to convert back and forth between warehouse and industrial uses; Additionally it is recommended that the following concepts be further studied: 1. Create an economic disincentive for warehouse and 3 transportation related uses; and 2. Aggregation of parcels by the Redevelopment Agency. Currently the Comprehensive Zoning Ordinance allows the following uses in the M-Zone: 1. Industry; 2. Residential Dwelling or independent living facility; 3. Residential Unit - temporary; 4. Public facilities; S. Retail and Commercial uses with a floor area of 10,000 square feet or less; 6. Warehouse and Wholesale uses with a floor area of 50,000 square feet or less; 7. Refrigerated warehouses; 8. Vehicle sales, fabrication or repair facilities; and 9. General offices with a floor area of 10,000 square feet or less. The following uses are permitted in the M-Zone with a conditional use permit: a. Retail and Commercial uses with a floor area of more than 10,000 square feet; b. Hazardous Waste Treatment facilities; C. Trash to Energy facilities; d, Petroleum related uses; e. Public Storage facilities; f. Cogeneration facilities; g. Trade Schools; h. General Offices; 4 i. Residential Dwelling. Unit Multiple; j. Accessory Warehouses; and k. Recycled Materials Processing facilities. The General Plan's principal focus is to provide sufficient appropriate locations for manufacturing and industrial uses and to permit the location of those activities which support manufacturing in areas where they will not interfere with and not crowd out manufacturing operations. The City was incorporated in 1905 as an "exclusively industrial City" and subsequent City Council's have adopted policies which were intended to encourage the continued development of industrial uses. The current General Plan continues that long history of encouraging the development of industrial uses. The public policy reasons for maintaining the industrial nature of the City are as follows: - - �1�lF• . iu - � Industrial uses on a square foot basis employ a greater number of people than warehouse type uses. The workers are generally more skilled and therefore have a higher wage earning potential. The City of Vernon is located in an economically depressed area with high unemployment rates. Vernon believes•' that it can benefit its neighboring communities by providing a supply of reasonable paying jobs. Vernon's location does not conflict with more sensitive uses that are commonly found in residential settings. Therefore, industrial use continues to be the highest and best use for the property in the City of Vernon. -� -M .-. M- . - Industrial uses take full advantage of the City's investment 5 in utility infrastructure. The City owns and operates its own Water and Power utilities. A warehouse use typically would have minimal utility use. Water use would consist of drinking water and toilets. Power use would be limited to lighting. The City has invested heavily in providing an* electrical and water distribution system that was designed to serve manufacturing facilities. A Vernon manufacturer versus a warehouse use typically will pay more than its proportionate share of the operating cost of the utility. Where large utility customers take and use utility services, the operating and maintenance costs can be spread among a larger quantity of users and therefore a reduction in the utility rate to the customer will be realized. For example the City of Vernon's water system must keep a minimum crew on staff to operate its pumps and wells. This staff must be available whether the City is pumping one or one hundred acre-feet of water per day. However, the greater number of acre-feet of water that is produced the more the cost can be spread and the lower the price of water service. ONEW .� t.-in., Vernon property, street and rail service was designed to-' serve manufacturing users. Manufacturing use does not require the same number of truck trips which is required of a warehouse distribution center. Therefore, manufacturing was not adversely effected by the City of Vernon's narrow streets and lack of truck maneuvering space and numerous rail crossings. However, the frequent subdivision of large lots with the corresponding development of warehouse distribution causes serious congestion 0 on Vernon's narrow local streets and those intersections with large streets leading to freeway access. Vernon provides a convenient centralized location for businesses. By maintaining a strictly industrial community it provides a home for much needed industries to locate, such as hazardous waste treatment facilities, slaughtering facilities solid waste transfer sites, chemical manufacturers, etc. These businesses would not. be accepted in traditional residential communities, yet they are necessary for a modern urban economy. Due to the size of its residential population Vernon doesn't receive its proportionate share of State funding, which is almost always based on population. Industrial uses usually have expensive machinery that is installed as part of their operation. The County Assessor assesses the equipment within a building as unsecured property. The City receives a small percentage of the property tax for this equipment. If the nature of the City were to change from manufacturing to warehouse uses the income from the unsecured property tax would be substantially reduced. 6. Police and Fire Protection. Vernon has developed and trained a highly efficient police and fire service organizations which provide top quality protection for industrial enterprises. If revenue is substantially reduced, then Vernon will have to consider providing a lower level of service. The presence of an efficient police and fire service in Vernon provides important support to 7 neighboring communities. The City's graffiti abatement program provides additional social defense against urban decay and reduced employment opportunities. For the factors listed above, it is recommended that the City retain its industrial nature. The Community Services Department was asked to recommend legislative changes which will assist Vernon in maintaining and attracting industrial uses. City staff held discussions with the Real Estate Developers in the community to determine how the City's goal could be.achieved. A variety of concepts were studied. Staff reviewed trends of new construction and the existing landscape of the City. It was determined that a broader scope of changes than just restrictions on subdivisions were needed in order to achieve our goal. The following are the staff's recommendations, the concepts that were studied and the pros and cons of implementing the concepts. The Community Services Department has considered numerous programs that can assist the City in reaching the General Plan goal of providing sufficient appropriate locations for manufacturing and industrial uses.. It is apparent that zoning and City policies could be changed to encourage industrial development in the City. It is recommended that the City: A. Restrict the adjusting of Lot Lines or Subdividing of parcels in excess of 3 acres so that only one lot less than three acres is created. Establish a minimum lot 0 size of 3/4 acre for commercial and general office, and 1 acre for all other uses with the exception of residential lots which will be developed in accordance with Section 26.4.3 of the Comprehensive Zoning Ordinance. Each lot shall have a minimum frontage along a public street of 150 feet. City owned property shall be exempt from the minimum lot size and frontage requirements; B. Allow existing warehouses in excess of 75,000 square feet the ability to convert back and forth between warehouse and manufacturing use; C. Increase the City parcel tax on warehouse and transportation related uses; and D. Encourage the Redevelopment Agency to purchase smaller sites and assemble them into larger sites to be made available for manufacturing uses. The following concepts were considered leading to the abovementioned recommendations. I. WAREHOUSE, FLOOR AREA, MULTI -TENANT OR SUBDIVISION SIZE LIMITATIONS A. Elimination of Warehouse and Wholesale Uses in the M-Zone or a Reduction in Size (1) Warehouse Size Reduction: The majority of new development that has taken place since 1989 will accommodate warehouse and wholesale type uses. A warehouse use in the M-Zone is allowed to occupy up to 50,000 square feet on any single lot or parcel. If the City were to reduce the allowable size of warehouses this would proportionately reduce the number of E structures that would be developed for this purpose. Warehouse uses are designed to store products in bulk. By reducing the amount of the commodity that can be stored on the premises the structure then becomes less desirable for this type of use. Large distributors would be forced to warehouse their product in multiple buildings reducing their efficiency. It should be noted that importers of high priced smaller items or wholesalers that do not have a full range of products do find the smaller buildings desirable. However, an undesirable effect of such a policy could be an intense development of warehouse use buildings that would be just under the size requirement set. When the City set the size requirement for warehouse uses at 50,000 square feet in 1989, the vast majority of buildings built since that time have been less than 50,000 square feet. (See Appendix Fortunately this size building can accommodate both manufacturing and warehouse uses. If the City sets a limitation of a 25,000 square warehouse, it could result in the development of only 25,000 square foot buildings within the M-Zone. Buildings of this size would be less desirable for most manufacturing operations. (2) Elimination: The alternative would be to eliminate the warehouse use in the M-Zone altogether. By eliminating the warehouse use as an acceptable use in the M—Zone it would insure that most new construction would be for industrial uses. The elimination of warehouses uses may require an amendment to our General Plan. The total elimination of warehouse uses in the M-Zone could have a substantial impact on 10 property values. Without warehouse use the property owner would lose a majority of the current real estate market because his property would be limited to almost exclusively industrial uses. Further, it would be very difficult for a property owner to re - market his building after a manufacturer moves out due to lack of a market. Potentially more buildings could become vacant. If the building were to remain unoccupied for more than one year, it would have to be brought up to current code requirements at substantial expense. Lastly, it is possible that manufacturers may have their leases revoked or not renewed by the property owner prior to such an ordinance taking effect in order for the owner to establish a grandfathered warehouse use. This could have the reverse effect of what the City is trying to accomplish. In response, the City could amortize the conversion of all existing buildings over a set time period. Given the stated reasons, it is recommended that the size of the warehouse limitation not be changed at this time. B . Fstabi_i-sh a Mi ni m»m —Lot i 7p - The City of Vernon's current Zoning Ordinance prohibits the construction of a warehouse in excess of 50,000 square feet in the M-Zone. The only exceptions to this rule are cold storage facilities and an accessory warehouse with a conditional use permit. Typically, most new developments have a floor to area ratio of 55 to 600k depending on the lot configuration. This ratio is driven by the number of truck and automobile parking and loading spaces. If parking was provided on the roof, or within a parking structure, the ratio would rise substantially. For a lot coverage ratio of 11 55% a 55,000 square foot building would require a 100,000 square foot lot or approximately 2.3 acres. A coverage ratio of 60t would require a 1.9 acre site. The City currently has 301 lots that are in excess of 2 acres, and 180 lots over 3 acres in size. See Appendix "2" for a list and a map showing all properties over 2 acres. One proposal is the adoption by the City of an amendment to the zoning ordinance that would restrict the subdivision or adjusting of Lot lines for all lots or merged lots 3.0 acres or greater. The proposal is to limit the subdivision of lots in excess of 3 acres so that no newly created lot will be less than 3 acres. The intent of this ordinance would be to preserve industrial sites. A merged lot is defined as lot's tied together by a recorded instrument. If a Developer were to construct a building to be used solely as a warehouse in the M-Zone on a 3.0 acre site he would be limited to a floor area to lot area ratio of 38t since the building would be limited to 50,000 square feet in size. If the lot is oddly configured this may be acceptable. However, if the lot were rectangular in shape the Developer could construct an' industrial building with a floor to area ratio of 55t or a 72,000 square foot structure on the site. This would clearly drive the Developer, due to economic constraints, to develop a building on this site for industrial purposes rather than for a warehouse type use. Typically in speculative construction the aim is to construct the maximum square footage of building on a lot. The price of the property is normally driven by the size and 12 driven by the size and functionality of the building. On the negative side, the prohibition of subdividing large parcels into lots less than three acres in size could shut out the small manufacturer from suitable sites. Most of the development in Vernon has been the redevelopment of large industrial sites. The small manufacturer will be excluded from these business parks. However, the vast majority of properties in Vernon are less than 3 acres in size. This equates to approximately 500 of the land. These smaller properties could be utilized by the small manufacturer, however these would be stand alone buildings and the lot sizes may not meet their exact need specifications. For example a small manufacturer may only need a 75,000 square foot lot but the only lot available is 100,000 square feet. Given current subdivision rules a developer would be able to subdivide a larger lot to meet the exact needs of the business. An alternative would be to allow only one lot of a subdivision of a property in excess of 3 acres to be less than 3 acres in size. This would give the developer much more flexibility and open the market to small manufacturers. The down side is that one lot of the subdivision could be used for warehousing. For example if there is a 5 acre lot under the previous proposal it could not be subdivided and a developer would have to find a single user who could use the entire site. The second proposal gives the developer more flexibility. He could subdivide the 5 acres into 3 and 2 acre sites, or 3.5 and 1.5 acre sites depending on his client's need. It should be 13 noted that most businesses do not want to be in the development business. They typically want to enter into an agreement with a development contractor who can deliver a building meeting their specifications. The more flexibility given to the developer the more likely he will meet his clients needs. Given these factors it is recommended that the City approve an ordinance establishing the lot size as follows: Single or merged Lots 3 acres or more in size may only have their boundaries adjusted or be subdivided so that only one lot is created less than 3 acres in size. All sites created shall be of sufficient size so that a building can be constructed on the site. All lots must have a minimum 150 foot frontage on a public street. The Subdivision Map Act provides that a local agency must limit its review and approval of a lot line adjustment "to a determination of whether the parcels resulting from the lot line adjustment will conform to local zoning and building ordinances". Further, a local agency shall not impose conditions or exactions on its approval of a lot line adjustment except to conform to local zoning and building ordinances, or except to facilitate the relocation of existing utilities, infrastructure or easements". The City currently has minimum lot sizes for slaughtering, rendering and residential uses. City staff believes that it would be appropriate to establish minimum lot sizes for all uses in order to encourage development in accordance with the General Plan and discourage the creation of smaller lots. It is recommended that a minimum lot size of 3/4 acre be established 14 for commercial and general office, and 1 acre for all other uses with exception of residential uses which already have minimum lot size requirements. Additionally it is recommended that each lot shall have a minimum lot frontage along a public street of 150 feet. City owned property should be exempted from the minimum lot size and frontage requirements. The creation of a minimum lot size of 1 acre for warehouse and industrial uses will easily accommodate the construction of a 20,000 square foot building on a square or rectangular site, while providing ample room for truck parking, loading and access requirements. Lots of smaller sizes become non-functional for proper site development since truck maneuvering will become increasingly difficult, requiring a disproportionate share of the lot to be utilized for truck maneuvering, eventually creating a situation where the only way to practically develop the site is to place the driveway directly in front of the loading docks, which encourages trucks to back into the docks from the street. Figure 1 shows a typical development of a one acre lot. Office and commercial uses do not have the same trucking requirements as industrial and warehouse uses. However, automobile parking needs are far greater on a square foot basis. The establishment of a minimum 3/4 acre parcel for these office and commercial uses will both accommodate the occasional need of large semi trucks and the parking needs of these types of uses while providing an appropriate size structure. The lot frontage requirements were driven by the need to provide appropriate onsite truck maneuvering. Figures 2 and 3 15 show typical site development patterns. In both cases, in order to provide proper driveway widths, maneuvering areas and staging areas, a 150 foot frontage is required. The City of Vernon currently has a floor to area ratio (FAR) of 2 times the buildable area of a lot for the M and M-2 Zones, and 4 times the buildable area of a lot in the CM Zone. In other words in the M Zone you can build a two story building over the entire lot. However in order to accommodate this ratio you would have to either provide parking on a separate lot, on the roof, subterranean or in a parking structure. In the past 10 years the parking and loading requirements have driven the amount of building constructed on a lot. We have had no parking structures constructed. one building was retrofitted to accommodate rooftop parking and two buildings provided a portion of their parking within subterranean structures. Several buildings provided parking on separate lots. This concept would create a low floor to area ratio (FAR). for warehouse uses and higher FAR ratios for industrial uses. For example the City could create a FAR for warehouse uses of '.40 and leave the existing FAR for industrial uses. Therefore, if you have a 100,000 square foot lot the maximum size warehouse that could be constructed would be 40,000 square feet. In contrast, under our current zoning regulations, if parking is provided on a site, a developer can expect to construct to a 55t FAR coverage. So for a 100,000 square foot lot you could construct a 55,000 square foot industrial facility. Given the M, option a developer most likely will construct a building that maximizes the building intensity. This would give him his highest profit. Therefore given the choice of being allowed to construct to a .4 FAR for a warehouse or a 2.0 for an industrial building, they are most likely to construct the building with the maximum square footage. The major problem with this concept is the fact that the FAR is usually based on the needs of the use. Typically a use that employs numerous people would have a lower FAR than a business that has few people working. Manufacturing uses have substantially higher parking needs. Industrial businesses often require that equipment be installed outside. A warehouse has few employees and therefore their parking requirements are less, nor do they have the need for outside equipment. Warehouse uses typically have higher truck parking needs. The excess outdoor space would tend to attract outdoor storage. Given these factors, by instituting a lower floor to area ratio for warehouse uses, the result would be contrary to typical planning strategies. Therefore the implementation of this policy could have potentially negative perceptions by the public. D. Prohibit Multi -Tenant Uses The City of Vernon currently allows a building to be utilized by more than one tenant. The uses can either be mixed such as a warehouse sharing a building with a manufacturer or the building could be used solely for one use. The zoning ordinance allows in the M-Zone, a maximum of 50,000 square feet of warehouse or wholesale use on a single lot. The concern is that 17 if the City is successful in having larger buildings constructed in the M-Zone, that 50,000 square feet of the building would immediately -be dedicated to a warehouse use. Therefore if we implement a minimum lot size of 3 acres the Developer could construct a building 72,000 square feet in size and turn around and lease 50,000 square feet to a warehouse use defeating our General Plan goal. The good news is a portion of the building would be dedicated to a manufacturing use. The bad news is that the majority of a building would be for a warehouse use. The dilemma is that most users of a large building cannot readily use the entire structure. They may lease a large building and sublease a portion until their growth can accommodate the remaining space. Often businesses are limited to a search of properties that are available. Sometimes the only structure that meets their needs is a smaller space within a larger building. If we were to eliminate multi -tenant buildings owner's would lose much of their flexibility resulting in lower lease rates and the possibility that it would take them in excess of one year to find a tenant. The property owner would then be further impacted by not only losing the lease income, but also having to bring the building up to code. It is recommended that this option not be considered at this time. E. Allow existing buildings used for warehouse purposes in excess of 75,000 square feet the ability to convert back and forth between warehouse and industrial uses The City of Vernon's Comprehensive Zoning Ordinance permits a warehouse and wholesale use up to 50,000 square feet in size 18 within the M-Zone. Any warehouse or wholesale use currently existing in excess of 50,000 square feet would be considered non- conforming. Section 26.4.6-1 of the Zoning Ordinance states that a non -conforming use may be continued providing that it shall not be expanded or extended into any other portion of the building. Section 26.4.6-3(d) states that the non -conforming building or use shall be completely removed or altered to structurally conform to the uses and development standards within forty years of January 1, 1989. Finally Section 26.4.6-8 states that a property in the M-Zone improved with a building area of more than 50,000 square feet but less than 75,000 may subsequently be utilized for either industrial or warehouse purposes until January 1, 2014. If on January 1, 2014 the property is used as a warehouse, then it may continue to be so utilized. If it is thereafter converted to an industrial use it may not be reconverted to warehouse use. Therefore a building less than 75,000 square feet can be utilized as either a manufacturing or warehousing facility until the year 2014. However, a building over 75,000 square feet does not have this luxury. If the building is currently utilized for an industrial use, then it must remain an industrial use. If the building is currently used for warehousing it may continue to be utilized as a warehouse use until the year 2029. If the warehouse use is converted to an industrial use prior to 2029 then it must remain an industrial use. Given these parameters, property owners have found that larger buildings are much easier to lease for warehouse purposes. 19 With this in mind they are very reluctant to lease their building to a manufacturer. This ultimately closes the market of large industrial type buildings to the manufacturing community. Realtors have stated that property owners refuse to lease their large buildings to manufacturers because of the limitation it places on the structure. City staff is aware of only one existing building that has been converted from a warehouse to manufacturing. There currently exist approximately 109 buildings in excess of 75,000 square feet within the City. See Appendix "3" for a list of the sites. The proposal is to allow buildings currently utilized for warehouses in excess of 75,600 square feet to have the ability to convert back and forth between manufacturing and warehousing until January 1, 2014. This would open the market of large buildings to manufacturing uses. The property owner would have more of a market to select from. Given the fact that manufacturers may have costs associated with moving equipment they typically will sign longer term leases giving the property owner financial stability. The City policy is advanced by having the opportunity of trying to attract and retain manufacturing uses by having more buildings available for that potential. If things remain status quo the property owner will continue to lease only to warehouse uses. Buildings owned by such businesses as Smart and Final, Jetro, Four Seasons, Ernest Paper, and Sears will continue to be utilized only as warehouses if they come on the market. It is the staffs recommendation that the Zoning Ordinance 20 be changed to allow buildings currently utilized for warehouse purposes to have the ability to convert between manufacturing and warehousing until January 1, 2014. Those buildings currently used for manufacturing will not be given this opportunity since they are presently conforming uses. II. ESTABLISH NEW ZONING DISTRICTS The City could develop new zoning districts. Within these districts development standardscould establish warehouse size limitations, new floor to area ratios or minimum lot sizes. The City has made a study to determine the location of large lots that currently exist within Vernon to determine if there is a concentration of these lots in one specific location within the City. Attached is Appendix "2" which is a list and aerial photo showing the location of all existing parcels in excess of 2 acres. The map clearly shows that these parcels are spread fairly evenly throughout the City and therefore no specific area could be targeted on lot size alone. The City could, however, target any area and develop zoning requirements that would preclude any use other than manufacturing. The most logical area to target would be those areas where redevelopment is most likely to occur. One location that could be considered for a special zone designation would be the property located between Alameda Street and Santa Fe Avenue south of 55th Street. This area contains the former Domtar site and U.S. Steel building. Another location that could be considered is the property just east of Seville Avenue west of Alcoa Avenue south of 50th Street and north of Slauson Avenue. 21 This section of the City would include the Alcoa, NI Industries, Sears and Owens -Brockway sites. See appendix "4" which is an aerial photo depicting these areas. This concept would have the same negative impacts as those previously discussed, just on a smaller scale. III. Create an Economic Disincentive for Warehouse and Transportation Related Uses Warehouses, truck terminals and intermodal facilities generate substantial numbers of trucks. The great volume of trucks has adversely impacted. the City's circulation system. Trucks often maneuver in the streets as they back up to onsite truck docks causing significant delays to the traveling public and adversely impact emergency response. Just as detrimental to the circulation system are the long Port Trains traveling to the intermodal facilities on the north side of the City. These trains must travel slow and often stop prior to entering the railroad yards causing significant delays on City streets. The City has enacted Zoning Policies that would require all truck maneuvering to be performed onsite. However the City has been forced to consider constructing expensive Public Works Projects in order to alleviate the substantial congestion caused by the slow moving trucks. The contemplated projects include the reconfiguration of the 710-Atlantic/Bandini Boulevard Interchange, Grade separations at Bandini Boulevard, District Boulevard and Slauson Avenue over Downey Road and the Union Pacific Railroad, the Alameda Corridor, the construction of a new Interchange at Route 710 and Slauson, the widening of Soto Street from Bandini Boulevard to Olympic Boulevard and improvements to 22 26th Street so that capacity on this roadway can be increased. Not only do the trucks cause substantial congestion, they are the primary cause of pavement failure. Roadways are designed based on the number of repetitive truck loads. Automobiles have no impact and are not considered in pavement thickness design. The more trucks, the thicker the pavement must be designed. One overloaded truck could potentially cause the pavement to prematurely fail. Given the number of trucks that travel on City streets the pavement must be resurfaced at an accelerated pace when compared to typical arterials and local streets of neighboring communities. If the City fails to resurface the street in a timely manner full reconstruction could be required. Lastly, trucks are involved in approximately.40 percent of all vehicular accidents within the City. Therefore the industries causing the truck movements should pay their fair share for road improvements and other City services. Typically warehouses, truck terminals and intermodal facilities contribute very little money to the General Fund. Since the City of Vernon is an industrial community it receives very little gas tax and other state funding earmarked for roadways because the funds are distributed based on population. Therefore the vast majority of roadway improvements within the City are paid for out of the City's General Fund. The General Fund must also pay for Police and Fire Department services. Each local community must decide where every dollar must be spent. Typically the decision of whether the infrastructure of the City should be maintained, or police 23 and fire protection be preserved is a difficult one. An alternative would be to supplement the City Is General Fund with a tax or impact fee on those creating the truck movements causing damage to the public streets and adding to the congestion on our circulation system. The City recently approved a parcel tax of 1 cent per square foot on properties used for trucking and warehousing activities. It appears that the City could achieve two goals with one mechanism. As stated previously the City goal established in the General Plan is to maintain and attract industrial uses. If the tax or impact fee were high enough it would cause warehouses and transportation related uses to reconsider staying or moving into Vernon. If truck intense businesses don't move into -Vernon then the funds generated by that business are not needed because the circulation and roadway surface would not suffer the abuse caused by their vehicles. Last Year, the City council adopted Ordinance No. 1057, which among other things established a special parcel tax on warehouses, truck terminals, freight terminals and other distribution facilities. The ordinance was approved by the voters of the City on April 14, 1999. The City Council then passed a resolution setting the tax at the maximum rate allowed by the ordinance — $1.00 per 100 square feet of land (approximately $436.00 per acre). Proceeds of this tax are earmarked for construction, improvement and maintenance of streets, bridges and other public rights -of -way, including acquisition of land. 24 However, the small tax currently in effect is not substantial enough to deter the trucking uses from entering the City. The average lease rate for a Class A warehouse building in Vernon is approximately $0.40 per square foot per month. Therefore the lease for a 50,000 square foot warehouse per year is $240,000.00. A class B building would be approximately 3/4 of this, while a class C building would be one half. In comparison given a lot coverage of 55t the current annual parcel tax for the same size building is $909.09. While the parcel tax will collect over $400,000.00 for the City annually, it is far from covering the City's total public works and capital improvements budget. The parcel tax is less than 0.4t of the annual cost of the revenue gained on the property. In order to deter a warehouse use or transportation related use the annual tax would have to be in the range of 8t of the lease rate. At this cost, the mentioned uses may consider relocating to other sites away from the Los Angeles urban core. The City tax would offset any added transportation costs. This balancing effort would cause the warehouse and trucking uses to consider alternative sites. If a warehouse decided that Vernon was still the prime location for" their business, the tax would offset the detrimental effects that their trucks would cause in our community. The funds received could be used for much needed roadway and circulation improvements. An 8t tax of the lease rate would result in a tax. of approximately $.211 per square foot per year or $9,191.00 per acre per year. This would be 21 times the current rate. The property tax for that above -mentioned 50,000 square foot building 25 would be $19,200.00 per year. The City Attorney has looked at the legal question of raising the tax to the level of $20.00 per 100 square feet. Despite the size of the increase, the City Attorney has concluded that the increase would be legally justifiable both as a means of raising additional revenue for street construction and maintenance and as a means of discouraging non -industrial uses. A tax increase would require voter approval at a general or special election. Under the state Elections Code, a special election on a measure submitted to the voters by a legislative body can be scheduled between 88 and 103 days after the call for the election. Staff suggests bringing the parcel tax issue back to the Council for a progress report on August 1, 1999, and that August 17, 1999 be targeted as the date for adoption of an ordinance increasing the tax and the necessary resolutions for scheduling the election. This would enable the Council to schedule a special election between November 13 and November 28, 1999, if the.Council so chooses. The City of Vernon's zoning ordinance currently restricts the conversions of buildings over 75,000 square feet from being converted from manufacturing to warehouse. As mentioned previously, property owners are reluctant to lease their buildings that are in excess of 75,000 square feet which are currently warehouse to a manufacturing use. If the tax is implemented the City should consider removing the restriction of conversion of large manufacturing buildings to warehouse uses. Given this opportunity, the property owners may be more willing 26 to accept the tax. If this option is not provided the City will be giving them the impression that they are being trapped into converting their building into manufacturing use in perpetuity. Staff recommends that the maximum rate of the parcel tax on warehouse and transportation related uses be increased to $20.00 per 100 square feet of gross area of land. If the City council concurs, staff should be directed to return to the Council in sixty days with the necessary ordinance and a resolution calling for an -election. III. REDEVELOPMENT PROGRAMS The Vernon Redevelopment Agency was formed in 1991. In 1998 additional area was added. Approximately two thirds of privately owned property in the City is within the Redevelopment Area. The vast majority of property that has not been included in the redevelopment area consists of new construction, the Los Angeles River and railroad property. The Redevelopment Agency, to date, has not been very active. The primary reason is lack of funds. The Agency was formed in 1991. At that time real estate prices reached their peak. Since the agency's formation the economy has been mired in a recessionary period. The City and County have been in a long battle over establishing the base year property value. However, the economy recently began to rebound and the Agency has begun to receive a limited amount of funds from its share of the tax increment. At this time it is difficult to determine whether the Redevelopment Agency will accrue substantial funds to 27 actively provide business assistance programs to the community. If substantial tax increment is available, the Agency could consider paying some of the development costs or providing GAP financing in order to assist a developer in attracting industrial uses that the City has targeted as being desirable. The Redevelopment Agency could also purchase small contiguous, blighted lots. These lots could then be merged to a size desirable for industrial uses. This concept was one of the goals of the Redevelopment Plan. However, lack of tax increment has limited the agencies ability to meet this goal. The Agency proposes a land assembly program for the purpose of assembling parcels of property into sites suitable for industrial type development. The property would.then be transferred to the private sector for development. The Agency's efforts in assembling land would be applied in selective cases. The Agency could assist in the selective assembly of parcels of land through negotiated purchase or acquisition. The objective of the program would be centered on the elimination of existing blighting conditions, such as parcels suffering from a lack of proper utilization, and may also assist owners in complying with the lot coverage and circulation ordinance anticipated to be in effect in the year 2009. Land Assembly would likely take place in response to property owner or developer initiated efforts, in which public participation is required to assemble property needed for the expansion of existing uses or for the creation of a site capable of development for new uses. The Agency may also choose to KU participate in the acquisition of property which an existing owner may desire to sell, or to acquire certain parcels for infrastructure or public facilities purposes. Relocation assistance and payments would be required for properties acquired by the Agency which contain business and residential occupants. A redevelopment agency is required by law to provide relocation assistance to safeguard businesses and residents. The land assembly program may also include site preparation activities such as demolition and assistance for environmental remediation. ataffreport.submor 29 SITE UEVELOPEMENT OF A ONE ACRE LOT 50.0' , i PIY F DC/ 30 HANDICAP 120.7' le I13 REQUIRED AUTOMOBILE PARKING SPACES HANDICAP ASSUMING 10% OFFICE SPACE 28 REQUIRED TRUCK LOADING SPACES 3 REQUIRED TRUCK PARKING SPACES 3 36.0' 24 65.0' AREA=25,093 FT2 w S � a o 149.7' 23 � z W 19.0' 40.0' 65.0' 84.7' �LG f MANEUVERING I LOADING STAGING TYP. AREA AREA AREA FIGURE 1 P L A N SCALE 1 "-30' FRONTAGE REQUIREMENTS 150.0' FIGURE 2 P L A N SCAL1 1 "=30' FRONTAGE REQUIREMENTS 19' 40.0' 65.0' 26.0' PARKING MIN LOADING STAGING STAHL TYP. AREA, AREA FIGURE 3 P L A N SCALE 1 "=30' tn r. V4 0 r. 0 0 -ri -ri -rl •ri -ri -r-i -H "A -ri :���NN4)4)4)��a)a) NNE 4)4)4)a)0 a)4)4)04)4)4)4)0) m Ln (a 4J 4J M M m dJ JJ dJ LT) CO M 0) 4J W M (a L11 JJ JJ M W M 4J m M :3 :3 U U :3 :3 a U U U 0 0 :1 :3 U :j :3 :j : U U :j :j :j U :j :j OOnf (d0000mfdo0 00(d 0000m(d 000000000 4.044 k44.0.0.0444444.4.0 k..0444 .0.0..0Al4444 .�.�.�4a.04444 Wo:j4)0000000a)a)a 000 4)a)4)4):j :j a)Na)0a)a)a)Na) Okm04jommwmwwwm4jjmmw rtk k k 0 0 �rtrtaf ��rtrt 33x0x333zxx33033333 333�33333 iJ riONOlnmvif000ODOO r-100 Ln NM01-1r OMN�Od+lp[�N W LnNriONt,NN000M001�00 NMLn0CDM 0 N m t.0HHM0 d c ind�NNNN000Nomt-00 N w w 0r1M Omm ri0rlr- Hw 00kOONOt000NONtnLn c d;- c OmkOr- Co r( ODtONmOtOkO( tk V] ci+ Ln ri ri r-I H ri r-i rl [r H H ri Ln .4t ri N N v O dr N ri m N ri ri m x va)a)a)a)(u Dr. a): 0_0 �a0i H rr :3 JJ a) (L) aJ .iJ J-J A a) 4) 00 >~ !~ 0 0 a) > a) a) a) m > > s~ w m �� m >� H >0a)mNwa)a)cu()0)4):344 4) 0 >4>>1>1>.>4 y4J o�>c"nc"nw > o o a)� or. `" y p �3333333 rX4 r0 :~ TO rd res rd 0 4 0 0 rt� rw G 0 •ri b1 to to b1 to t31 u1 000000 k s�� 0 sew $i>k�i����� (drtom0000ko00cocor-000 OrtmN m 0 0000000 4j o � v 5 s~ cr M O > > 4J d� > ri H >• is U 0 S i U � r. tO >4 E H r-i r-i r-i H ri r-i 5C A4 m (d H id H (d Id (d (d 0 r-I (d (d • Ln o - O (d (d (d (d (d (d ad o w��nww�www�wwcnwwwu4 wa�� OmLnODmmLfrir-i000OLntOLnO L,OODLnH0 MOHMOMMMM b O N rh i- tO Ln r- to %o m Ln to Ln oD w M Ln to N i- dr 0 0 Ln O Q0 GO m m m M d� ill 'd riMMNtntn111LnwmONmmMr Mw Lnm nOLnLn mmmmmmma0 t A'i LflLftd'MdAd'd�d�NNNNNNtnNN vv olNdrLn Ng4LnLnL1)U1MWW O -X >04 P 4J a) O b) 0 to (dU040 U O (1 H H a) , J p0, 0 m h' (n '—I a) -ri -rl o U) •• (d m m 3.1 0 w U m dJ Q U (d Qa) 0 (d p, •ri ro -ri (d � t)) A i) dJ O k l✓ 4J O > 0 .Q 4) 0 ro (d "1 O H as 0 k 0 -r-I k � -ri • • -ri JJ JJ W a) Q1 0 )-( -ri 04.) O O U (d ca •• S I V4 U) -ri JJ E4 A aJ U U o , a) (d a) U 0 dJ 4J M :j M k t71 U ro .Q 4J a) U m JJ 01 a) (d -r) r-I 4,8 U of L8 LT) O U V4 V. r--1 ro U k o r. N $4 Q (d i~ m 40 -ri H O a) H -ri H •rl (d r-I -ri k 0 -ri �i 10 -ri O i~ S4 b) a) 4J U 0 4J (d t)I rd k 0- .0 m 0 4.8a) a) (d a) U (d ul a , to () 41 cn4)x04Jk100 4J:J-ri 04 NxkM 0 M0�i N(dE ul :J O O W (d JJ V. O )•i 0) a) 0 41 U -ri (d F-( H a) "1 a) U f~ m LT) a) ( 2I U -r l U ri, :j 4) (d -r-I r-I (d -ri si a) (d (d rQ a) N to r-1 rd 1J rl -rI 0 O Q+ 0 rO 3 4) 4-)U U> r-I 0 k a) a 3 3 w 0 (d 0 (d H 4 (d U N tr O •ri N( 0 J, 44 P 0 -r( 4.)a 4J0 J aJ o X it .0 k w dJ U) m 0 rn f4 E Z 0 OH O (d w r-I k O m (d (d 0 O k 0 3 El -ri x 0 (d o ty 4) "1 -ri "1 0 '0 X a) a am 0 -ri 0 0 0 -ri >, > o (d 0 (d i~ 0 ai V4 ems: (d P (d f14 a) a (d ri M - O o N o N M >r V4 ri -ri U) 0 (d 0 a .IJ 4) tit -ri r-I 0 -ri -ri N 04 • 1.J M - rl i~ 0 (d i~ 0 rd m rl k 0 W 4) 1-1 rl "1 0 U 3 .Q k R.' r-I L 0 U) X (d 0 H O 4J 4J (d X N k a°co7hw°c�nOh�alc�7aiuc�c�7 uxh6 (d k 4) .0HAcna­1 l° mmmmmrnmONmmmmmmmmm 000000 T-4HHr-lririHHH a) CDWWMWmwcom 0 W M W W M W W mmmmmm mmmmmmmmm A HHNmmmmMlnmmmmm00 H HLntOtDOri HNMMMMMM('M riHH HH m m m to to to t71 t)1 C31 til t7t t3l t n fi Mod) m 1-) 4-) m m JJ 4J .(J 1J m JJ 4J m 4-) m CO m dJ m m JJ m U U:j :j U U U v:j U U 0 U 0 0 0 U 0 00 0 000000(d000000000000 O(d 0 4 W 33X33333x3xX33333330333 01 01 � to 0() a)a)a)��a) a)m�m � m to m m m JJ JJ m m m 41 m 41 0 0 0 0 0(d it 0 0 0(d 0 �4 4 4 4 J-1 4 W W .z: �I .0 .� W .i; ) I W WOW 033 333333033330 rd MOB'"�N0�100L�*-11�0100000cJ+00OaD0 00o OOOOL�OOpCpOpp� OOOOONO drOD000001000NOMOpOM O OtO(n OOdrLnawm0.44H 0a0) Oil(1N1�N0�-itnOd�t�Q1NLf1aONt�N 0w 0ri0 OcHN mmNONd+lOhlpNNOL-[, OIMMLf1 C dr dr001Li d drl000Lf1O00drOMN IOr' Cl000 40O0pMN1nco MU1N0 r-I tp ri r-I ri N d' dr dr ri .0 W ('o d+ r1 r-I N r-I r-I W 1144 r-I N r-I d' dW r-I N M ri N r1 10 a) rt 0 a) a) a) 4J a) a) 4J > m a) >r >r >1 >r >r �4 >r >r >r m .'fir SO( a) 4 a) 4J 0 4J044 000000000>04Jk 43 0M(f0k 3s3333FC3v�4-) 0W4j 0 .L, 04JrdrU CO b�t3lt5Lb�t3�t�mmm0 0(d 0 �U4J � m4� as V. i-I $i }a S-i ).( S ( k is k O k b ,4) Si ri3 w -ri > to r-I r ���m�4)Na)001 k 004J4J A A A O .A E Ln yr= w 0 4.I (d O dr -,I -r( r-♦ r-I H r-i H r-I (d H (d (d 4J m E 4J 0 :3 �X�Z��Z�COZ4ww�wr°nAa°cnwww M Ln dr t0 r-i M O O 01 O t0 N rl Lf 1 O M w m t0 [, N w t0 �t0t� ri MMtf)00101rlMNl000INNrIMOII!r1 M t0 to W tO tf) t0 tf) to t0 M to in N N sir dr u) dr •dr M dr m m > a) > 014 )Or-io0 >m >:jO0wO>w(da)rt FC3 0 �C� r-I y4>t��4 �3 0 01 0 a) m 4J 4 to 4J to 0A)I ,qI � aJ 0000)4cA14 �A`J---rlwnW p O f0�"3 0 O.Q 04 r�tl�ld 0 •Ln0rUiP r0-IN(HtSON v)2w iliwwLnr44 >f]gw'Jxwx ( drt-0 avm( iaHHr-00(D01M H WONcq L-rIIU m m a m m m a (n v MOdr OOIptOMOOpOOMM000r-I MkDm Md+dr(7LnLnMdrMNlOMtO m m 0 O 00 33 H }4 P4 .H J) >4 -ri -ri a) s~ (d m m -ri k r-I k U 4-) -ri bl rCl a) rz3k H0Um-H00000 0 0ru 0 (dam 93 m 4) k mm H O k • ri O 0 a) J-I 4J-ri k to (d -ri r-i 0 0 U a) I~ -ri 0 -H 0 CO 0 0 4J 0 0 0 (1 rd (d tr) O m 4-) U 4J U a) a) 4JW -ri -ri (d 4J •r1 r (d O J.J 9 a (d o > • U) Ut7i Hrrii 4r-) 044a40 CO k NUAMNHdJoNa�rd 9 U (d (d -ri td -ri a) rd .X 4-) V4 U (d 4J 'a H r-I a) (d 0 >~ 4J 4J )1 •r1 4-J 4.8 CS 4.) H k >r-ri cS -r4 (L) t!1 ( ,L'i 0 4J 'd -ri 4J 0 -ri I~ 93 A m aJ 9 0 (d k 4J m W:E rd U A U (d 0 Cd ri--Hu°c°�wu >1>�HUZ aa)) aro� i m� 5F4f-4 v U -ri 0 r-I 0 r-I ri3 A A 0 JJ x� JJ (d 0 k 0 -ri ( Uri - 4 �i r-I (d r-i >1 �, O a) L1) x O U � 04 0 a4 a) U 0 -ri W mvma)aJOMx- aU.0 .u�tvva�-ri ���E-4kk 0AAa)t4rU �3HhaHaaH�aaav)>A w°uZwh"E-1 V)a ri r-i ri H ri r-( r-I r-I ri ri r-I ri r-I ri rl H ri ri H r-I H r-I r-I r-I r-{ H ON ON Ol Ol 01 Ol 01 al Ol 01 Ol al Ol Ol Ol Ol mOl Ol Ol Ol Ol 0) Ol 01 Ol \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \\\ \\ \\\ \ \\ \\ \ \ \ \ \\ MMMMCr1MMMM(VI (VI [4drtptp0000aH V-4HCl NN r-I Hr-I Hr-I Hr-I HH Hrl 4)) Ad Sir O H A 0 � rl 1J m (d w' i; 0 m )-i -•-I ild A m I~ aJ H U q :1 aJ s~ 4-1 k 0 (d (d 4 H J a) 0) -Y C -tin k -r. uv) 0(d�UU U UQ1 r-Iao4i a) m H 0 m H -r-1 O -ri 3 4 in (d 0 m -ri tr a) r-I 4-) A -ri W -ri H 4J O 0 •r1 r-i • (d O CO H $4 trL-VIMZ� N�f�Uc!] m -°� �°Q-H 4)�a -Hi 3-ri k 0p4 m\ro hp�AU0Cl)M 40 DE4> tVNNNNN(V NNNNNN Ol ON a1 O1 0) 0) 01 Ol Ol 01 Ol 01% 01, \ \\\ \ \ \ \ \\ \ \\ r-I r-I rlNNNN(nmMMMM to bl bl 0 01 M b) to b) to fi is m 0 0 >! 11 0 t. 0 0 1~ rl -r1 .rl .r.( -r1 -r1 ri -r-f -ri m m 0 0 m��� 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 m 0 m m 0 0 0 0� m 0 0 o � 0 m m m 1.J 4J CO m .1J .LJ 4J .1.1 m .m sJ .LJ 4J m m m m m m V m m m .LJ m m m 4J .LJ m in 00 Do 0 U U U U 0 0 U U U 0 0:j :j 0 :j U 00 0 U :j :j 0 U U 33 00 (a00 0(d(d(d(d00(d (d(d00000 0 (d00 0(d 000(d (130 .� . k W W W W 4 4 W W W .fir' .L"i .fir" .�"i .rr S4 .o 444,0 S4 W 4 .0000 4.0s40 00~ 4�i� 330333033333333 333333303 333033 3333 33 dJ O H aww o000D0000DLl0 NOOOU1NH00 000001ri OlOO1 ri 000 W amww00000OOOOMO HtOOMLnmwoo Ln000Lnr- OMMO ON 0010ODen000O0O0lnLnO\00 OOHON W lOdrOto DOOM HtDN 00 Ln Ln OM tl4 ONOlyMv VONt-�O1t000'0,M tOdr00tD01tDNO1 1000%D04ll1 [N0ON0 tOH +- IcMHM-:rMH W WHNMN (AHN V HHNN NNM 144 MN riM tOH N > > 43 � 4.)4J V aJ 4J> > 4-3 m 0 m 0 tJ aJ .� y 4-) 4J 4J4-)4-)m m m 0 rmt a'Ji m 0 0 ,y m 0 0 0 m 0 µ 0 m 0 0 m:j :j m m mm04)m04) 04$44) (D;j4)> 0�J ?� 4) W4141mO m0 0 :3 -4 t�J a�J 1�i (d rt f+ m. iJ > �+ H id m m Ld m k k 0 0 k k S4 M V A .LJ V 4V 4.�UJUJU] 0J.)1J4J>ra mr>r 4J a) 41 3 m4J3 4-34Jm mV4J .1.J 0 0 Cl1 > m m m >~ rn cn cn 0 sJ k m m cn k k m cn CO 4J 0 e Or Je v vi c e �' 'ri 'ri e e �" c N U) U 4J -r1 0) 4J 4J a r r- t a r o 4J S I -ri CO) r, p u 41 co to o r. .0 -rl 4J -r-I Q CO m 0 N N [- lD (d W 0 V t- m t- (d [� m Ei [� [� N N m k is (d 43 d� :3 -.r Ln Ln N N o (d (d N f''.r -r1 M :j M O M 41 A 11 O (dA M M 0 0 Ln Ln W J, 4J0 04 (d UEE p� (d U 11CAm4.)EH 4J 4J m43 to Uc- m r-1 • • • • • r-1 0 0 - m $s • H • r-I (d (d -r1 0 0 (d 0 O • -H co -r-1 ri (d WcnwwwWWaw>Nwco wwcncnww wA-IfA �Cx 64 NPLnt000Ln0O0OLna%LnLnOD tnOO1LnO1O1MtOtl LnoLnHOID LnMtO Ln g4Ln 4y OtDNLn0MQ1Cgwko V g4aLnm t,O0r11,01Nd0N H d+t-LnLnON 144H1,00 %DN R7 tDP)kONM('r1L,OoLnLnvc) 4:r ' cq NHMInO1LnOD1-0 MMODODNN Ht,(nW 1-0 d�rq-W NNNmv144drNm 44(14 r) NtONMLnvm-ot0 NNmmC14N Nd+Nv mm U >r 0 (d to H 3 � m •• P4 >1 -0 U 0 0 >1 4J .,I ri V4 0 r. -ri H A 0 m U JJ rLJ 3a •d 04 �i H H td (d fy" 0 $4 U' O E - m 00 4-1 m W ro E m (d H H 04U 0 ri W 0 04 H 43 .�; .�.' in U (d aJ S-1 !~ 0 O H U U M M H 'Jr U r-1 0 • U ri U • 4J 0 0 U -r1 k P (d r-1 u m o 0 i s U U tr m 0 a m -ri �i 0 to U ra 00 k -ri 04 tr U-ri 3 3r-1 0 0 •• > H k :J4J (d m 0 W 0 3 3 :J U p,0 td U 4J JJ (d (d cgs H 4.) -r1 (d 0 0 to (d t7) m -ri U 'f. H U ,�." 11 JJ 4-7 0 ii 0 H 14 0 .t-1 M 0 X 4 z U >.r" 0 0 O .L.J 0 td 00 (d H CO .L.) 1J 04 (d -ri -ri 0 0 0. X U ro U H} 1 H U H m. r-1 m -rl -r1 ',Z t� 0 0+n-ri ki.l004r-1mmkm ts�,' O0 0 A�: tilmmWPkk •mE( HM +J 0 $4 W W •ri 0 (d :J 0 (d W H U m .0 0 ri 0 (d a W m t3 U sr J, k E-+ 0 k H m N �' • Zj -ri 4.3 r-i H (d O m U - r4 o m RS i'r m LS 0 ''-1 (d "A it fi r>r m m o H U 0 3.1 m m Lh -rl U CS L28 ,ta" :j -ri (d .0 ill H-r1 w04Jtd.1JH0?C 04k 004J0k mom UAmk U] 4J rtJ m m i-1 S~ K N �i E-+ 0 (d 0 0 0 H p m 0 (d 0 4z -r1 ro Ul m 0 0 -rl 0 m v m(d>,>40O(Is H0(dm E+ y a1-rI 04 m >0rt>4>1 O >to m- v �iUHAAaJm 0HrA4r-1(d % A Rr .LJmOPVAA 0cA0(d (dO 0 (D -ri cn -'i 4-) (d 04 DIM m (d s~ o m co w >4 V.>i $4 04 p k U r I 0 .0 :J m 4-)k 0 m ro rid .44 a.J U (d �s w (d a, (d tr-ri -riAUry'FZ'3U0Uµr0oPmm Pmr-ib1r0U(d(da WU 0>rya' R :jx �aX-HHah0aaz4COZE0M En XX0MaX nz Hmgax-Az NNNNNNNNNNNNNNN ('r1M(MMM('M(' mm dr drdrdrdrdr UILnLnLn %DtO 91 O101 mO101O101mOl O1O101mOlO1 01Ol01O1O1C1MOl01 O1 Ol a%O1OlO1 O1O101O1 m O1 43 \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\ \\\\\\\\\ \ \\\\\ \\\\ \\ d�drtOt�l�L�000DODm0HNNN HHHMMcMtoLnO1 H N to In00 OOOON NN Q H H H H H H H H H H �N m NNNNUi mmmmm 4) 4) Ea N m � NNNtUNON0a) ��� m «� :3 :3::J 0 :3 0 .um v 0 �l .tJ U mmmmmmmaJm 41 41 41 0 0 0:j 0 0 0 v 0 U v U 00000 00 44 (u0 0 444 $4 4 �4 m 44 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 m 0 (d(d(d � .L" .� Jr. 44 44 44 44 .ri .0 33333 33 33030 3333333300333 4; 4 co000001 lOotnOw Hap NO N0w00 (3100100 d" H Oap(,4;:p0i,apOMwtnOOtn MMr-IE`•ap L-01 OONMto 0 NMll1t001apOlOUl0000w tnOMa10l11oOl--%Ndiainso m I�HOa1M HU)MNM W t` NN NN HC 0� d+W N 01UlNN (YMtnNr_n M NHWtOdvMd' H MH H 0 4J 4J 4-1 N N O r-i ri 0 4J -LJ 0 r-i r-1 O 4J ri > O O 4J 4J 4-1 4J Q1 N N �NNNC: 00 H N N U 0:300� ri � :j :j H 41 :j 4 N N N N N OO:UO k 4)4J4J04)a) JS-JisN NCO M0k$40 0 M900f+W fd4-1 O U� M cci3 > 4 U Cq 4-1 J.J N CO > CA CA 4-) 4J Cn rO 4-) N O JJ 4J J.J 4.) 4J Cn41 m 0w k }acncoco w u ,°, a�i {' 4' -ri U UV) RC -rl -ri a,, u U -ri U U U U -ri 1J (d J.J 4J u > 4J r-i 4 iA CO 4 u u 10mrn 0. d.J V 44 du 0 0 k lv.," 4-1 k44wd1 0 JJ -ri N V rl 44 -ri k k44k N1.1r- wrr- 4-)41 -ri W V M •ri M O O N M m 4) 4)H H(d 0 tti .14 "A- �•r cd •�iO-rik -O0 Cnwww> >A Aawwav a AAawAamwwcncnwww N 1`wHtno mr-r•iMN wtn Hr a% LnoHUl rnwwVr, ri 0 ririMotnMOwOoltnt,00 di t,Mr-I0v M('MNNM t-tn U1tnLnHfM w w0mac14m0mvooL-tnM %DWLn M W(F%kOMt-000Dw[h N clv d vv(ntn cr v-44 44N-wd+tnMNMMNNN U s~ . t..i al HNC v 0 .0 H 41 U 0 -ri -ri Ha W x . $4 C!) 4J H H U� d) 4-)0 U) \zf � U� U) (d 00 �m V4mU >, - m m i I tlf (d N 010 'ij > 0 �1 H tU U N -rl ill m �' Qa 0 U 0 •r I ,J 0) 0) s~ s~ C: ri O -ri 0 0 v +J a is • H (d v -ri to ?1 040 rn 4J v m (d$4 rt 0 E u �+ 4J V) E+ m N m 0 0 -ri U N 4) E A q 41 C4 .se 'o 0 0 m N• a 04 r-i 0 -ri : H m r-i U) p HA m Li E 43 0 Tf i~ E ro ctl 0 -el m r-1 k (d m i•i (d 'ii rd ro �4 is (d O N rd rd 0 0 4J W -rA O U k (d V. O ' 3 id 43 17 -ri 'd id ad a 0000 rowauu rZ400 «s (d : U)NX :J ari 34J .0 �H0-r1 '�� a) V. 1.1044 H rd x w 4 0 m 0 rs v a0w0 H k k r-aMcallowA 0 0 r-i 0 ri m -H- >1 (d -ri rd ?+ v (d (6 44 N ..Xvy 00m>-riEHmcn v 0 (d b) 0 -ri 4Jb4(d(d44 ri }4 4 0 w k c� CO k 0 • w .x � a 4) 3 f i a) aJ TJ -rl .��>,ra0m S 1 .� X 4) >~' (d • 3 tv 0k t 00 0 CO4-)m A 4) � a aJ (d A 0.4" m r-i as r-i i~ 14 N U U oaaCQE--1 rt H A cn co O >~ :j -ri m m .sG '0 > N m - F] 0 c°�x>ha v Ul i�CQo+3HhH0w�h n 4i w t0 w w 110 MM0101p1 r- t` t` 0143101 r- Mo1Q1M(1 ap ap aD ap ap o ap w aD aD o cw ap aD Ol01d1010)0la%0101d1Q1ma1Cif (d co r-IH NU)U1 inwL-HN r-irir-iriwa0o0oONNNNN Q Hri HH HHririHHH sg i'S� W ®rm. vl Ny r r��E r� z 3z tt � y�9f Lo${ �z • �2 �{tea....,, ?. Rio ?R %w fx ; 2 b y� P{ 5 a w3 ?try .w � y C CY„� C Eu a S � r APPENDIX "2 ii PARCELS WITH 2 OR MORE ACRES WITHIN THE CITY OF VERNON Parcel Number Address Acres 6302-001-030 2626 26th Street 4.41 + 6302-001-042 2720 26TH Street 2.49 + 6302-002-031 2727 37th Street 15.00 6302-002-020 2169 37th Street 7.67 + 6302-002-029 2600 28th Street 3.07 + 6302-002-030 2600 28th Street 9.25 + 6302-003-019 2600 26th Street 8.67 + 6302-006-021 2275 37th Street 3.24 + 6302-006-023 2825 Santa Fe Avenue 2.12 + 6302-006-012 2929 Santa Fe Avenue 2.12 + 6302-007-023 2801, 2803, 2807 and 2809 Santa Fe Avenue 3.84 + 6302-007-022 2727 Santa Fe Avenue 2.47 + 6302-009-015 2622 Alameda Avenue 1855 27th Street 3.45 + 6302-009-031 2011, 2025 and 2031 27th Street 3.06 + 6302-009-028 1820, 1840, 1842 and 1844 27th Street 2.10 + 1 6302-009-029 2036, 2038 and 2040 27th Street 2.09 + 6302-009-035 2750 27th Street 2.14 + 6302-009-028 1862 27th Street 2.81 + 6302-009-028 2036, 2038 and 2040 27th Street 2.37 + 6302-009-030 2828 Alameda Street 5.10 + 6302-010-013 2910 Ross Street 4.39 + 6302-010-014 2121 37th Street 2.18 + 6302-010-002 2891, 2895, 2901, 3.10 ± 2911 Saco 6302-011-011 2910 Alameda Street 2030 Ross Street 3.57 + 6302-015-030 3851 Santa Fe Avenue 2.50 + 6302-016-028 2230 Santa Fe Avenue 9.27 + 6302-016-026 2100 38th Street 8.27 + 6302-017-045 4200 Alameda Street 2.50 + 6302-017-901 4305 Santa Fe Avenue 8.16 + 6302-017-025 2301 Vernon Avenue 6.04 + 6302-017-026 2263 Vernon Avenue 4.47 + 6302-017-024 2041 & 2047 Vernon Ave. 6.07 + 6302-017-043 1931, 2001, 2035, 3.67 ± Vernon Ave 6302-017-022 1913 & 1925 Vernon Ave. 6.00 + -2- 6302-017-030 2050 38th Street 4.06 + 6302-020-038 2522 & 2602 38th Street 5.20 + 6302-020-039 2610, 2640 and 2660 38th Street 3.68 + 6302-020-038 2528 & 2608 38th Street 6.20 + 6302-020-040 3751 & 3775 38th Street 6.80 + 6302-020-023 **** 2.29 + 6302-020-041 2727 Vernon Avenue 6.98 + 6302-020-024 2601 Vernon Avenue 2.00 + 6302-020-026 2501 & 2503.Vernon Ave. 3.51 + 6302-020-021 2677 Vernon Avenue 2.29 + 6302-020-042 2801 Vernon Avenue 2.50 + 6302-020-047 3870 Seville Ave 2.38 + 6302-020-056 Various 7.07 + 6302-020-057 2730 & 2750 37th Street 2.38 + 6303-001-007 2850, 2860, 2890 and 2900 Sierra Pine 3.06 + 6303-001-009 3430 26th Street 5.11 + 6303-001-004 3492 26th Street 3.48 + 6303-001-003 3540 26th Street 2.81 + 6303-001-008 Various - Bandini 9.98 + 6303-001-605 3305 Bandini Blvd 7.32 + 6303-001-001 3333 Bandini Blvd 10.76 + -3- 6303-002-025 3220 26th Street 14.50 + 6303-002-026 3250, 3252 and 3254 26th Street 5.48 + 6303-002-021 3260 thru 3278 10.66 + 26th Street 6303-002-011 3001 Sierra Pine Avenue 2.58 + 6303-002-011 3001 Sierra Pine Avenue 2.19 + 6303-002-014 Various - Bandini Blvd. 2.69 + 6303-002-020 2939 Bandini Boulevard 3.67 + 6303-002-014 Various - Bandini Blvd. 4.23 + 6303-002-013 3109 & 3111 Bandini Blvd. 2.00 + 6303-003-015 2600 Soto Street 2.31 + 6303-003-010 2858 26th Street 2.52 + 6303-004-901 2800 Soto Street 2.61 + 6303-004-037 2820 Soto Street 2.12 + 6303-005-030 Farmer John - Vernon Ave. 2.78 + 6303-005-030 Farmer.John - Vernon Ave. 2.86 + 6303-005-030 3049 Vernon Avenue 4.53 + 6303-005-027 3095 Vernon Avenue 5.00 + 6303-005-019 - 2.50 + 6303-005-020 3163 Vernon Avenue 2.34 + 6303-005-022 3207 Vernon Avenue 2.46 + 6303-008-014 **** 2.78 + Se 6303-010-037 4301 Downey Road 2.44 ± 6303-010-902 4355 Downey Road 3.50 ± 6303-011-047 **** 3.55 + 6303-011-047 3420 Vernon Avenue 2.36 + 6303-011-048 44th Street 3.57 + 6303-012-041 3055 44th Street 2.69 + 6303-013-042 2809 & 2825 44th Street 2.98 + 6303-013-055 3200 Vernon Avenue 2.00 + 6303-014-016 2801 & 2815 46th Street 3.80 + 6303-014-012 2957 & 2959 46th Street 3.97 + 6303-015-001 3060 44th Street 2.28 + 6303-015-002 3041 & 3051 46th Street 2.28 + 6303-016-005 3100 44th Street 3.84 + 6303-016-004 3250 & 3280 44th Street 2.90 + 6303-016-006 4510 Boyle 3.95 + 6303-019-015 4633 Downey 4.54 ± 6303-019-014 3385 Leonis Blvd 2.18 + 6303-020-010 4700 Boyle 6.06 ± 6303-020-010 4615 Alcoa 6.06 + 6303-021-005 4601 Boyle 2.50 + 6303-021-007 3501 Leonis 2.00 + 6303-022-003 2812 & 2834 46th Street 2.83 + -5- 6303-023-008 4900 Soto 3.96 + 6303-024-012 2929 50th Street 2.34 + 6303-024-020 4901 Boyle 2.56 ± 6303-024-004 4925 Boyle 2.00 + 6303-025-009 4800 Boyle 2.01 + 6303-025-013 4900 Boyle 4.00 + 6303-025-021 4926 Boyle 2.00 ± 6303-025-022 4817 Alcoa 3.13 + 6303-026-001 3359, 3379, 3385 and 3399 50th Street 4.68 + 6303-027-900 Various 6.97 + 6303-027-900 Various 2.80 + 6303-027-003 3300 50th Street 2.36 + 6303-027-002 3301 Fruitland 2.31 + 6303-028-011 5055 Alcoa 2.68 + 6303-028-015 5008 Boyle, 4.14 + 6303-028-013 3211, 3221,& 3223 Fruitland 5125 Alcoa 4.38 + 6303-029-001 2910 50th Street 4.50 + 6303-029-001 2910 50th Street 4.10 + 6303-029-001 2901 Fruitland 4.00 + 6303-029-001 2901 Fruitland 4.40 + 6304-001-021 4368, 4382, 4400 and -6- 4404 Bandini 2.44 + 6304-001-020 4408 Bandini 4.10 + 6304-001-018 4380 Ayers 4.10 ± 6304-001-016 4398 Ayers* 2.97 + 6304-001-015 4440 Ayers 7.27 + 6304-001-023 2800 Ayers 4.09 ± 6304-001-020 2900 Ayers 5.70 ± 6304-002-008 4310 Bandini 4.26 + 6304-002-008 4310 Bandini 4.26 + 6304-003-001 4150, 4160 and 4170 Bandini 5.00 + 6304-003-001 Various 7.00 + 6304-003-008 4120 Bandini 3.10 + 6304-004-015 4240 Bandini 8.00 + 6304-004-004 2901 Sunol 4.08 + 6304-011-005 5000 District 2.00 + 6304-012-013 5100 District 2.60 + 6304-013-002 5010 Loma Vista 2.47 + 6304-013-025 5035 Gifford 2.18 + 6304-017-011 Various 50th Street 2.54 + 6304-018-018 **** 2.15 + 6304-018-023 **** 2.17 + -7- 6304-020-024 **** 2.41 + 6304-020-033 **** 2.60 + 6304-021-013 4265 Charter• 2.00 + 6304-021-021 4295 Charter 2.13 + 6304-021-039 4320 Maywood 2.83 ± 6304-021-043 4215 Exchange 3.50 ± 6304-021-045 4321 Exchange 2.47 ± 6304-021-055 4353 Exchange 4:09 ± 6304-021-052 4383 Exchange 2.22 + 6304-021-806 4433 Exchange 2.33 ± 6304-022-042 4423 District 2.00 + 6304-022-059 4575 Loma Vista .2.37 + 6304-023-010 4309 & 4325 Fruitland 6.00 + 6304-028-015 4224 District 8.21 + 6304-028-015 4955 Maywood 6.23 ± 6304-030-001 4500 Bandini 13.02 + 6304-030-002 4500 Bandini 2.45 + 6308-001-039 2721 45th Street 3.27 + 6308-002-016 4620 Seville 2.04 + 6308-002-012 2757 Leonis 2.86 + 6308-002-009 2727 Leonis 2.87 + 6308-002-900 2715 50' Street 5.84 + -8- 6308-002-008 5001 Soto 5.10 + 6308-003-801 2657 Fruitland 2.43 t 6308-003-802 2657 Fruitland 4.62 + 6308-003-022 4900 Pacific 4.50 + 6308-004-013 2665 Leonis 4.58 + 6308-005-900 4462 Pacific 4.80 + 6308-005-012 4480 Pacific 3.40 + 6308-005-011 2651 45th Street 5.20 + 6308-005-010 2640 45th Street 5.08 + 6308-005-009 4553 Seville 2.10 + 6308=007-018 4400 Pacific 5.04 + 6308-007-019 4460 Pacific 6.12 + 6308-007-008 4600 Pacific 2.04 + 6308-0.07-012 4700 Santa Fe Avenue 2.92 + 6308-011-009 4950 Santa Fe Avenue 3.10 + 6308-011-011 2465 Fruitland 3.48 + 6308-012-022 2300 Vernon 3.90 + 6308-012-022 2300 Vernon 8.00 + 6308-012-016 4481 Santa Fe Avenue 3.80 + 6308-013-044 4510 Alameda 3.31 + 6308-014-032 1946 46th Street 5.39 + 6308-014-038 4768 Alameda 4.29 + -9- 6308-014-025 Various 48" Street 4.32 + 6308-014-027 2311 48th Street 6.73 + 6308-014-029 2345 48th Street 2.00 + 6308-014-031 4601 Santa Fe Avenue 4.05 + 6308-015-063 4890 Alameda 2.96'+ 6308-015-034 2034 Alameda 2.71 + 6308-015-043 4815 Santa Fe Avenue 6.40 + 6308-015-072 4890 Alameda 4.11 + 6308-015-044 4871 Santa Fe Avenue_ 10.59 + 6308-015-031 2000, 2050 and 2100 49th Street 7.92 + 6308-015-020 2242, 2254 and 2288 49th Street 4.69 + 6308-016-010 2322, 2360, 2368 and 2380 515t Street 3.82 + 6308-017-031 Demo 6308-017-009 2200 55th Street 4.02 + 6308-017-030 5525 Santa Fe Avenue 4.50 + 6308-017-031 Demo 6308-017-031 Demo 2.40 + 6308-017-015 2001 Santa Fe Avenue 2.40 + 6308-017-015 2001 Santa Fe Avenue 2.20 + 6308-018-019 5819 2nd Street 7.00 + -10- 6308-019-017 2300 57th Street 5.91 + 6309-001-001 5190 Santa Fe Avenue 2.07 + 6309-026-013 2700 Fruitland 2.07 + 6309-026-034 2750 Fruitland 2.04 + 6309-026-012 2700 Fruitland 9.46 + 6309-026-028 2726 Fruitland 2.44 + 6309-026-033 5225 Soto 7.66 + 6309-026-032 5401 Soto 4.85 + 6309-026-019 5525 Soto 18.02 + 6309-026-019 2737 54th Street 2.20 + 6310-001-010 2.91 + 6310-002-028 5333 Downey 2.25 ± 6310-002-029 Various Downey 7.40 ± 6310-002-032 5501 Downey 4.59 ± 6310-002-031 5601 Downey 3.31 ± 6310-004-014 5899 Downey 2.53 ± 6310-004-008 3365 Slauson 4.00 + 6310-005-009 3.62 + 6310-005-010 2.06 + 6310-006-014 5705 Alcoa 5.17 + 6310-006-013 3251 Slauson 3.43 + 6310-007-006 3165 Slauson 2.22 + -11- 6310-007-003 5800 Boyle 5.03 ± 6310-007-008 5750 Boyle 3.25 + 6310-008-003 5401 Alcoa 10.30 + 6310-008-003 5401 Alcoa 10.30 + 6310-008-003 5401 Alcoa 10.30 + 6310-008-003 5401 Alcoa 10.30 + 6310-009-014 2900 Fruitland 8.46 + 6310-009-010 2825 54th Street 4.35 + 6310-009-015 4.02 + 6310-009-015 4.02 + 6310-009-019 5215 Boyle 4.84 ± 6310-009-019 5215 Boyle 4.84 ± 6310-009-019 5215 Boyle 4.84 + 6310-009-019 5215 Boyle 4.84 6310-010-007 Various 54th Street 5.00 + 6310-011-007 5675 Boyle 3.63 + 6310-011-007 5803 Boyle 3.30 ± 6310-014-001 5600 Bicket 2.82 + 6310-015-021 5500 Soto 2.55 + 6310-027-037 Various Slauson 2.70 + 6310-027-037 6152 Boyle 4.80 ± 6310-027-037 6190 & 6174 Boyle 5.80 -12- 6310-027-022 6250 Boyle 7.20 ± 6310-027-023 3200 & 3212 Slauson 6.18 + 6310-027-026 5991 Alcoa 2.11 + 6310-027-027 6077 Alcoa 11.25 + 6310-027-028 5920 Aloca 2.85 + 6310-027-039 5970 Alcoa 2.28 + 6310-027-030 6062 Alcoa 3.61 + 6310-027-031 6140 & 6118 Alcoa 4.75 + 6310-027-036 6180 Alcoa 2.28 + 6310-027-047 3338 Slauson 2.00 + 6310-027-048 3390 Slauson 2.71 + 6310-027-049 5990 Malburg 2.02 ± 6310-027-053 6200 Malburg 2.17 ± 6314-021-007 4925 & 4935 52nd Street 2.32 + 6314-022-008 2.80 + 6332-003-006 3030 Atlantic Blvd 3.00 + 6332-003-006 3030 Atlantic Blvd 2.50 + 6332-003-006 3030 Atlantic Blvd 7.00 + 5192-019-809 2.98 + 5192-029-014 3650 26tn Street 2.31 + 5192-029-018 3663 Bandini 6.97 + 5192-029-806 3677 Bandini 10.66 + -13- 5192-029-810 3691 Bandini 2.69 + 5192-029-809 3691 Bandini 3.00 + 5192-029-807 3691 Bandini 2.60 + 5192-029-004 Various 26th Street 3.64 + 5192-029-803 3768 26th Street 3.50 + 5192-029-804 **** Bandini 6.21 + 5192-030-001 3840 26th Street 7.00 + 5192-030-009 **** Bandini 4.51 + 5243-022-010 3900 26th Street 5.41 + 5243-022-009 3-900 26th Street 2.01 + 5243-017-010 4560 26TH Street 3.89 + 5243-017-009 4560 26th Street 6.66 + 5243-017-012 4505 Bandini 3.72 + 5243-017-011 4651 Bandini 3.31 + 5243-018-010 4444 26th Street 7.27 + 5243-018-016 4440 26th Street 3.40 + 5243-018-014 4333 Bandini 4.73 + 5243-018-012 4425 Bandini 3.86 + 5243-018-011 **** Bandini 2.83 + 5243-019-010 4330 26th Street 2.45 + 5243-019-009 4366 26th Street 3.89 + 5243-020-010 4300 26th Street 4.10 + -14- 5243-020-010 4300' 26th Street 2.34 + 5243-020-012 4214 26th Street 6.45 + 5243-020-013 4319 Bandini 5.71 + 5243-020-022 2701 Bandini 2.12 + 5243-020-019 4199 Bandini 2.10 + 5243-020-018 4199 Bandini 2.40 + 5243-020-014 4151 Bandini 2.15 + 5243-021-021 4100 26th Street 2.40 + 5243-021-021 4100 26th Street 2.40 + 5169-031-013 2835 26th Street 4.08 + 5169-032-008 3113 26th Street 4.10 + 5169-032-015 3137 26th Street 2.05 + 5169-033-014 3211 26th Street 4.24 + 5169-034-801 3305 26th Street 2.53 + 5169-034-010 3365 26th Street 2.48 + Non usable property includes streets, Public Utility right-of-way including. railroad property and the Los Angeles River right-of-way. parcels. acreage -15- P. 6 m i .. - _. �, , R — .� >r kk s r ;'� t !'i Hi F x iqt s''3 E kS re �� '.Za 3i11 - 3, "w* r �, 'P' t a laic ' +4 r w+ ,ro, fi .3r,& p i; K ' *-_.�,,+ - . I I I�, �� � , m . ! g - , .A,!??.M - a W. � I "., '', —�F' ; . i : . 9 .,.,o �,.--,� — � ,me 4, �� - .1 5 A , �- - I ! - � - � , �- I - � � .1, ,� - I � --l'--, a `J 101 u 3 � - I I ", I�j �� — , . Ar- -, ft 1] -®e �1- - @ +j ` f y a `� {9F^'.17 i'C7' _ - :jib- _ - f.-. y ^r+�.. s�iE' s3"�.$•' 'T' t ,154"' ` S — Y i i, ?1 1: s tw �' if I g5�'"`-,>< J y`+i 1 ..'" .. 4 .. I 1Altl 't :"'. d am �tw'I'll 51: p,. - 5- _ - ? t.g{ _ if g, tf zz^ yr .xa.._�3 ,t_ i -. � E>� sT ` , �!I r ,� �F \�TiII, ¢ d �, $ -4j4 I � - f } ' - t g �.'° .'� i f4 - �4P9v :. `fro + ; } I - - h ., .�V a� ' i v.9 , W } a � '" r 3 W. a v A i -' � tFx :. , + L 3 #i ;'ems '�i I� 3T'N \5 w' ....a#k "' ;$ `' � ,@'� �_) %� , �' '9` ,+w; k "i. - f i 3iIII a•, �i. :" ^if F!' a ` '- - �.. - r- -lFt� 3 !ft 1� gz �,' fi �� ®; �a a .a I41'NN ® g Yiii41 '� ro: if .rir r- . �..'3 li �a .� _ . Y;P' f-'-tom ' v` , n ;Ifii 11 ,a l f -� S z �. .fie"+ tr�•��` i iVv" ? ,, t. `; #�. f=ey Ih3S - _ ,a �-a TF--lei ,, ,.: a. ;,{� f c ` `S @,'. _� t 3 r--yzi 11- ,tr+t I fr ."s 14 e�. •Iti.:. k �` �„ - - -, +` '. _ . w 11 Car 9 t_ ++ „' IJI.I,: I{ s s x a �-+' s f s �i 7 '�^F, v,yi �`a int+SR.' 7 l.. a s-<j9 xx, a�� f; �"' c vas is a. a vtt E'� + t '^ - -� ' x ., #..`1 ,' €ems.. I���>•n +��sa � ' �:, % ilp O � I , 0 , It, A ", . -,!L �l ��{ijj cdw - s.,�..'. is ` 1� ' ' r 'r: - zr : r '' ,_- .a . s i 7, i � 9# i iZ, UTy ''�` . l i5 €3i j r £ FKidi4t8 i O 1+ t a i i -' `; ,,+s `'�`iz' -x x F..�s, - 3 . ,�: a a , t1 s ,. t ,_ 1 +'Y &w� qq.} '3N"{' a Y i34 ! „rim E '. mt. — I LI 0 - :-- !. - ��,�� ��--i — , -1. M77 :'�1L 4 �, y r ` 1.Yt fey oaf �;:: f .;T# i 5 ��,--`' .,-&�-'i K K. -- �' I, + » + t - ice x "f' 1` - . @ -� - ,5 ., 1 � - 'G-.r%_I y` n . - , - I - — - . -- - - - "I ,� k x'�_ " ., li I � ��igly'lf , I � �,-. ` .- ,Q , ,,,I, . I " I . , , I z Jr. I'�, I -O`'' III F i . * ti if 1 �� t r .i - - H "; ­i, * - � I , --� . p , I , �,. 1. _ __ s'LtQ�l — --, - ---l- I � I- I I , ` R , '- ,� �� — - .a xk - a '' t a e ki ,yy`, i11 h l3 _` - ;_ ti'pp@�5§2 cP�5� Li Y S b -'� :.-t'�5d1. *t' T 6 �2] `...: /h - m -gg t f q i A I lr"�s2 ,.11 �- C•xk°"t &'�% �c1.= ire �a a.4 „ M ' ' v �> r rT' "'j-i.. �,�--- € . 1 F ^n"xr k E1 8- - ,- ,t + t i.,Y 9 1. ID t ip P' E Jam- 4 as , as ..i, 'ro a 3 tl �.c +'-' , f A ' -, t , r ` 14 ssa M r . 1 t ! : ,a 3 - - G i : +a ,� � � . It! 61 f t E P" , $1 i ; x, r q .. + &',•. g 5 � �` < m - m , , i t ti i, f s r St +i; F 7+ M ? "�.6�i +=+ z .i � ,1 ) r—I , _t,Fd )1` �f E C1' �T{ - :�' '.t�� ,ads *-- ' f i€ a Y + - � �'a . :: R t+? re ro i -' a f li ,i "T, 4� k s t r5 € >f a .ex ,'s D-zi € aYp _Ll+ 5+ + *. -. F ,? ft -JF k � � J , 'Pf Tti t o r a 4 n _ � I-n a E tits` a.. I.5f '1 f -, 3, $ e f` �I� -�I, I -N-1..�� I1,II- €F € ; f f } f - t t" C,.� .&h "� "V +0�� 3 " a l e y s% -.. tea, l r c j /� w `� l _ , f a f gyp{ `r� . - -.r , eI fit+� # 3 1�-7 n�, i.y� t i T. ��"� tt IGf I !ate"$, 4_ I .w+' t F, a'ta !' 1 P "} 1�, J / _ n .x t LF ` li �� I �>�71�J L ;f Fr.r / , �.�' f yl ' £ � V Fy+ e R/ ffy. di k9 y Sc p � . � �g1' qa i F f T y '.� i .JJ' a� �n , W "A 1etr+tisi.g �'071 a , c 1 11 } ! N r, .*lI �- �`I, i;V1�1 Ol Y +V �41kt=. ' hljt ..:.� , € h 1 - I t" ! ` I 3 F a P I L 'fin , t 14` ti ;iir , s -�€d: 1 t i, F -p. 4 j \ v f r f } ,Af *R's s: D P a 2{ �.' ikk. ' / � 4 - 1, fit :l If '� D bai V! •,C s i! !t! l . a flr.i i yr. r i ,�- : v? s #i `: ry \ t' + ' ! -dk Ar„ `Jai#. 1 `. r ', ' h 4 t +� t ir{ '' w , L* t�L:' $ >-. Exhibit "3" Building In Excess of 7500 Square Feet In Size CUSTOMER NAME SERVICE ADDRESS SIC SQUARE CODE FEET CLOUGHERTY PACKING CO 3049 E VERNON AVE 1 404,00 SEARS LOGISTICAL SERVICES INC 5525 S SOTO ST �•� WILLIA14S WAREHOUSE K B MANAGEMENT CO 1925 E VERNON AVE 4225 352,400 KAL KAN FOODS INC 4815/4871 SANTA FE AVE 3316-3376 E 44TN ST 341,450 OWENS ILLINOIS INC I PEARLMAN, 2900 FRUITLAND AVE 328168 310:750 DON PEST INC 5819 2N0 ST 297,9006023 SLAUSON GIST CNTR LTD ALCOA AVE 6100 S BOYLE AVE �� RELIANCE STEEL & ALUMINUM CO 2500 E 26TH ST Z/5'000 BYRON JACKSON PUMP LASKEY 2300 E VERNON AVE 274,975 2 26,068 06 WEIL 11 OWENS ILLINOIS INC 1 2025 E 55TH ST 2628 , SOUTHLAND BOX CO 2923 FRUITLAND AVE 4955 MAYWOOD AVE 2,0 OWENS ILLINOIS INC I 5137 BOYLE AVE 2645 224,400 5353 DOWNEY ASSOCIATES 5353-5401 DOWNEY Rp 222,900 PEP BOYS JETRO 2640E 45TN ST 219,100 214,500 CASH & CARRY OWENS 2300/2330 E 57rH ST 213,175 ILLINOIS INC I PABCO PAPER 282UMO E 50TO ST. 204,200 CORE MARK DISTRIBUTORS INC C BLVD 2311 E 4460 PACIFIC ST 196,500 MOBIL OIL CORD 2619 E 37TH ST 193,150 PACKAGING ADVANTAGE CORP 46M DOWNEY RD 190,000 UNIVERSAL WAREHOUSES ERNEST 3751 SEVILLE AVE 5199 186,328 182,575 PAPER PRODUCTS INC SLAUSON 2727 E VERNON AVE 171,750 DIST CNTR LTD U 6174-6190 S BOYLE AVE 169,000 S GROWERS COLD STORAGE INC CALIFORNIA 2045 E VERNON AVE 167.600 WAREHOUSE JENSEN 4455 FRUITLAND AVE 164,950 INC L A DYE & PRINT WORKS INC 1946/1948 E 46TH ST 2131 E 52ND ST 3964 162,750 JERRY LEIGH OF CALIF INC LASKEY 3113 E 26TH ST 2861 5137 159,000 158,255 VEIL II MR REALTY COMPANY 1901 - 2023 E 55TH ST 158,050 RED CHAMBER CO 1931-2037 E VERNON AVE 4510 S ALA MEOA ST 155,500 SOTO INDUSTRIAL DEVELOPMENT 5400 S SOTO ST 151,400 ANGELUS SANITARY CAN CO 4900 PACIFIC BLVD 1".186 CONTAINER CORP OF AMERICA 2001 E 57TH ST 2631 142,900 141,800 CATELLUS DEVELOPMENT CORP 4507 NAYWOOO AVE 140,000 U S ALUMINUM UNITED PARCEL SERVICE 3663 BANDINI BLVD 1791 139,750 PAUL DAVRIL INC 3333 DOWNEY RO 5401 S SOTO ST 3561 138,900 CONTAINER CORP OF AMERICA 2200 E 55TH ST 131,000 INTERNATIONAL BAKING 5200 S ALAMEDA ST 130,750 t29,725 CONCORD ENTERPRISES INC PJK 2957 E 46TN ST 129,375 INC ACME TRADING CORP 5175 S SOTO ST 2036E 27rH ST 128, STANDARD PAPER BOX CORP 2301 E VERNON AVE 5199 128,42525 MT VERNON INDUSTRIAL LLC 3033-3063 BANOINI BLVD 128,100 127,300 CONCORD ENTERPRISES INC 2801 E 46TH ST 4225 122,625 U S GROWERS COLD STORAGE INC 3141 E 44TH ST 122,300 CENTRAL FURNITURE TISSURAMA INDUSTRIES INC 2263 E VERNON AVE 122,225 EVERGREEN SCIENTIFIC 3001 SIERRA PINE AVE 2254 E 49TH S7 2621 121,043 MT VERNON INDUSTRIAL LLC HANNIBAL 3001-3031 SANDINI BLVD 120,600 1 INDUSTRIES INC 3851 SANTA FE AVE ,0 118,450 CUSTOMER NAME SERVICE ADDRESS Sic SQUARE CODE FEET NORTON PACKAGING INC ORVAL KENT-FOOD CO KAL KAN FOODS INC HANNIBAL INDUSTRIES INC FLEETWOOD CONTAINER/DISP JAMES STREET FASHIONS PENNZOIL PRMUCTS CO WHEN, JERRY ANGELUS SANITARY CAN CO GAUTIER LAND CO KNITEX INC CAL -WIRE STANDING SANDBERG FURNITURE KIM, MICHAEL GENERAL MILLS INC FIESTA CONCESSIONS CORP U S CONTAINER CORP UNICAL INTL, DBA RELIANCE STEEL & AUXINUM CO CONSOLIDATED METAL & SUPPLY 26TH ST INDUSTRIAL PARK FOUR SEASONS GEN MERCHANDISE KAREN KANE COMPANY MOROWITZ, RALPH TRANSAMERICA TRAILER SERVICE TISSURAMA INDUSTRIES INC MAAS NANSEN STEEL CORP IMPRESSIONS P Y T-SHIRT U S CONTAINER CORP PACKERS INVESTMENTS L A DYE & PRINT WORKS INC L A DYE & PRINT WORKS INC 7-UP BOTTLING CO BASKIN ROBBINS USA CO IVY HILL PACKAGING PACIFIC COLD STORAGE INC GREENLAND INDUSTRIES INC PACIFIC COAST CHEMICAL CATELLUS DEVELOPMENT CORP SANDBERG FURNITURE RELIANCE STEEL CO OVERHILL FARMS JFC INTERNATIONAL INC MUTUAL WHSLE LIQUOR INC SLAUSON DIST CNTR LTD PRUDENTIAL INSURANCE FILTROL CORP VERNON WAREHOUSE ELCO HILLCREST CATELLUS DEVELOPMENT CORP CHUA & SONS CO INC ACADEMY TENT AND CANVAS INC PACIFIC COLD STORAGE INC 5800 S BOYLE AVE 5001 S SOTO ST 3250 E 44TH ST 3837 SANTA FE AVE 2721 E 45TH ST 6062 ALCOA AVE 3430 E 26TH ST 2550 S SOTO ST 5050 PACIFIC BLVD 2800-2840 s ALAMEDA sT 3155 BANDiHi BLVD 3200 E SUWSON AVE 5705 ALCOA AVE 2803 SANTA FE AVE 4309 FRUITLAND AVE 2812/2834 E 46TH ST 4950 SANTA FE AVE 2608 E 37TH ST 2541 E 26TH ST 4600 SANTA FE AVE 3700 E 26TO ST 2801 E VERNON AVE 2275 E 37M sT 3193/3201 BANDINI BL 2600 S SOTO ST 2850-2900 SIERRA PINE AVE 2435 E 37TN ST 5500 S BOYLE AVE 2126 E 52ND ST 2465 FRUITLAND AVE 4215 EXCHANGE AVE 2021 E 52ND ST 5132 S ALAMEDA sT 3250 E 26TN sT 2529 E 37TN ST 4700 SANTA FE AVE 2809 E 44TH ST 2301/2303 E 55TH ST 5100 DISTRICT BLVD 4553/45V MAYWOOD AVE 3251 E SLAUSON AVE 2537/25S1 E 27TH ST 3055 E "TN ST 4353 EXCHANGE AVE 4510 S BOYLE AVE 6000 S BOYLE AVE 3260 E 26TH ST 3250 E WISHINGTON BLVD 2050 E 38TH ST 4355 FRUITLAND AVE 4551/4567 LOMA VISTA AVE 3300 E 5OTN ST 5035 GIFFORD AVE 2851 E 44TH ST 3079 2653 4225 3542 3312 4225 3412 4213 3462 5131 4225 2011 5161 2512 2819 3999 2819 116,775 115,400 113,973 113,900 112,800 112,575 112,400 110,000 108,673 106,500 106,500 104,680 104,1SO 103,650 102,675 102,000 101,673 100.000 99,550 98,888 97,500 97,500 96,812 96,800 96,600 94,350 93,S75 93,487 91,575 91,125 91,020 90,900 90,900 90,000 89,380 87,225 85,744 $4,750 84,025 84,000 83,678 83,625 83,600 83,360 82,200 82,200 81,320 81,260 81,200 79,200 77,900 76,836 76,500 75,469 raliv �� .arr' .ak�C Nt� , er ' 45 ilk RW r b ' e ' i _ .. h � ,,..,..�.•.•s} x tea.: <�. '<WW ,, kl •11�1� �PM#i Ey k fr, Y ` � ' �� ;^ i 1 tt..� � � � � �,�� , „a.. • �s"�„�.'.. � `P q-:-, t aN<tmga � a, 1 q;` � f6�lf� 3 p 4y �._< a .. -.- I � •r ..... �..:«...q .�. �ti,.v �T..n2.Y 4a.�.,,....... - •<.. _ �.. -. �.� LDS..-> ,. ,.. ..:� 4 '�.:• P 'a5inna�. ca^� � i ' If t`� -t •P, ^ .. a -" �.� � p � � 3 ]. a y, x¢ �5 3 p Y g.L s a ram. "* � • .5 '� c'�.- �' � • �4 ... ' � �r , �. ... �`.s� q ' � Nr � N� � '"mot`, - 1 ``'^'.' � • � � � �._�. �, `� � �� � r' TV a�l z �I VII F i t i % . - -„ ar4 lot��� r _ '14 z Alf, E gg ; ,K _a- —,, -- x ��.'4' . � _ U xi: a '�', �enxc�=„ — . .Y�_ AFFIDAVIT OF POSTING STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES ) ss CITY OF VERNON ) I, Gloria, J. Orosco, Chief Deputy City Clerk of the City of Vernon, do hereby certify that on the 18th day of August, 1999, I did have posted three (3) copies of: Ordinance No. 1076 One in each of the following places, to wit: at the northwest corner of 38th Street and Santa Fe Avenue; the northeast corner of Leonis Blvd., and Pacific Blvd.; and on the bulletin board in the Lobby of the City Hall of the City of Vernon, located at 4305 Santa Fe Avenue, all in said City, there being no newspaper of general circulation printed and published in the,�iC i ty of Vernon .,_, 91bria J . OroKco Chief Deputy C' y Clerk Date: Subscribed and sworn to before me this Sg{ of �}(�uc s� 1999 2� ► �- C Notary Public `is$ and for the County of Los Angeles, State of California ift SHARON L. JOHNSON Commission # 1225459� Notary Public - California Los Angeles County I&MV Comm. EppIres Jun 21, 2003 CERTIFICATE STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES) ss CITY OF VERNON ) I, Gloria J. Orosco, Chief Deputy City Clerk of the City of Vernon, County of Los Angeles, State of California, do hereby certify that the attached is a true and correct copy of: ORDINANCE NO. 1076 - An Ordinance of the City Council of the City of Vernon Amending Section 5.45 of Article IV of Chapter 5 of the Code of the City of Vernon, California, 1959, Regarding a Special Tax on Parcels of Real Property Used or Designed for Use as a Warehouse, Truck Terminal, Freight Terminal, a Railroad Facility or Other Distribution Facility; Making Provisions for the Assessment, Levy and Collection of Said Tax; Establishing a Date for an Election to be Held to Approve the Levy of Said Special Taxes; and Declaring that Said Ordinance Shall Take Effect Immediately The original of same is on file in the office of the City Clerk of the City of Vernon, said offices being in the City of Vernon, County of Los Angeles, State of California. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto set my hand and affixed the Official Seal of the City of Vernon, County of Los Angeles, State of California, on this 18th day of August, 1999. loria J. OroVyr Chief Deputy Clerk AFFIDAVIT OF POSTING STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES ) ss CITY OF VERNON ) I, Gloria, J. Orosco, Chief Deputy City Clerk of the City of Vernon, do hereby certify that on the 29TH day of July, 1999, I did have posted three (3) copies of: A Notice of Public Hearing to be held August 17, 1999 to consider a proposed ordinance for the increase of a special tax on parcels of real property used or designed for use as a warehouse, truck terminal, freight terminal, or other distribution facility. One in each of the following places, to wit: at the northwest corner of 38th Street and Santa Fe Avenue; the northeast corner of Leonis Blvd., and Pacific Blvd.; and on the bulletin board in the Lobby of the City Hall of the City of Vernon, located at 4305 Santa Fe Avenue, all in said City, there being no newspaper of general circulation printed and published in the City of Verno Subscribed and sworn to before oria J. Or co me this of Gtt 1999 Chief Deput City Clerk Date: gel Notary Public n and for the County of Los Angeles, State of California •`r Tw / U. S. GROWERS COLD STORAGE, INC. 3141 EAST 44th STREET • LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA 90058 TELEPHONE (323) 583-3163 • FAX (323) 583-2542 City of Vernon Attn City Clerk 4305 Santa Fe Ave Vernon Ca 90058 April 19, 2013 RE: Rewording of Ordinance 1076/ Section5.45 to 5.47 RECEIVED APR 2 3 2013 CITY CLERK'S OFFICE Dear Mr. City Clerk (the following letter was sent to each council member and the City Administrator), I am writing to further clarify my objection to the proposed "clarification" that Kevin Wilson proposed at the Vernon City Council meeting on April 16, 2013. Ordinance 1076 (Special Parcel Tax) was put in place to address the burden that was placed on Vernon's infrastructure owing to the increase in number of "dry goods" warehouses. Vernon had long done its best to attract large consumers of electricity, but as the world market has changed, there are fewer and fewer manufacturers that wish to be located in California. The population, however, has continued to increase so distribution facilities have become more prevalent. These distribution facilities (dry goods warehouses) do not consume a significant amount of electricity; they cause or create significant traffic and wear and tear on the City's services. In 1999, in order to better distribute the expense of running the City, Ordinance #1057 was amended to Ordinance #1076; which increased the Special Parcel Tax from .01/sgft of land to .20/sgft of land. The following excerpt is from the ordinance: Whereas, the small maximum parcel tax which is currently authorized and which is currently in effect is not substantial enough to deter trucking uses from entering the City or to offset the detrimental effects that these businesses have on the City. While, at first glance, the proposed rewording of Section 5.45 might seem to be quite logical it is an oversimplification of what Ordinance #1076 was intended to accomplish. The examples given, in the staff report, while technically accurate, are not wholly indicative of the situation, current or potential. The Staff report paints a scenario where, with the current wording of the ordinance, a facility with both manufacturing and dry goods storage could be unfairly charged the Special Parcel Tax, on the entire parcel The flip side of this scenario is that, with the current wording of the ordinance, a manufacturing facility, which is contributing to the City with large utility payments but has some dry storage space, is exempt from the Special Parcel Tax; as was the intent of the original ordinance. U.S. GROWERS COLD STORAGE, INC. -* For Example with the defined apportionment plan, as proposed: Company "A" pays $2,000,000./year in electric bills but has 20,000 square feet of dry storage space on the same parcel that consumes all of the electricity. They will have to pay the Special Parcel Tax. Company `B" (on the same size parcel as Company A) manufacturers a product that requires very little electricity but their process takes up considerable space and causes considerable truck traffic; they will be exempt from paying the Special Parcel Tax. The apportionment process that is proposed seeks to answer these questions but it does so in a way that is neither fair, just nor inline with the original intent of Ordinance #1076. The complication arises when the Staff begins to quantify or apportion the use of the facility in order to impose the Special Parcel Tax. Nearly all manufacturing facilities have space set aside for storage. How much of that storage should be exempt from the Special Tax? With the proposed apportionment language in place you will be, in effect, requiring City Staff to assess each business needs for ancillary storage. That would, in turn force businesses to justify their requirements and business model to City Staff in an effort to avoid paying the tax. The end result would be a series of ad hoc taxing decisions with the obvious specter of abuse of discretion and inequitable treatment of similarly situated parcels. Do you really want Vernon to go down this road of inevitable litigation? Furthermore, with the new Utility User Tax that has recently passed, Company "A" will be paying an additional $20,000. on top of the Special Parcel Tax that they would be required to pay for the percentage of building that was used for dry storage. In effect, double taxing the type of company that has supported Vernon for so many years. In closing, I would urge you to reconsider the original intent of Ordinance 1076 and rework the new sections to comply with that intent. . J. Corselli Growers Cold Storage Inc.